Hello all~
I'm new here. I just bought my first official binder, thus I found it fitting that this would be my first post.
A bit of background: I've been binding with Ace bandages for 8 yrs so I was very stoked when i placed the order for my Underworks Gynecomastia Compression Tank. Ima pretty skinny guy (ribcage 28") but i got a lot of boobage (chest 34"ish). Reviews suggested getting a size up but i'm used to things being tight so i went ahead and ordered a small. All was good, my binder arrived in the mail, and i did my happy dance, until.... I TRIED THE BINDER ON AND WAS HORRIBLY DISAPPOINTED!
The tummy area was quite snug, as reviews warned, but was in no way uncomfortable. However, when it came to the chest area, the binder was completely ineffective! It was larger than the tummy area and fitted like a loose sports bra. I'm returning it first thing in the morning. I'm not sure if i should exchange it for a smaller size? Or maybe buy the Tri Top instead?. I feel very uninformed and skeptical that a binder that doesn't cause pain can do anything for my chest curves (Like if it aint hurtin it aint working, right? Jk i know thats not healthy). I'm not even sure if i should buy from a different company altogether...
As you can see I need serious help

Any tips on sizing or preferred models?