Hmm. If I'd have to say first, it would have been my janitor in elementary school

. What can I say, I'm a sucker for facial hair. I didn't really feel "that way" towards anyone at that age, but it was still a crush nonetheless.
Afterwards, I believe I've developed crushes on Johnny Depp, Niel Patrick Harris (too bad he's gay...what a man...), and the Isaiah Mustafa (the Old Spice guy). Oh, and my best friend, but I've gotten over that one.