Henriette,
I hear you. Every word.
I'm not going to tell you that you must be thriving. I'm not going to tell you transition is supposed to feel like a party. That pressure to perform happiness—to be a success story on demand—is its own kind of violence. You're right to refuse it.
I've been at this for over 30 years. I remember when the framework was "you do this because the alternative is not surviving." Not pride flags. Not aesthetics. Not celebration. Survival.
The shift in discourse has left many of us feeling like strangers in what's supposed to be our own community. When you say you feel disconnected from the current young trans movement, you're not alone. And no, it doesn't make you a TERF to notice that something has changed, or to grieve what that change has cost.
But I have to stop here and speak directly to something you wrote: that death seems alluring. That you're doing everything possible to forget you're alive.
I'm not reading past that. I can't.
You matter. Your pain is real, and so is your life.
Please reach out:
- Trans Lifeline: 1-877-565-8860 (US) / 1-877-330-6366 (Canada) — staffed by trans people who understand
- 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline: Call or text 988 (US)
- Crisis Text Line: Text HOME to 741741
- International Association for Suicide Prevention: https://www.iasp.info/resources/Crisis_Centres/ 🔗
You don't have to perform wellness. But I need you to stay.
I want to share something a member named Miharu Barbie wrote here in 2017:
Quote from: Miharu Barbie"I feel overwhelmed with gratitude for life today. When I was much younger than I am today, I never expected to live this long. Indeed, prior to transition 19 years ago I believed at that time that I had already lived too long and seen too much and I was prepared to snuff out this life by my own hand.
I am so grateful that I made the choice to stick around and transition. I have seen and experienced so much amazing stuff over the years! I know now that those darkest days of my younger years were little more than speed bumps on the road to this happy, fulfilled life that I'm living today. It would have been such a bummer to miss all this adventure!
I am grateful to all the people who open up and share their fears and sorrows, their joys and triumphs on this forum. You all enrich my life with your openness.
I am especially grateful to Susan and her army of moderators for creating this safe space and for keeping it safe all day every day. You all rule!
Thank you, thank you, thank you!
Love! Miharu"
She was exactly where you are now. Convinced she had lived too long. Ready to end it.
And 19 years later, she looked back and called those darkest days "speed bumps." Not because they weren't real. Not because the pain wasn't crushing. But because there was road on the other side she couldn't see yet.
I've watched this pattern repeat for 30 years. People who were certain there was no way forward. Who couldn't imagine a life worth living. Who later came back to tell us they were grateful they stayed.
Not all of them. Not every story ends well. But enough of them that I know the ending isn't written yet when you're in the darkest part.
Bodies are stubborn. Genetics are unfair. Timelines are cruel and vary wildly from person to person.
Some of us get lucky. Some of us fight for every millimeter of change. And sometimes what we hoped transition would give us doesn't arrive—not on schedule, not in the way we imagined, sometimes not at all.
That's not failure. That's the path being brutally harder than anyone prepared you for.
The "just wait longer" advice is maddening when you're living in a body that feels like a betrayal every single day. I understand why it lands as dismissal. But I also know that bodies can surprise us.
Changes at year three that weren't there at year two. Changes after adjusting dosages or delivery methods. Changes after surgeries that seemed out of reach.
I'm not selling you false hope. I'm saying the story isn't finished yet, even when it feels like it is.
Before I transitioned, if someone had told me I would ever pass, I would have assumed they were either lying or mocking me. Dysphoria had me convinced it was impossible.
Yet within weeks of starting, I began to feel comfortable in my own skin for the first time—and passing followed. It didn't happen all at once. Getting my hair done properly. Learning how eyebrows and makeup could highlight what worked and soften what didn't. Losing weight. Finding my style. Each small step let me see a little more of my real self in the mirror.
Within months, I wasn't performing womanhood anymore. I just was.
The photos below show that progression. The first one is pre-transition—if you look at my eyes, you can see how dead they were from years of hiding. The next few show my early days of coming out, then public speaking, then just living. The later ones came after surgeries.
But here's the thing: there's no surgery between those early photos and the middle ones. The difference you're seeing is confidence. Belonging. The light coming back into my eyes.
Even when I looked rough in those early pictures, I felt amazing—because I was finally letting my real self be seen.
But I need to say this too: even if I had never passed, I still couldn't have gone back to pretending. That's what was unbearable—not the fear of failing at womanhood, but the certainty of dying inside if I kept living a lie.
Transition wasn't about achieving some perfect outcome. It was about finally living honestly, whatever that looked like.
You said you know deep inside you were never a man. That knowing doesn't go away because the mirror is cruel. That knowing is you.
The disconnect between who you are and what you see is dysphoria doing what dysphoria does—it lies. It tells you that the outside is the truth and the inside is the delusion.
It's wrong.
You asked how one finds happiness knowing they've "failed" at being their inner selves. I'd push back gently on the framing.
You haven't failed. You're in the middle of something hard. The middle is not the end.
For me, the measure of successful transition was when I started looking forward instead of back. Not when I passed perfectly. Not when the mirror stopped hurting. When the weight of what I'd lost stopped being heavier than what I was moving toward.
That shift doesn't happen on a schedule. It doesn't require a particular body. It requires staying long enough to get there.
What would actually help you right now? Not what you're supposed to want. Not what would make a good story. What do you actually need?
I'm here! This community is here!
You don't have to be okay! But please—stay!
With love and deep care
— Susan