Ok, so i'm only REALLY late to the party, but whatever, lol. I would like to be on the shorter side (5'4"-ish) and smaller in general. Fit, but not muscular. Imagine Amanda Seyfried, but with red hair maybe....

If i wanted to start on my current stats, and find the closest analog that i would be thrilled to match up with, I think Emma Stone, who is my height, and a weight close to where i was for years, but GORGEOUS imho.

Honestly, they are pretty much the same basic form on different scales, so i guess that gives you an idea.