I can't really get my head around the question. I think it's like asking a cisgendered guy, would you like to have been born a girl and be happy about it? I simply can't imagine it.
Would I like to have been a cisgendered guy, yes. Not that I hate who I am, but got enough challenges in life without this one, but there's no way I'd try and reconcile myself to being female to avoid this challenge.
For me, the ranking would be cis guy then trans guy, then male-bodied androgyne (that's for my wishes, not for what's better or worse for others). Just can't imagine being happy in a female body for me, it was such a misery.
Dennis