Susan's Place Logo

News:

Visit our Discord server  and Wiki

Main Menu

A question I'm already sick of...

Started by Cassandra Hyacinth, April 23, 2014, 07:38:48 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Cassandra Hyacinth

I'm scarcely anywhere transition-wise, yet there's one question I already can't stand - "Why do you think your life would be easier/better/etc. as a woman?"

It's utter BS. I'm fully and completely aware that life as a woman would be far more difficult, and there's certainly no guarantee that transitioning will make my life better. That's completely missing the point.

So many people continue to think of transitioning (for male-assigned folks, at least) as stemming from a desire to do feminine things (stuff I have never had a problem doing as a guy. Ever.), or even as some sort of extreme fetish (I will never forgive Bailey for that  ->-bleeped-<- horse ->-bleeped-<-).

For someone to boil down an incredibly destructive condition, the treatment of which is literally life-saving, and suggest that the only reason for doing it is because I don't feel like my hobbies are masculine enough? It disgusts me no end.
My Skype name is twisted_strings.

If you need someone to talk to, and would like to add me as a contact, send me a contact request on Skype, plus a PM on here telling me your Skype name.  :)
  •  

Ltl89

My answer, because I'd want to actually live.  Seriously, being a woman in this world is hard and challenging, but it's better for me to live a free life than stuck in a mental, emotional and physical prison.  I think people who aren't trans have a hard time understanding what leads us to do this.  They don't understand dysphoria.
  •  

naomi599

My father, who is supportive of me transitioning, asks me that question all the time. I always tell him that its not about being happy or better, but allowing my body to agree with its inner identity.
  •  

Madison (kiara jamie)

my response would be something like

"just because a married couple with kids would have an easier life for them and their children if they didn't divorce since their marriage isn't working doesn't mean that its right for them to stay together, so just because i would have an easier life staying male doesn't mean that i should stay that way when it will just hold me back from reaching my true happiness and self image"


  •  

JamesG

@ Madison-  errr... no.  Staying in a difficult marriage for the sake of kids is hardly easier.  It's actually really tough and most that try fail.  Divorce is the "easy" way out. It's more like the choice of remaining the assigned gender, vs. doing what you know is "right".
  •  

liz

I was sick of this question too. Just answer them as the reality was.

For me I was answering to the most comprehensive people : "It's not easier to be a woman but it's easier to live as myself"

For the others it was more like : "I would be dead by now If i hadn't begin this transition, so yes it's easier and better to be a woman"

With the second answer peoples were not arguing in most of the cases.
  •  

Carrie Liz

People just generally don't know that it's a medical condition where being your birth gender causes you active distress and impairs your functioning, they still see it as someone who has lived life as male just fine arbitrarily deciding that they'd rather be the other sex because it "fits" them better.

Knowledge is power. The next time someone asks that, educate them. It will make life a lot easier for the next trans person they meet.
  •  

Christine167

As I have I experienced in life changing to be a woman is no easier than it was to become a man. And the same applies for any difficult change in life. It's overcoming the difficulty and becoming good at it that makes it easy. So yes it will be better in the long run than lying to myself for the next forever and dying with regret and disgust.
  •  

Miyah48

Id simply say it would be harder. But its either live and transition or suffocate and die as a male. Gender is at the heart of someone. I.dont feel disgust. I dont blame them. To most people its like trying to have the color violet explained when theyve been blind all there life. They just simply wont get it.  If the pain didnt hurt so much, i wouldnt try to transition. Continuing as a male is like being afraid of fire and signing up to be a firefighter. My ass is doing water polo instead.
Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication
  •  

warlockmaker

We change because we fell so much better being who we are. Each person's life path is different and being male or female has its normal up and downs as we travel down the path. I asked myself that question many time before I understood my full commitment to transition, most of us here have asked ourselves that queston. I could dwell on the problems facing me but I chose to look forward to the wonders ahead of me. As I have said in other post we get to expriece a full spectrum of ife - not many can say that they have lived a life both s a male and female.
When we first start our journey the perception and moral values all dramatically change in wonderment. As we evolve further it all becomes normal again but the journey has changed us forever.

SRS January 21st,  2558 (Buddhist calander), 2015
  •  

Ms Grace

#10
Interesting, I don't think I've ever been asked that. Great responses though!

(edit...I really hate autocorrect!)
Grace
----------------------------------------------
Transition 1.0 (Julie): HRT 1989-91
Self-denial: 1991-2013
Transition 2.0 (Grace): HRT June 24 2013
Full-time: March 24, 2014 :D
  •  

Cindy

In a way it is the same question you may get when you go for the second opinion before surgery. 'Why do you want surgery when you are already a very attractive woman?' Asked by the psychiatrist. 'I replied, to match my body to my brain'. His reply, 'I totally understand, here is your letter'

  •  

JulieBlair

#12
I've never had anyone suggest to me or query as to why I think that life would be easier or better as a "woman.  A more common response, to me at least, is either "You're joking right?" or "Why would you do such a thing?"   The answers are "No," and "Because I must."  The people I am out with (and that is pretty much everyone that matters) seem to get that this is an abandonment of privilege rather than entering into a privileged state.  Both the men and the women in my life see my transition not as a threat, but as some sort of passing, the death of a friend almost. I have gotten more sympathetic '"sucks to be you" kinds of responses than anything else, and then the relationship begins to change.  Even close friends were tentative and unsure at first.  I kind of feel that I have to really put on the nice as people begin to get to know me all over again.  But there is distance between people I have known for years and me that wasn't there before.  I understand, but it is still saddens me.

Anyone who trivializes transition as to a desire to be more girly, hasn't hung out with any of my gay friends.  I know some very feminine men, who never-the-less rejoice in their maleness.  For a long time when I needed a break from being a straight cis guy, they are who I would seek out.  It would have been simpler, easier and much less scary just to be gay.  People seem to get the LG part of LGBT, but not so much the T.  For me gay wasn't it - sometimes I wish it had been. 

A colleague at work asked me why I would throw my career away like this.  She is a smart post doc biologist, and it was crazy to her for me to willingly surrender participating in the elite world that she worked so hard to be a part of.  Then she gave me a hug and nothing more was said about it.  I'm sorry to have wandered away from the topic header, but I seem to need to write this.  As has been written on this site thousands of times I looked for an easier softer way everywhere I could think of before accepting in my heart that I was both, a girl and that it was ok to be that way.

I'm not very flamboyant, and am really pretty androgynous in my daily life.  I am still learning to be a woman in gesture, voice and demeanor, but I try not to overdo the affectation of femininity beyond what I feel is authentic for me.  What I do know is that at three thirty in the morning when I am alone in a city far from home and cannot sleep.  I can come to Susan's and find inspiration and draw courage from fellow seekers of life.  I would not have chosen this path if I didn't have to so I could remain alive, but I feel whole and beautiful with your help and grateful for a place where I can ramble, and work out who I am.

Thank You,
Julie
I am my own best friend and my own worst enemy.  :D
Full Time 18 June 2014
Esprit can be found at http://espritconf.com/
  •