Quote from: Brenda32 on October 01, 2005, 10:13:13 PM...
However, this is a scenario that has been played out WAY too many times. Criminals taking advantage of women? Please, it's one of the oldest tricks in the book.
...
If criminals were stamped out with a cookie cutter I would be alarmed, but they are not. Without knowing the motive I cannot see how we can accurately judge.
Quote from: Brenda32 on October 01, 2005, 10:13:13 PM...
Though none of us can predict the future, the only way to come close is to look at past history. Odds makers do it all the time in betting.
...
We can assume based on statistics yes, however isn't it prudent not to assume anything?
Sure, be
very cautious but you should already be that... regardless of the past of the person you are interested in.
Quote from: Brenda32 on October 01, 2005, 10:13:13 PM...
By reading the previous posts we can see that he has made a life of robbing, deceiving and lying to people.
...
Robbing yes. Deceiving and lying to people? Probably, by necessity.
Does this mean this person is an mean evil bad voodoo doll? ... Not as I see it, such things are done by others, granted usually "legally" But only because some of them make the laws too. This, of course, does not make it "right", but many things are not. Should I damn someone because they have done something I do not approve of without first understanding
why they have done this thing?
Quote from: Brenda32 on October 01, 2005, 10:13:13 PM...
Let's assume your daughter comes home with this story of how she met and married her husband. Are you going to say "oh that's great and terrific. I'll look forward to meeting him in 2010."? I don' think so.
...
First we have to assume I have children at all. I'd want to know why she has done what she has done. In essence, to check her logic, and I would want to talk to him. Surprise surprise that is exactly what I'd do for anyone else.
Quote from: Brenda32 on October 01, 2005, 10:13:13 PM...
Are we quick to judge? Yes. Should we be? Probably not. Are we giving some good advice? You betcha!!
I have never once said the advice was poor.
I question more the right and wisdom of judgment given the circumstances.
For example to twist the given situation a bit, what do you do when your daughter comes home and announces she is married to a *shudder* 'trans person'... I mean, they are ... eeeew. ... Which, we know is inaccurate (to say the least), but the concept is the same. They judge us without understanding, yet we turn right around and judge others the same. ... I think we should be careful of that.
Quote from: Cassandra on October 01, 2005, 11:22:28 PM
I would agree with you Kimberley on not being quick to judge. But you said:
This is comparing apples to oranges. We are judged based on preconceived notions. I think everyone here is basing their judgement on criminal statistics. Big difference. As Brenda pointed out.
Some of us may have been less than forthcoming with our spouses but I hardly think his activity could compare.
Just my additional two cents.
Cassie
Apples to oranges perhaps, however I was referring to how people who believe in a binary gender idea judge us who do
not fit into such a definition. We are judged without understanding. This seems relevant and a fair comparison to me.
Quote from: AmyNYC on October 02, 2005, 12:34:32 PM...
I'm all in favor of giving someone a chance and not judging them on their past, but let's have some common sense here. It's my guess that nobody here was saying drop the guy completely, but just take it a little bit slower.
...
That I can agree with, though I would say a lot slower. However, I think things should progress slowly for any life long commitment. Transition very much included by the by.
Quote from: AmyNYC on October 02, 2005, 12:34:32 PM...
If I knew someone who was going to move in with a SO they've only dated for a month, that would be crazy.
...
I actually think that happens often enough to not be noteworthy. I am not certain though and undoubtedly it would depend on a few things.
Regardless, in my opinion, it is not that crazy of a thought. What better way to figure out if the person you are interested in is really who you think they are? I do not really like the idea, but I do find it both prudent and practical.
Quote from: AmyNYC on October 02, 2005, 12:34:32 PM...
But to say you're married to someone whom you've never met,
...
Depends on the culture and the circumstances. Beliefs too for that matter.
Quote from: AmyNYC on October 02, 2005, 12:34:32 PM...
when this person is currently serving time for bank robbery...
...
We have no idea of the motive. How can one even pretend to understand someone when they don't know why someone did something?