Hey Cynthia, so sorry to hear that things with the wife have taken such a serious turn for the worse. It seems, from what you've said, that she has already made up her mind and drawn a line in the sand. She's had a year to try to learn, to talk to you, to try to understand, but so far, doesn't seem to have really tried, or if she has, isn't willing to accept it. Unfortunately, it seems you are in the very unenviable position of having to decide what is most important to you. On the one hand, you can do what she wants, give up all the gains you've made, but save the marriage, with the understanding that it is a strong possibility that you would develop a lot of resentment toward your wife over time, as you would be having to deny and hide who you really are, always wondering what could have been, who you could have been, never being able to express any femininity, or having to do it in secret, always worrying about being found out, since she has said she wants a man. On the other hand, you do what you need to do to be happy with yourself, to take care of your well being(physical and emotional), you continue with transition, but most likely lose the marriage. Yes, that option would be very painful and difficult, but that pain would ease with the passage of time, and you would have a chance for happiness again. It's a tough thing to face, for sure, whichever way things go, but it's a matter of figuring out what is most important to you, what is best for your well being, and what you can most live with. I do hope things improve, but I think that maybe it might be time to start preparing yourself for an eventual separation. Still, great job standing your ground, though. That must have been very difficult to do, but glad to hear you are feeling calm about it. You deserve your identity 🙂