In another discussion, I was told by mmmmm that some people who had FFS done had some regrets afterwards. I initially couldn't believe it, and thought it was like the 1% of MTF who have regret. Apparently, it's not. It's more than that. And this is not just when the surgery was not feminizing enough but like the opposite - too feminizing!
This is not the kind of things you want to read a few weeks before your surgery. So I decided to investigate, mostly on sysm29 because she posted about her thoughts and she's very clear in her explanations.
Her posts started to concern me as something I should have found before, because it could be legitimate buyer regrets that may strike any of us. So I decide to read her entire post history
https://www.susans.org/forums/index.php?action=profile;area=showposts;u=12761, to check for differences or common points between me and her. I'm sharing the results of my investigation, in case it could be helpful to anyone else.
Long story short, I realize that her story was quite different:
- she didn't really want breasts: " I don't want to grow breasts unless I'm ready to live as a woman full-time. " My boobs are my pride and my joy! I thought I was just A cup, on the verge of B, but when I realized they were C cups but didn't look as such yet because of my body frame and some weird cliches that were put in my head, I was overjoyed for a few days!! My plans are advancing faster than I thought, which was puzzling, but like "puzzling good"!! Like unexpected good news!!
- she mentions hating her hair: "Now my hair is growing too long and it looks terrible... I don't know what the f to do with my hair." With my boobs, this is like the only part of me I actually love and I'm proud of

It took me some serious time and commitment to grow my hair. I would hate to have them like shaved because of some brain surgery

- she had no transition plan and listed transition like the step #6 of a 7 step list, with no specific date. I have a precise idea of what to do this summer to go full time : first in july when I'm still frankenstein (letter for the driver license with the help of WWH where I conveniently scheduled an appointment), in august (HR, then come out to my colleagues when I no longer look like frankenstein to avoid frightening them lol), in september (resume classes as my true self, get a new pic on my driver license as I should look less worse)
- more precisely, she mentions how she didn't really want to pass: "When you have FFS, the goal is to make you instantly pass. My face is said to now be so feminine that I can't pass as James anymore and that terrifies me. I hadn't wanted to pass right away" - well, I do want to pass right away. I even dream what it would be like to have problems on the flight back - say with passport control! Why? Because it would validate me as passing real good lol. Like, I don't care whether they let me flight back immediately or not because I don't look like my passport picture, as long as I had my FFS done, whatever!!! If they need to check my dental records/DNA/something else, and hold me for hours or a few days. I'll be a smiling girl anyway

- she mention how she loved her guy face: "I already mourn the loss of a brother. I loved him and I loved his face. He was beautiful." What?? Well, no. I love my boobs and my hair. My face is more like an impediment that needs to be fixed. When it is, it'll be RIP, but good riddance! For example, I've been thinking about what to do with old pictures etc. I think just want them gone to bury the past me. I plan to let whatever face recognition program run on my picture collection to selectively remove all those where my face is showing, because I want to keep the memories. I'm not sure about that picture thing, though. Maybe I'm overreacting. I'll see in a few month if I still want the pictures gone. Maybe I'll keep say 10 ultra important ones - but with a hard limit, because I don't want that to be a burden.
- she mention a sense of loss of her ethnicity: "I feel as if i've lost myself, my identity, my ethnicity..." There are some parts of my identity I'd like to remove, like with an eraser. I've already changed my name to get of some of them. I've burned a lot of my past in doing so. I've already left everything behind, not just once, when moving. I'm sorry girl, I stand firmly on the opposite. I just want to be a regular boring neighborhood white girl.
- her post were frequently sad. You get the impression she was not happy. I do feel energetic. More important, I finally allow myself to feel happiness. That's the best way to describe how I feel when I look at the sky. I'm no longer repressing myself
- finally, she was hetero :"I think 18-19-20 year old guys are hot as heck." Well, for me, they're disgusting. Don't even mention trying to get intimate! I'm already with a girl I love and who loves the inner me. I wish I will be pretty, but for myself, not for anyone else. Certainly not for "scoring" a person.
There's some ambivalence too :
- she mentions how she's happy to start HRT, then after FFS that she didn't like HRT: "Estrogen has that effect on me, it makes me look so thin and withdrawn. All of the vitality in my guy face is gone. I just don't like what estrogen does to me". With HRT, I could finally start seeing (when I squint my eyes
really hard) the girl in my. I am finally starting to become prettier. It's not all boobs and hair

- she mentions how she hates having hair all over, then how she regrets her facial hair: "I actually even miss the facial hair. I hated the feel of it growing on me, but I liked the way it looked. Since I have a lot of jaw and chin, a beard would have looked great on me. Why couldn't I have just grown it out into a beard and been a guy?". WHAT?? WHAT?

? I hated it when it was growing. I hated the look it gave me. I just hated it - it was like having black worms inside my skin, yuck - especially when they came out after laser. Even on my hands it was disgusting when I was washing the hair away. 2 years later, I don't have the shadow of a regret - pardon the pun

I still have to pluck a bit and it's still disgusting, but nothing that money won't fix someday.
There are some common points though, a wish to be a pretty teenage girl, how she felt every year not lived as her true self was being lost (even if she was only 26), an empty social life in school, a perfectionist streak, a fear of not passing (" I do not want to go through life looking like a man in a wig and a dress" - it's like she was reading my mind!) and the inner feeling she absolutely needs FFS.
I mean, we're very close. When she mention how she started by hating her chin, I think about my nose. It's true that I hate my nose, but only because it's too big. Personally, I couldn't care less if it was made more feminine.
But when she says among her first messages, "all I can think about is "Will I be a pretty woman?"" - well, all I can think about is "will it be good enough to pass without makeup all the time". I did read all her posts very carefully, and I can't say I relate with most of her feelings. But dear anonymous reader, who may be lurking as I long did, you should read her post yourself. If you can't, my post is just a TLDR as good as possible, but very incomplete. You shouldn't make your mind based on my words.
We're all very different. I don't want to diss sysm29 experience. It is very unique, and she has had enough love and trust to share her full history with us, including her regrets. And that is special, since they are not many people out there who can admit doing wrong, even anonymously. She did share her regrets hoping her story could help us. I'm putting that advice to a good use, by making sure my story will not like hers.
I can only recommend anyone seriously planning FFS, or even scheduled for FFS, to read her entire post history if you haven't done so yet. I want to be put on anesthesia with a clean mind and a clean soul. I did read a lot before I created my account to start talking about FFS, but for some reason I had missed that. I wish I had read about her experience before, just because I wouldn't have had the back luck of discovering it a few weeks before surgery. Yet there's a strong anti-FFS streak out here, and it wouldn't have had the same effect if I had found it in a pinned post. I had to find it myself, and read it carefully myself without any premade opinion.
It's a bit of a voyeuristic experience, but it's a very good read, even if you feel anxious. I mean, I didn't know a girl could seriously have regret about her FFS. I still bother about being scammed or about the surgeon being hit by a bus. But I don't fear I may have regret. I just fear what's outside my control. I'm sure now there's no room for regrets. Charlotte is going crazy well enough by herself lol