To some extent, most people who have good results will be partial to the person who did their surgery. And even in a surgery with a pretty large degree of complexity with regards to its modification of an area with a huge amount of nerve endings, the fact is the chance of serious/permanent complications among most major surgeons is pretty minor, as most surgeons who have been doing this for several years have fine-tuned their own procedure to the point where it's standardized—if not for all surgeons across the world, then for that specific surgeon/practice/hospital/etc. So in general, once you're looking at someone who's performed 100+ surgeries, I think the differences are rather minor from a functional stand point, and more down to personal preference.
It's worth thinking about not just the price for the surgery itself, but also of course the cost of travel, the cost of time off from work, and so on. Other than that, I'll say that you seem to have done some research so far about surgeons in the US, but it might be worth looking at Brassard in Montréal. Around the time when I had surgery with him, about five years ago, the price was comparable to surgeons in the US like McGinn, Bowers, etc., but the Canadian dollar is weaker than it was five years ago, so it might be more inexpensive for an American these days.