Are you proud of being transgender?

[Semiopathy]

No.  Pride is a virtue that has to be earned.  Pride falls under the domain of ethics, not of metaphysics: You can take pride in the actions you take, in your accomplishments, but not in your genetics or where you were born.  You have no choice if you are born in America or in Russia, if you have brown hair or blonde hair; if you are cisgender or transgender.  You do have a choice to uphold American values, and thus take pride in being American.  You do have a choice in transitioning to your correct gender, and can take pride in that accomplishment and the courage you exhibit in making it.

[Arch]

Just like I'm proud of being white, blond, and blue.

[N.Chaos]

To me personally, it'd be like being proud to have been born missing a limb (which I guess in a way, it is) or some other defect. That's how I see it, at least for myself, as a defect.

I'm proud of the BS I've endured to finally be myself, I'm proud of the excellent relationship I have with my boyfriend, and I'm proud of all the art and writing that's come from all of this internal tumult, but I'm not proud of the source. Not in the least.

[smooth]

I'm proud of the way I've dealt with my own GD but I'm not so proud of being transgender. I don't like being lumped in with everyone else because this can lead to being considered the same as everyone else. As much as I am transgender I feel like an outsider because I didn't follow the same path as seems typical....

[annette]

I'm not proud for my transsexual past, I rather have been born in the right gender.
I mean, where should I be proud off? That mother nature or God made a nasty joke when I was born?
The only thing I can be proud on is the way I picked up my life since than  and making the best of it.
yes, one can be proud on things that one did, not for a birth condition.
So, I'm defenitely not OUT and PROUD, I'm just me.

[Felix]

I'm not proud for my transsexual past, I rather have been born in the right gender.
I mean, where should I be proud off? That mother nature or God made a nasty joke when I was born?
The only thing I can be proud on is the way I picked up my life since than  and making the best of it.
yes, one can be proud on things that one did, not for a birth condition.
So, I'm defenitely not OUT and PROUD, I'm just me.

I'm out and proud in the same way that I've ceased to try to hide my limp, or the fact that I didn't finish middle school, or that my kid has only met her other biological parent a couple of times and by court order, or the reality that I'm not particularly skilled at social behavior even with tons of practice. I'm tired of keeping secrets for other people's comfort, and the more they vilify any intrinsic part of me, the more I will glorify it.

[batgirl]

Just like I'm proud of being white, blond, and blue.

Brave man! good for you!

[wheat thins are delicious]

I'd rather be a real woman but still.

so trans men and trans women aren't "real"

[Arch]

I guess the word "proud" is kind of problematic; I tend to be proud of accomplishments, not accidents of birth.

I go to Gay Pride events, but I wouldn't actually say that I'm proud to be gay. However, I'm unashamed. Yet I'm still somewhat ashamed of being trans.

[Arch]

Brave man! good for you!

Hey, I worked really hard to be born white. All of that gene manipulation...

[Constance]

so trans men and trans women aren't "real"

I have to echo this. I'm not a real woman?

And, why should I be ashamed of my sexuality? If people find my sexuality distasteful, that's there problem. I'm queer, and I'm not ashamed of that, either.

[batgirl]

so trans men and trans women aren't "real"

OMG! my post was deleted! lol

[batgirl]

I have to echo this. I'm not a real woman?

And, why should I be ashamed of my sexuality? If people find my sexuality distasteful, that's there problem. I'm queer, and I'm not ashamed of that, either.

We should never be ashamed but being proud of your sexuality is like walking around in a trench coat and flashing people. It's not evil but just rude

[batgirl]

I guess the word "proud" is kind of problematic; I tend to be proud of accomplishments, not accidents of birth.

I go to Gay Pride events, but I wouldn't actually say that I'm proud to be gay. However, I'm unashamed. Yet I'm still somewhat ashamed of being trans.

Don't be ashamed of being trans! It's not sexual it's just you gender so it's quite socially acceptable.

btw the first sentence of your post is super masculine

[Constance]

We should never be ashamed but being proud of your sexuality is like walking around in a trench coat and flashing people. It's not evil but just rude

I disagree. Heterosexuals do this, most likely without realizing it, every time they are out in public with the children they've conceived.

[batgirl]

So I'm not allowed to hold hands with a girl in public 'cause people might be uncomfortable? 'Cause my gayness is distasteful? What the <not allowed>?

I didn't say that

[batgirl]

I disagree. Heterosexuals do this, most likely without realizing it, every time they are out in public with the children they've conceived.

How so?

[wheat thins are delicious]

batgirl: it's obvious you are an unimaginative troll.

I disagree. Heterosexuals do this, most likely without realizing it, every time they are out in public with the children they've conceived.

Agree.  They don't even have to be children they conceived.  People are going to assume, that they are their genetically conceived child.

[batgirl]

batgirl: it's obvious you are an unimaginative troll.

Unimaginative? You really don't know me at all. My craftiness knows no end but I assure you I'm am transgender. I was born male but live as female.

I think that was mean to say I'm unimaginative and a troll.

[wheat thins are delicious]

Trans people can troll too.