Quote from: Julia-Madrid on November 08, 2014, 05:18:08 AM
"I often wonder whether I will still define myself as transgender once I get SRS done. Historically, I will have transitioned from male to female, but in all other senses only a woman will remain, so is she transgender now? I'd be interested to understand your views on this."
While I can appreciate those views of those who have found happiness irrespective of how they are viewed by others or the world at large, I would like to address myself directly to Juiia's question, "....so is she transgender now?"
First of all I need to state the obvious which is that because I went through this process of transforming my physical body so very long ago, (before many of you had even been born and long before the Internet), things were very, very different then.
In my case there was not a lot of 'navel gazing' or "gender therapy". There was just a fundamental
need, to first understand just what the "problem" was that I was suffering from,
admitting and accepting that I had this problem, and then going about the rather involved and painful process of
fixing that problem.
In my case, and I strongly suspect in Julia's case, my physical body simply did not "fit" or match up with who I actually was. Once my body was "fixed", I was essentially whole and healthy and able to go about my life without any further turmoil or emotional torment about not being able to simply
be, who I simply was...just a simple woman with some rather unique physical limitations due to a rather unique medical history.
Other than the inability to actually conceive a life and carry a child within them to term, I see no reason that given the state of modern medicine today, anyone born with a genetic anomaly similar to mine, should not be able to realize their dreams and be anyone they aspire to be, given that they are willing to make the effort and take responsibility for their own happiness.
To answer Julia's question directly, my feeling is that she should allow those memories of her conflicted past, to fade into oblivion just as quickly and naturally as possible. I never knew much of a "community" when I suffered through the pains of transition, and frankly, I still do not. I honestly see little benefit in the constant online regurgitation of the rather hackneyed old memes constructed to "support" the personal proclivities of so many at the expense of so few.