I understand why they did this, whether I agree with it or not. It's been a long time since 2004. A lot has changed. A lot of big deals have been made since then, over trans folks (almost entirely trans women) winning things. You would think we would have moved forward in twenty two years in terms of research and understanding but we really haven't. Because mostly people only want to hear and believe what makes them feel good. And some folks just want a scapegoat for not meeting the standard they wanted to meet.
As a result, bodies follow the path of least resistance. Or the path that they are being pressured to follow. So I understand this even if I don't necessarily agree with it. Considering everything that's gone on in the last twenty two years, I don't think it was really so stunning as much as it was kind of inevitable. Which is sad.