Susan's Place Logo
Main Menu

Doubts

Started by Mavka, November 05, 2025, 08:58:21 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Mavka

Hello everybody! This is my first time here, I found this site somewhere in the dead of night... honestly, I won't go far.
 
I am aware of myself as a girl, even though I was born in a man's body, now I have strong doubts about myself, I am not sure if this is true, I am afraid that I have invented dysphoria for myself, which makes me very worried and suffer, it is difficult for me to understand myself, and I cannot seek professional help because I live in Russia, and here LGBT is recognized as an extremist organization, and any crossings for transgender people have been banned, any LGBT movement is being persecuted, and I can't turn to anyone but my girlfriend, not even my parents....

Although it's difficult, I think I understood myself a little... This afternoon I decided to use makeup for the first time, yes, not so much, but when I stood in front of the mirror and drew these arrows, I felt some relief, I was pleased to do it, but honestly now analyzing it, it's hard for me to say that is it the euphoria of showing my inner self, or just the joy and surprise of doing something new in my life, or maybe all at once...

I'm sorry right away, I don't really know English, so I have to translate the pre-written text into English, so my words may not be clear!

And I'm sorry that there is so much text, so much has accumulated, it's difficult to convey briefly (

Lori Dee

Hello Mavka,

I'm Lori Dee. Welcome to Susan's Place!

Thank you for that wonderful introduction.

We strive to make this a safe space for you to find information and share your thoughts and comments. No matter who you are, you are always welcome at Susan's Place.

Since this is your first post, I will move it over into our Introductions Forum. The link will remain the same, and our members can still see it, so they can welcome you as well.

You are in a tough situation with all of the restrictions placed upon you. You did the right thing coming here for advice. That is why we are here.

Your questioning and doubts about yourself are perfectly normal. We all wonder sometimes if what we feel is real, or something we made up, or if it's just a fetish or fantasy. The fact that you were aware of yourself as a girl is a strong sign that your gender dysphoria is real. The fact that you felt compelled to try on some makeup and felt some relief is further evidence that this is not some fetish or fantasy. It is a part of who you are. And that part of you is seeking expression.

It is important for you to explore this further, but your personal safety is most important. Normally, I would suggest that you seek out a therapist to help guide you and find the answers you seek. But I realize that may not be possible for you. Perhaps talking to a trusted friend can help if you are certain that it is safe to do so.

We have a wealth of information here. We have real-life experiences from real people who have been through this. Perhaps, by reading their stories, it will help you understand your own feelings and that you are not alone in this.

When you click on the HOME button, you will see a page listing all of the various sub-forums by category and topic. Each sub-forum has a description of what that forum is about, as well as any guidelines for posting.

Please keep in mind when posting that this is an ALL-AGES  PUBLIC  Forum and the internet never forgets.
Do not post anything that you do not want to be made public.

I will add links below that are important for new and returning members.
Pay special attention to the links in RED.

If you have any questions about the Susan's Place site and the Forums, please feel free to contact me at LoriDee605@outlook.com.

Once again, welcome to Susan's Place!

~ Lori Dee
Forum Staff



Things that you should read




@Mavka 
@Sarah B
@Northern Star Girl
My Life is Based on a True Story <-- The Story of Lori
The Story of Lori, Chapter 2
Veteran U.S. Army - SSG (Staff Sergeant) - M60A3 Tank Master Gunner
2017 - GD Diagnosis / 2019- 2nd Diagnosis / 2020 - HRT / 2022 - FFS & Legal Name Change
/ 2024 - Voice Training / 2025 - Passport & IDs complete - Started Electrolysis!

HELP US HELP YOU!
Please consider becoming a Subscriber.

Susan

Hi Mavka,

Welcome to Susan's Place. I'm so glad that you found us, even if it was somewhere in the dead of night. Some of the most important discoveries happen when we're searching in the darkness for answers.

First, please don't apologize for your English—it's perfectly clear, and you're doing an excellent job communicating something that would be difficult to express even in your native language. Also don't apologize for the length of your post. You have things you need to say, and we're here to listen. That's what this space is for.

I want to acknowledge right away how incredibly difficult and dangerous your situation is in Russia. The fact that LGBT people are labeled as extremists, that transgender healthcare has been banned, and that you cannot safely access professional support—those are real, serious barriers. You are not imagining those dangers, and I'm so sorry you have to navigate your identity in a place that criminalizes your very existence. That takes tremendous courage, and the fact that you are here, reaching out despite all of that, tells me you have strength you may not even realize yet.

Now, let's talk about your doubts, because what you're feeling is something many people experience when they're questioning their gender, and it doesn't mean you're wrong about yourself.

Doubt is not the opposite of truth. In fact, doubt is often a sign that you're asking important questions and taking yourself seriously. Many transgender people—maybe even most—go through periods of intense doubt, especially early on. That doubt doesn't mean you've "invented" your dysphoria. It means you're trying to understand something about yourself that the world around you has told you isn't supposed to exist.

Here's something I've learned over many years of running this site and talking to thousands of people: cisgender people—people who are comfortable with the gender they were assigned at birth—do not spend significant time wondering if they might be transgender. They don't lie awake at night questioning their gender. They don't search the internet in the dead of night looking for answers. They don't feel relief when they do something that expresses a different gender than the one they were assigned.

The very fact that you are here, asking these questions, is itself meaningful.

You described standing in front of the mirror and drawing on makeup for the first time, and you said you felt relief and pleasure. Then you immediately began analyzing it, wondering if it was euphoria from showing your inner self, or just the joy of trying something new, or maybe both.

Here's what I want to tell you: it can be both, and that's okay. You don't have to have perfect clarity right now about what every feeling means. What matters is that you felt something positive. You felt relief. That word—relief—is important. Relief means something that was tense or uncomfortable became easier. Relief means a weight lifted, even if just for a moment.

Gender euphoria is real, and it's one of the most important signals we have. Dysphoria—the discomfort with your assigned gender—can be hard to identify because when you've lived with it your whole life, it can feel normal. But euphoria—the joy, the rightness, the relief you feel when you express your true self—that's often much easier to recognize.

You felt something good when you put on makeup and saw yourself in the mirror. That matters. You don't need to label it perfectly right now. You just need to notice it and allow yourself to explore it further.

You mentioned that it's hard for you to understand yourself, and I want to tell you that this is a process, not a single moment of revelation. Some people have a clear, sudden realization, but many others—maybe most—come to understand themselves gradually, through small experiments, small moments of recognition, and a lot of questioning.

The doubt you're feeling doesn't disqualify you. It's part of the process.

Here's what I would encourage you to do:

Keep exploring safely. If it felt good to try makeup, try it again. Try other small things that feel affirming, even if you're not sure why they feel good. Pay attention to what brings you joy, what brings you relief, and what feels right.

Trust your feelings. You said you are "aware of yourself as a girl." That awareness is important. It came from somewhere inside you, not from outside. Listen to it, even when doubt tries to drown it out.

Give yourself permission not to have all the answers yet. You don't need to be 100% certain to keep exploring. You don't need to commit to anything permanent right now. You just need to be honest with yourself about what you're feeling and give yourself space to figure it out.

Stay safe. I know you understand the risks in Russia, and I won't pretend to fully understand what that's like. But please be careful. Use this space to talk and to process. You can be yourself here without fear. This is a safe place for you.

Keep talking to your girlfriend. It sounds like she's someone you trust and who you can be honest with. That's precious, especially when you can't talk to your parents or access professional help. Hold onto that support.

One more thing: you said you're "afraid that I have invented dysphoria for myself." I want you to consider this—if you had invented it, wouldn't it be easy to just stop? Wouldn't you be able to just shrug it off and move on? The fact that this question won't leave you alone, the fact that it's causing you to worry and suffer, the fact that you searched for answers in the middle of the night and found your way here—all of that suggests this is real, not invented.

You are not making this up. Your feelings are real. Your questions are valid. And you deserve to explore them without shame or fear, even though I know fear is unavoidable in your situation.

We are here for you, Mavka. This community is here to listen, to support, and to walk with you as you figure this out. You are not alone, even though I know it feels that way sometimes.

Please keep posting. Ask questions. Share your experiences. Read other people's stories. You will find many people here who have been exactly where you are, who have felt the same doubts, and who have come out the other side with clarity and peace.

Ты в безопасности и ты здесь желанна. Мы видим тебя—не просто как нового участника, но как молодую женщину, ищущую себя в месте, которое говорит ей, что она не может существовать. Мы слышим тебя, и то, что ты приносишь в наше сообщество, имеет значение—твой голос, твои вопросы, твои сомнения, твои маленькие моменты радости перед зеркалом. У всего этого есть место здесь.

Ты дома.

For anyone else reading this who doesn't understand Russian, I told her "You are safe and welcome here. We see you—not just as a new member, but as a young woman searching for herself in a place that tells her she cannot exist. We hear you, and what you bring to our community matters—your voice, your questions, your doubts, your small moments of joy in front of the mirror. All of it has a place here.

You are home!"
— Susan
Susan Larson
Founder
Susan's Place Transgender Resources

Help support this website and our community by Donating 🔗 [Link: paypal.com/paypalme/SusanElizabethLarson/] or Subscribing!

Mavka

Quote from: Lori Dee on November 05, 2025, 09:11:09 PMHello Mavka,

I'm Lori Dee. Welcome to Susan's Place!

Thank you for that wonderful introduction.

We strive to make this a safe space for you to find information and share your thoughts and comments. No matter who you are, you are always welcome at Susan's Place.

Since this is your first post, I will move it over into our Introductions Forum. The link will remain the same, and our members can still see it, so they can welcome you as well.

You are in a tough situation with all of the restrictions placed upon you. You did the right thing coming here for advice. That is why we are here.

Your questioning and doubts about yourself are perfectly normal. We all wonder sometimes if what we feel is real, or something we made up, or if it's just a fetish or fantasy. The fact that you were aware of yourself as a girl is a strong sign that your gender dysphoria is real. The fact that you felt compelled to try on some makeup and felt some relief is further evidence that this is not some fetish or fantasy. It is a part of who you are. And that part of you is seeking expression.

It is important for you to explore this further, but your personal safety is most important. Normally, I would suggest that you seek out a therapist to help guide you and find the answers you seek. But I realize that may not be possible for you. Perhaps talking to a trusted friend can help if you are certain that it is safe to do so.

We have a wealth of information here. We have real-life experiences from real people who have been through this. Perhaps, by reading their stories, it will help you understand your own feelings and that you are not alone in this.

When you click on the HOME button, you will see a page listing all of the various sub-forums by category and topic. Each sub-forum has a description of what that forum is about, as well as any guidelines for posting.

Please keep in mind when posting that this is an ALL-AGES  PUBLIC  Forum and the internet never forgets.
Do not post anything that you do not want to be made public.

I will add links below that are important for new and returning members.
Pay special attention to the links in RED.

If you have any questions about the Susan's Place site and the Forums, please feel free to contact me at LoriDee605@outlook.com.

Once again, welcome to Susan's Place!

~ Lori Dee
Forum Staff



Things that you should read




@Mavka 
@Sarah B
@Northern Star Girl


Thank you very much! It's so wonderful! It is impossible to put into words how pleasant it is to be in a place where you are accepted for who you are! I am very grateful to you for your support. I will continue to explore this forum and other people's experiences, and I'm sure it will help me in the future. Thanks again!

Mavka

Quote from: Susan on November 05, 2025, 09:16:06 PMHi Mavka,

Welcome to Susan's Place. I'm so glad that you found us, even if it was somewhere in the dead of night. Some of the most important discoveries happen when we're searching in the darkness for answers.

First, please don't apologize for your English—it's perfectly clear, and you're doing an excellent job communicating something that would be difficult to express even in your native language. Also don't apologize for the length of your post. You have things you need to say, and we're here to listen. That's what this space is for.

I want to acknowledge right away how incredibly difficult and dangerous your situation is in Russia. The fact that LGBT people are labeled as extremists, that transgender healthcare has been banned, and that you cannot safely access professional support—those are real, serious barriers. You are not imagining those dangers, and I'm so sorry you have to navigate your identity in a place that criminalizes your very existence. That takes tremendous courage, and the fact that you are here, reaching out despite all of that, tells me you have strength you may not even realize yet.

Now, let's talk about your doubts, because what you're feeling is something many people experience when they're questioning their gender, and it doesn't mean you're wrong about yourself.

Doubt is not the opposite of truth. In fact, doubt is often a sign that you're asking important questions and taking yourself seriously. Many transgender people—maybe even most—go through periods of intense doubt, especially early on. That doubt doesn't mean you've "invented" your dysphoria. It means you're trying to understand something about yourself that the world around you has told you isn't supposed to exist.

Here's something I've learned over many years of running this site and talking to thousands of people: cisgender people—people who are comfortable with the gender they were assigned at birth—do not spend significant time wondering if they might be transgender. They don't lie awake at night questioning their gender. They don't search the internet in the dead of night looking for answers. They don't feel relief when they do something that expresses a different gender than the one they were assigned.

The very fact that you are here, asking these questions, is itself meaningful.

You described standing in front of the mirror and drawing on makeup for the first time, and you said you felt relief and pleasure. Then you immediately began analyzing it, wondering if it was euphoria from showing your inner self, or just the joy of trying something new, or maybe both.

Here's what I want to tell you: it can be both, and that's okay. You don't have to have perfect clarity right now about what every feeling means. What matters is that you felt something positive. You felt relief. That word—relief—is important. Relief means something that was tense or uncomfortable became easier. Relief means a weight lifted, even if just for a moment.

Gender euphoria is real, and it's one of the most important signals we have. Dysphoria—the discomfort with your assigned gender—can be hard to identify because when you've lived with it your whole life, it can feel normal. But euphoria—the joy, the rightness, the relief you feel when you express your true self—that's often much easier to recognize.

You felt something good when you put on makeup and saw yourself in the mirror. That matters. You don't need to label it perfectly right now. You just need to notice it and allow yourself to explore it further.

You mentioned that it's hard for you to understand yourself, and I want to tell you that this is a process, not a single moment of revelation. Some people have a clear, sudden realization, but many others—maybe most—come to understand themselves gradually, through small experiments, small moments of recognition, and a lot of questioning.

The doubt you're feeling doesn't disqualify you. It's part of the process.

Here's what I would encourage you to do:

Keep exploring safely. If it felt good to try makeup, try it again. Try other small things that feel affirming, even if you're not sure why they feel good. Pay attention to what brings you joy, what brings you relief, and what feels right.

Trust your feelings. You said you are "aware of yourself as a girl." That awareness is important. It came from somewhere inside you, not from outside. Listen to it, even when doubt tries to drown it out.

Give yourself permission not to have all the answers yet. You don't need to be 100% certain to keep exploring. You don't need to commit to anything permanent right now. You just need to be honest with yourself about what you're feeling and give yourself space to figure it out.

Stay safe. I know you understand the risks in Russia, and I won't pretend to fully understand what that's like. But please be careful. Use this space to talk and to process. You can be yourself here without fear. This is a safe place for you.

Keep talking to your girlfriend. It sounds like she's someone you trust and who you can be honest with. That's precious, especially when you can't talk to your parents or access professional help. Hold onto that support.

One more thing: you said you're "afraid that I have invented dysphoria for myself." I want you to consider this—if you had invented it, wouldn't it be easy to just stop? Wouldn't you be able to just shrug it off and move on? The fact that this question won't leave you alone, the fact that it's causing you to worry and suffer, the fact that you searched for answers in the middle of the night and found your way here—all of that suggests this is real, not invented.

You are not making this up. Your feelings are real. Your questions are valid. And you deserve to explore them without shame or fear, even though I know fear is unavoidable in your situation.

We are here for you, Mavka. This community is here to listen, to support, and to walk with you as you figure this out. You are not alone, even though I know it feels that way sometimes.

Please keep posting. Ask questions. Share your experiences. Read other people's stories. You will find many people here who have been exactly where you are, who have felt the same doubts, and who have come out the other side with clarity and peace.

Ты в безопасности и ты здесь желанна. Мы видим тебя—не просто как нового участника, но как молодую женщину, ищущую себя в месте, которое говорит ей, что она не может существовать. Мы слышим тебя, и то, что ты приносишь в наше сообщество, имеет значение—твой голос, твои вопросы, твои сомнения, твои маленькие моменты радости перед зеркалом. У всего этого есть место здесь.

Ты дома.

For anyone else reading this who doesn't understand Russian, I told her "You are safe and welcome here. We see you—not just as a new member, but as a young woman searching for herself in a place that tells her she cannot exist. We hear you, and what you bring to our community matters—your voice, your questions, your doubts, your small moments of joy in front of the mirror. All of it has a place here.

You are home!"
— Susan

You are very sweet, I have no words to convey my joy! All this is very pleasant, thank you very much for your words and analysis of my words, I think this is what I need now to at least understand myself a little! Thank you also for your advice, I will continue to study myself and my feelings, and I hope sooner or later I will be able to understand myself, and finally get out of my gray mask and be myself!

Lori Dee

Quote from: Mavka on November 05, 2025, 11:37:13 PMfinally get out of my gray mask and be myself!

This is the important part. When you think about it, you really cannot be someone else. You are you all of the time. We pretend to be someone else for many reasons, such as personal safety in a hostile environment. But deep down inside, we know that that is not who we are.

Dysphoria is when we know this, and it bothers us. Euphoria is when we behave in alignment with our true selves, whatever that means to us. We feel the difference, and that is how we know what is right for us.
My Life is Based on a True Story <-- The Story of Lori
The Story of Lori, Chapter 2
Veteran U.S. Army - SSG (Staff Sergeant) - M60A3 Tank Master Gunner
2017 - GD Diagnosis / 2019- 2nd Diagnosis / 2020 - HRT / 2022 - FFS & Legal Name Change
/ 2024 - Voice Training / 2025 - Passport & IDs complete - Started Electrolysis!

HELP US HELP YOU!
Please consider becoming a Subscriber.
  • skype:.?call
  •  
    The following users thanked this post: Mavka, Sarah B

Susan

Mavka,

Your words brought me joy too. 💜 The way you wrote about your "gray mask" is very powerful. Many of us here use that same language. For years, I talked about my own mask as a role — something I put on when I could not safely be myself, and took off again when I was finally alone or in a safe space.

At work, in public, around people who were not safe, I played that role. It looked like a "normal" life from the outside, but it was exhausting. Then, when I was home or with trusted people, the mask would come off and I could finally breathe. That back-and-forth was survival, but it was hard.

Over time, as I transitioned, I reached a point where I could put that role down permanently. I completed my transition mentally and physically, and now I am just Susan, all the time. I fought for my legal right to live as myself, and I will not put that mask back on – not ever, even if things here become as dangerous as they are for you in Russia.

But I need to be very clear about something important: that is my choice for myself. I am not asking you or anyone else to make that same choice.

Even though things where I live are better, they are far from perfect. There is a loud "moral panic" driven by religion and, frankly, a lot of the same rhetoric you are facing. We are facing the same forces, just at different points on a timeline.

The far-right leadership in the US wants to reach exactly where Russia is now, and religious hate groups are actively mapping the way for them. The machinery that has criminalized your existence in Russia is being built here too — we're simply earlier in that process.

With that said, I am still much safer than you are right now. Here, being transgender is not yet criminalized in the way it has been for you in Russia. You are living in a place where simply existing as yourself can put you at real risk from the government and from others.

So while I have made my decision about what I will and will not do, I will never judge you or anyone else for doing whatever you need to do to stay alive and safe. If that gray mask protects you when your safety depends on it, there is no shame in wearing it. Surviving is not a failure. It is strength.

What matters is that underneath that mask, you already know there is a real you, and she is starting to show herself. When you stood in front of the mirror with your makeup and felt that relief—that was her. That was a moment with the mask lifted. It might have been a mix of trying something new and showing your inner self, but the important part is that it felt right enough to give you comfort.

You do not have to rip the mask off all at once. You can lift it slowly, in small, safe ways:

  • A little makeup in private.
  • A quiet moment with your girlfriend where you are fully yourself.
  • A post here where you can speak as the girl you know yourself to be.

Those small moments add up. They help you learn what feels like you and what does not. They help you understand yourself, even while the outside world is trying to deny that you exist at all.

Please, keep exploring your feelings in the safest ways you can find—here on the forum, with your girlfriend, and in your private time. Notice what brings you relief, what makes you feel more real, more alive, more like you. That will guide you, even if it takes time.

And whenever you need a place where the mask can come off for a little while, you can come here. You are not a burden. You are not "too much." Your questions, your doubts, your joy in front of the mirror—all of it belongs here.

We will be here walking beside you, as long as you need us.

Пожалуйста, береги себя. Ты нам важна.
— Susan
Susan Larson
Founder
Susan's Place Transgender Resources

Help support this website and our community by Donating 🔗 [Link: paypal.com/paypalme/SusanElizabethLarson/] or Subscribing!

Sarah B

Hi Mavka

My name is Sarah and I would also like to formally, Welcome you to Susan's Place!

I see that other members of Susan's have also welcomed you as well.

There is not much that I can further add as Susan and Lori have pretty much said everything.  Just to let you know that what you are thinking and doing for yourself there is nothing wrong, regardless of what others say.

The only thing that I can only emphasise is that you take care of yourself and not tell anyone about your very private thoughts.  To ensure your safety, if you can protect your devices with strong passwords and use a VPN for further security.  One idea I have had and if it is possible get an Elon Musk Starlink Satellite connection.

Once you feel comfortable here, it would be appreciated if you add a little bit more about yourself in the other forums and threads.  I would appreciate it very much as, I'm always interested in learning something new about new members.

In addition members of Susan's will more than likely will discuss problems or issues that are similar to yours as most have experienced these issues as well.

Please keep in mind when posting that this is an ALL AGES PUBLIC Forum and the internet never forgets.  Do not post anything that you do not want to be made public.

Take care and all the best for the future.

Once again, Welcome to Susan's Place!

Best Wishes Always
Sarah B
Global Moderator
@Devlyn  @Jessica_Rose  @Mariah  @Northern Star Girl  @Lori Dee
@Mavka
Be who you want to be.
Sarah's Story
Feb 1989 Living my life as Sarah.
Feb 1989 Legally changed my name.
Mar 1989 Started hormones.
May 1990 Three surgery letters.
Feb 1991 Surgery.

Ciara

Hi Mavka,
It's lovely to meet you and welcome ❤️.

Ciara
I don't have a gender issue.
I love being a girl.



🔗 [Link: tickerfactory.com]