Susan's Place Logo

News:

Based on internal web log processing I show 3,417,511 Users made 5,324,115 Visits Accounting for 199,729,420 pageviews and 8.954.49 TB of data transfer for 2017, all on a little over $2,000 per month.

Help support this website by Donating or Subscribing! (Updated)

Main Menu

Does neg or tragic news about transgender people affect your view of transition

Started by stephaniec, June 24, 2015, 08:16:30 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Does news of the trans community affect your decision to transition

most definitely yes
4 (12.5%)
some what , but transitioning is too important
8 (25%)
not really life in general can be tragic
6 (18.8%)
Absolutely not
14 (43.8%)
or if not transitioning does it affect your perception of yourself as trans
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 32

stephaniec

There seems to be tragic news about transgender people every day just about. Are you affected in any way by bad news like discrimination, etc. Would the bad news in and of itself give you pause to your though of transition.
  •  

Mariah

It doesn't affect my view at all. It's not an easy journey to under take and for some it's even rougher. I'm not saying things have been all peaches and cream with my transition, but overall it has been pretty smooth. I know many have a much more difficult journey than I have had. Hugs
Mariah
If you have any questions, please feel free to ask me.
[email]mariahsusans.orgstaff@yahoo.com[/email]
I am also spouse of a transgender person.
Retired News Administrator
Retired (S) Global Moderator
  •  

Beth Andrea

Not really, I'm "good to go" for full transition. Bad things happen--as do good things. I wouldn't decide *to* transition just because of a plethora* of good news, nor would I *not* transition because of bad news.

Understand the risks/benefits, weigh the odds, and go for it!










*I've always wanted to use "plethora" in a sentence, ever since it was uttered on The Three Amigos.... ;)
...I think for most of us it is a futile effort to try and put this genie back in the bottle once she has tasted freedom...

--read in a Tessa James post 1/16/2017
  •  

kittenpower

Trans people are very diverse, therefore every transition is unique, and random events affect us independently, so my answer is no.
  •  

ashley_thomas

Yes if it's close enough to my situation and an aspect of transition I haven't finished.  I get quite worried about my professional transition which I'm about to start when I read about how lacking my area is in terms of openly trans and successful, but that's all I have left. 

I used to fret over marriage issues - made it through that.  I used to fret over family issues - made it through that.  I used to fret over kids issues - made it through that. I used to fret over the impact of HRT - made it through that and so basically I look back and realize I made it through those so I can make it through the next phase. Still when I see bad news for someone in a phase I still have to go through it worries me.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
  •  

Swayallday

9 murders from 542 and counting.
There is nothing that can be done to Americans that they aren't doing to themselves already.

Transitioning? No.

Does it make me sad? Yes.

Will I ever visit now? Probably not!
  •  

Jenny07

It does scare me to see the violence and hate directed to us including murder which is inexcusable.
The hate seems to come from one side of society yet nothing seems to be done to fix it.

I do not read the articles which regular appear as it is too upsetting.

Over in OZ 20 years ago it used to be a sport for young men to go "P##@er bashing".
Proving their "manhood"  :icon_no:
Many people were murdered and it was all swept up by the police.
Now some of these cases are being reopened and treated as murder.

We all need to be vigilant and look out for each other.

However is the ratio any higher than for women as they are also in the firing line as well under domestic violence?
We seem to struggle as a society to deal with such an important topic as so many loose their lives. :'(

I am often ashamed to be part of the human race.


So long and thanks for all the fish
  •  

Kellam

Anytime I hear about another tragic loss for whatever reason it just strengthens my resolve. Leelah Alcorn took her life just as I was aproaching transition. Her tragic final plea to "fix society" helped push me ahead. Because what could I do? Nothing fromthe closet...but out in the open I can strive to be a positive example of trans life, even in my liitle fish little pond way.
https://atranswomanstale.wordpress.com This is my blog A Trans Woman's Tale -Chris Jen Kellam-Scott

"You must always be yourself, no matter what the price. It is the highest form of morality."   -Candy Darling



  •  

Lady Smith

I'm with Jenny in that I often feel ashamed to be a part of the human race.  Violence against Trans-folk and gender diverse people makes me angry and sad, but not for one moment do I regret my decision to transition.
  •  

stephaniec

I just posted a story about Jess Shipps in the news section. 32 years old , member of SPARTA  ended it  because of unemployment and the way society treated her. I would think stories li ke that would have a strong effect on younger, not financially secure transition. I'm only able to transition in peace because I'm retired and don't need to worry whether I have a job or not. Let me add though , hopefully tragedies won't prevent people from their need to transition.
  •  

rachel89



  •  

suzifrommd

With our 24-hour globalized news cycle, when something awful happens to someone in Mongolia within minutes we hear about it here. That can give us the impression that the world is an awful place. But there are seven billion people in the world. This is what seven billion looks like:

7000000000

If a handful of those people are experiencing misfortunes and calamities, that means that nearly all of them are getting along just fine.
Have you read my short story The Eve of Triumph?
  •  

Swayallday

Yeah i'm sorry Suzi, I know the majority is but it's just a bit too personal sometimes :(
  •  

stephaniec

It definitely be disheartening , but we really must move forward. I stopped thinking about transition when I was going to school and read articles about the job market and girls transitioning and I made the mistake of listening to voices other then my own. I admit I was scared of the prospect of not finding a job or living an undesirable life doing things humiliating to support myself. Those were different times though and things today have so much more hope.
  •  

carlab

Violence towards anyone due to gender, religion, color, sexual orientation is simply hate and evil. Hate is a powerful emotion. Violence towards transfolk is scary, but honestly, Violence against women in general is higher than against men, once you include rape, "low level physical harassment" etc. Add race and sexual orientation perceptions in and it just gets worse. Compound that with the sad truth that many people in transition do not have a good support network or an understanding partner and end up seeking someone or something due to being lonely, often putting themselves at higher risk.

When I was still in male denial mode, I did still very much care about women's rights and safety. I guess I was raised right by my mother. My background was law enforcement and tactical shooting as well as combative hand to hand training and I taught a LOT of women's self defense courses. As far as I know, I never had a transwoman attend a class and candidly, we need to know how to defend ourselves as much or more than a GG. Transfolk are, to the point of this conversation, often at higher risk than cis-woman for physical violence while at the same time we are often giving up male physical strength and (at least in my case) an aggressive male outlook towards predators. This potentially leaves many Transwomen in a precarious position and one I have thought about a lot over the course of the last year as I finally begun my personal transition in earnest.

Not entirely sure what my point is here :) Actually, I do... It is simply that ALL women in this society should be empowered to take care of themselves. As much as society has progressed in the past few decades with regards to women's and transfolk rights, there is still a significant number of people who view us as prey. While I have (finally!) shed a lot of my personal macho male BS, I still refuse to be a victim and will continue to keep my defensive skills honed... Even more so now that I am losing a lot of physical ability I used to be able to rely on in a stress situation.

I am seriously considering tailoring a new course for transpeople, because honestly, both transmen and women in transition probably need some information to help keep them selves safe(r.)Keep in mind that these courses are 80% how to avoid an encounter and 20% what to do if all else fails. I may start a separate thread to see if this resonates with this community.

Apologies for the slight thread drift! Oh and- No, tragic news about transgender people do not effect my need to transition. It just makes me really sad that our society cannot seem to cure root causes of violence.
-Carlab
  •  

KyleeKrow

well...it certainly doesn't help, but it's not going to stop me... i already kinda understand how people can be due to past events, so i can't say that it ever really shocks me. in a way, maybe i feel more prepared because of it... having to learn how to fight back i guess.
  •  

Devlyn

So glad the poll had an "Absolutely not" option.

I think it should have been a broader net, though. You don't need to be transitioning to have feelings on the matter.

Hugs, Devlyn
  •  

Martine A.

It does not change my will to work on my body.
It does make me super sad about victims. So hard life and such an end.
It does help me hate more the haters and bigots.
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
HRT - on the hard way to it since 2015-Sep | Full time since evening 2015-Oct-16
Push forward. Step back, but don't look back.
  •  

Carrie Liz

It doesn't affect my view of transition.

But it does affect my respect for humanity, which has gotten worse and worse ever since starting. I began transition believing that most people were just trying to be nice. Now I've reached a point where I feel like a lot of people are shallow sheepish crowd-followers who give people lip service but really are only nice when it's convenient for them, or to make themselves feel better, or when not being nice would make them feel like they're a bad person. And the people who genuinely are nice, who genuinely think highly of everyone, the people who are always looking beyond themselves to help others, I appreciate them so much more now.
  •  

Shawn Sunshine

I just had an acquaintance share with me and she was so negative, that it did bring me down for a little while. I could not handle hearing what happen much more. She was in that stage where no advice mattered at all to her. But at the end she said she was glad to have vented. I had to let it go because it was a bit much for me.
Shawn Sunshine Strickland The Strickalator

#SupergirlsForJustice
  •