Yeah, I seriously didn't know they had to be my cheer squad too, but it makes sense that the job candidates with enthusiastic referees/references are going to stand a better chance of getting the job when it comes down to the split. Normally I'd just expect them to say "yes she's a great worker, dependable, etc" but clearly the other candidate's refs went the extra mile.
That's what really $#%&s me about all this at the moment - given we were neck and neck until the ref check I feel like blaming my refs when it obviously isn't their fault... but goddammit, WTF??