Susan's Place Logo

News:

Based on internal web log processing I show 3,417,511 Users made 5,324,115 Visits Accounting for 199,729,420 pageviews and 8.954.49 TB of data transfer for 2017, all on a little over $2,000 per month.

Help support this website by Donating or Subscribing! (Updated)

Main Menu

psychiatry

Started by stephaniec, February 20, 2014, 07:52:51 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

mandonlym

I've only had good experiences with psychiatrists, but also know that they're influenced by me being young, passable, educated, etc., etc.

The first one I went to specialized in dealing with trans people and (this was twelve years ago) I spent the session talking about why it's wrong to automatically think that trans people are mentally ill and how the guidelines at the time (living full-time before hormones, two years of therapy before transition) were horrible, and how gay people were treated the same way a couple of decades before. At the end of the session he prescribed me hormones and told me to come back when I was ready to be approved for SRS.

I came back four months later and he wrote me a letter approving me for SRS, and referred me to another therapist who wrote me a second opinion. So I ended up starting HRT November of one year and doing SRS in June the following year. Their letters cited a combination of factors, including family and friend support, the fact that I was able to blend in seamlessly as a woman, and had no previous signs of mental disorder. I wonder if their attitudes would have been different had I presented with more issues but there you go.
  •  

stephaniec

I think it might be changing for the better. I started to see a therapist for severe depression then the following week lost my job. I ended in the psyche ward at the hospital. The overnight psychiatrist and I had a talk about me wanting to change gender and the process began. I got lucky compared to a lot stories from other posts.
  •  

vlmitchell

I interview mental-health professionals like I would any employee. If they fit, awesome, if not, we don't see a reason to continue. Overall, I've had wonderful experiences with my mental health professionals in this way. It's also a lot like a relationship. You might grow apart over time and so, you should probably break-up if they're not fitting your needs anymore.
  •  

Suziack

Psychiatric and other medical services constitute some of the few services that people have to pay for, up front, whether the service turns out to good or bad. It's tragic that people have to put up with this kind of thing. While there are wonderfully exceptional physicians, the medical community (psychiatrists hold joint MD and psychologist certifications) have set themselves up to have a very powerful position in society, many being narcissists (which some believe to be a moral disorder, not a psychological disorder). If you have any familiarity, at all, with narcissism, then you should know they look down on most people with repugnant indifference, they have no remorse either for who they harm or who they lie to, and it's axiomatic that they are always right, and the patient is always wrong when they disagree. Furthermore, it's apparently common practice for most physicians to say that something is wrong the patient, mentally, when they have no easy diagnosis, don't know what's medically wrong with a patient, or simply disagree with another diagnosis.

One thing that people are generally not aware of is that, within the medical community, it is considered exceptionally bad form (faux pas) to disagree with any doctor who has previously made a diagnosis. The net effect is that if a patient is seeking a second opinion because an earlier doctor has made a very bad call, that patient is highly likely to get the exact same diagnosis from any subsequent doctors they see. This is one of the 'tricks' used within the medical community to avoid malpractice suits. In many cases, people must educate themselves nearly to the point of being their own physician, and completely nip in the bud any interaction with such medical people, preferably before an appointment is ever scheduled (i.e. when, prior to scheduling an appointment, a physician is unwilling to talk with you to see if their skills match your needs, which is usually the case. I know this is difficult, but it can be done when the doctor is sensible and patient friendly).

Another thing to watch for is the popular 'multidisciplinary' clinic, which is a buzz-word meaning that the physicians at that clinic will refer you to their numerous friends and acquaintances in other specialties (especially psychiatry) so that, between them, they can rack up the fees billed to your insurance. After much experience, I've come to believe that people have no idea what a truly horrendous medical system exists, how bad the doctors really are, and to what money-bilking extent the health care community has evolved. This applies to all specialties in the medical field, psychiatry included, although I've seen very little of it among psychologists and therapist counselors, who I believe generally, but not always, have a truly sincere passion for helping people.

As this applies to the trans community, I think the examples posted so far bear this out. Fortunately, there are also examples of intelligent and compassionate treatment.
If you torture the truth long enough, it'll confess to anything.
  •  

stephaniec

yes, I'm one of the fortunate ones. I got the bulk of my early therapy from schools or psychologists associated with universities. I get my care now luckily from a hospital on a charity basis because of job loss and no insurance . I'm very thankful for the helping hand that saved my life, but I know there's bad apples out there.
  •  

Alaia

My first time around going for therapy on trans issues I ended up using LDS social services (big mistake I know but back then I felt it important to see a therapist I know had a strong LDS background). Anyway, I ended up going through 3 different therapists before finally getting one they claimed was experienced with transgender issues. Turned out she'd only once dealt with a transgender youth whom they'd probably convinced to just repress their feelings. Anyway, the last time I saw her I was so infuriated that I was completely turned off to therapists all together.

One of the things we were talking about was personal happiness and my worries about whether I'd be happy if I transitioned. She pretty much told me point blank that she didn't think people who transition could ever be truly happy. And I was just sitting there in stunned silence thinking "What!? Who the hell are you to determine whether someone is or can be truly happy or not?"

There was that and another comment she made that just pissed me off. I stormed out of that place and never looked back.


My therapist now is much much better. Of course, this time around I made sure to research therapists that were recommended by others in my local trans community.



"Let yourself be silently drawn by the strange pull of what you really love. It will not lead you astray."

― Rumi
  •  

sad panda

Quote from: Alaia on February 27, 2014, 03:59:15 PM
My first time around going for therapy on trans issues I ended up using LDS social services (big mistake I know but back then I felt it important to see a therapist I know had a strong LDS background). Anyway, I ended up going through 3 different therapists before finally getting one they claimed was experienced with transgender issues. Turned out she'd only once dealt with a transgender youth whom they'd probably convinced to just repress their feelings. Anyway, the last time I saw her I was so infuriated that I was completely turned off to therapists all together.

One of the things we were talking about was personal happiness and my worries about whether I'd be happy if I transitioned. She pretty much told me point blank that she didn't think people who transition could ever be truly happy. And I was just sitting there in stunned silence thinking "What!? Who the hell are you to determine whether someone is or can be truly happy or not?"

There was that and another comment she made that just pissed me off. I stormed out of that place and never looked back.


My therapist now is much much better. Of course, this time around I made sure to research therapists that were recommended by others in my local trans community.

Huh. That was kinda the opposite of my experience. Sometimes when I am really emotional I complain to my T that being trans makes me so unhappy but I feel bad because really all she can do is listen, I know she can't help me with that issue or really anyone, and I am the first trans person she has met. And she is so supportive, but then when she says some things I have to wonder if she would say that to another girl or if she is just trying to help me feel valid, like, "ok missy I'll see you next week." (I can't remember if she said studf like that when she just knew me as a cis girl or not.) Not like it matters but I don't wanna be treated differently and yet I make myself different by talking about it.. hahh... :c
  •  

stephaniec

Quote from: sad panda on March 01, 2014, 04:31:39 AM
Huh. That was kinda the opposite of my experience. Sometimes when I am really emotional I complain to my T that being trans makes me so unhappy but I feel bad because really all she can do is listen, I know she can't help me with that issue or really anyone, and I am the first trans person she has met. And she is so supportive, but then when she says some things I have to wonder if she would say that to another girl or if she is just trying to help me feel valid, like, "ok missy I'll see you next week." (I can't remember if she said studf like that when she just knew me as a cis girl or not.) Not like it matters but I don't wanna be treated differently and yet I make myself different by talking about it.. hahh... :c
Well, It really helps to find a therapist you can really connect with. It definitely helps when trying to get at solutions
  •