Quote from: Kylie on May 12, 2014, 12:07:17 AM
Are those privileges really available to all men though? They certainly aren't available equally. In my experience, gay males and African American males seem to have less opportunities, choices, prospects, etc. than the Caucasian women I know. Some privileges will always be there, but as they have more difficulties along their paths because of other societal barriers, I kind of feel like lumping them in as part of some chosen crowd is a kinda wrong. I agree with most of what you said, I just think it applies to Caucasian males "the societal norm or ideal" that adhere to gender roles more than other males. The further you stray from that, the less you benefit is what I am saying.
Sure, but you still benefit from being male. Privilege means, all things being equal, that single factor is a privilege. Being male is a privilege, all things being equal.
So, a white male has privilege over a white female. A black male has privilege over a black female. A gay male has privilege over a gay female. You can still have the disadvantages of being black, gay, or any other deviation from the most privileged combination of factors... but being male itself is a privilege.
And it's true that being feminine loses some of that privilege, because it's essentially being less male, so yah, less male privilege..... but in terms of most male privilege, because our society is extremely binary, that doesn't mean much of anything. It's an M on your resume no matter what kind of M you are, and that will always be a privilege. Just having a male name is a huge privilege. Even just having the ability to pretend to conform to the norm is a privilege over not having the ability to. Just having the ability to make people perceive you as a male. So a female given a male name would actually experience some male privilege, just like a male who can't pass as male, or can't get by without people questioning if he is truly male, would lose some.
But being male itself is absolutely a privilege. That doesn't mean it necessarily matters significantly on an individual level though in the ultimate question of just being happy............ but it does always carry with it a set of advantages that almost all males have access to and almost all females do not. And I would say there are some female privileges too, they just are not as extensive as male privileges because our society definitely is male-biased.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Actually gonna go on a little personal tangent here...
Just to give an example of one thing I had to rethink when it comes to male privilege. And saying "female privilege."
I used to think that women having unquestioned access to both gender's clothes and to makeup and accessories and stuff was sort of a female privilege. But, at that point in time, I had only experienced one side of it. The male side.
Living as a girl definitely changed my view, and now I actually believe that not having access to feminine clothes, accessories, bags, makeup, all that stuff... is actually a MALE privilege.
It's not because men shouldn't have access to those... it's because they are exclusive to women *because* women are objectified in a way that men do not experience. The fact that they are exclusive is due to a male privilege, not a female privilege.
What I mean is... men have the *privilege* of not reasonably having to question their own worth or acceptability based on their commitment to buying and wearing/using a whole host of ornamental clothes, accessories, makeup, shoes, bags, etc. Men do not have to worry about being judged in the way that women are over not wearing makeup, or for trying too hard by wearing makeup, or for having bad fashion sense, or imperfect hair, or imperfect skin, or not accessorizing right, or even just not wanting to use certain grooming products. Or having/wanting to have certain beauty treatments. These things are used as indicators of a woman's validity as a woman, and there is no way for a woman to opt out if she just doesn't enjoy those things, or just doesn't feel like it one day, she is still judged for them. And she still has be aware that she may/will be judged for them.
What I experienced was that, these things went from being something I enjoy to be creative with and wanted to have access to, to something that I actually was required to think about and participate in as an indicator of my worth. The pressure pretty quickly zapped away a lot of the fun. That doesn't mean I don't still like fashion, but I'm just saying that when it comes down to it, it can actually be an incredibly pernicious presence in a woman's inner experience. It is used to evaluate and sometimes invalidate even women who have no interest in it.
So that's an example of a "female privilege" that isn't really even a privilege. There are a lot of things that men don't have access to simply because they are too respected as individuals with complex and deep inner worth.
Sorry for the tangent lol. Just something I was thinking about, not necessarily related to anyone's posts.