QuoteThe answers hinge upon the fact that male dominance, though very important, is not actually a basic precept of Gorean philosophy. It is actually a derivative of a more basic precept, one with no exceptions. This precept is the foundation of many aspects of Gorean philosophy and society. This precept is one of the clearest divisions between Earth and Gorean moralities. It is a precept that most people on Earth find repugnant. On Earth, this precept has led to genocide, war, tyranny, slavery and other horrors. The United States was founded to oppose such a precept.
This "terrible" precept is that "People are not Equal." A quote from the books helps to illustrate this point.
"The morality of Earth, from the Gorean point of view, is a morality which would be viewed as more appropriate to slaves than free men. It would be seen in terms of the envy and resentment of inferiors for their superiors. It lays great stress on equalities and being humble and being pleasant and avoiding friction and being ingratiating and small. It is a morality in the best interest of slaves, who would be only too eager to be regarded as the equals of others. We are all the same. That is the hope of slaves; that is what it is in their interest to convince others of. The Gorean morality on the other hand is more one of inequalities, based on the assumption that individuals are not the same, but quite different in many ways. It might be said to be, though this is oversimple, a morality of masters." (Marauders of Gor, p.
This precept recognizes that we are all individuals and that each individual is different from all others in a myriad of ways. Not all men are the same and not all women are the same either. People are judged on an individual basis according to their own skills, intelligence, flaws and such. Though Earth recognizes the importance of individuality, Earth still stresses the basic equality of all. Gor is more an elitist society where the most capable are considered better than those below them. Every person is still important but some are considered more important than others.
-From one of the essays (#34 regarding male dominance) on Luther's Gorean website
I think this is actually interesting, and I would agree with it somewhat.
The philosophy that all are equal, which countries like America were founded on is good in principle but it would seem a bit shortsighted.
I would suggest that a better philosophy is that "All deserve equal oppurtunity".
Simply put, I have met some people who swear up and down that anyone can do anything if they put their mind to it.
In my experience, this is simply not true.
My Love has knee problems, for instance: she is never going to be a triathelete.
And yet I've met people (and so has she, including some highschool gym teachers who swore she 'could' run as fast as the others if only she'd 'put her mind to it' and dispite a doctors order to the contrary) who swear up and down and refuse to believe that there are limits for anyone.
It's an interesting thing that Gorean Philosophy recognizes. It (gorean philosophy) treats people as an individual based on their individual needs, traits, merits, and ability, and would not be likely for instance to force a child to be what the parrents and teachers wanted them to be simply because they believed that "all are equal".
Goreans belive that all are not equal and thus individual and different.
Each has different needs, wants, skills, ways of learning, traits, behaviors, things they'd be good at, and things they would not be good at.
Goreans recognize this, and this aspect of their philosophy I am inclined to agree with.
-sara
Post Merge: February 26, 2009, 04:44:33 PM
An added thought,
I think the main concern is weather differences make one better than another.
I would argue that they do not,
However it is most definitely important to recognize that people are all one and all different.