My wife (post-op and full time some 30+ years) had experienced even more 'Bizarre' experiment from lovers and other T friends. Confused and or conflicted lovers that had to get approval from a trusted confidant, or another T that wanted to use her as 'justification'.
Essentially you tell the third party I am going to introduce you to a T. Now tell me whether or not she is a perfectly normal woman and you had no idea. Talk about a destined to fail test!
Your friend ran a far better version, using a cop show photo array to try to pick out the perp.
You should know by now the conflict cis people experience when confronting gender. Add religion into the mix and you got bigger mess to deal with. Sure it hurts to know she needed validation of what was likely her feelings of how well you present. She also probably felt she could not trust her opinion since she is 'too close' to the situation, much like my wife's friends in the past. You also forced her to confront her religious beliefs on 'deviants', such as yourself. Obviously you aren't quit up to the standards of "Evil" that she expected.
Oh - just make sure you put all the "Trans Agenda" training manuals away before she visits you.