Sorry, this is long... I don't have time to edit it down... had two choices, erase-and-skip or post... choosing the latter...
Quote from: Erika_Courtney on September 13, 2017, 08:36:39 PM
... I thought things were going good and my head was clearing up. Then it hit me like a ton of bricks, the thought of wanting to be a woman again. ...
I'm wondering if you are very judgemental of yourself. In the above you are saying "things were going good" and "head was clearing up" and
"then..." where the "then" implies something not good (bad?)... that "not good" thing being the thought of being a feminine being.
You might try to consider how you feel about yourself and your fluid fluctuations without such robotic imprint-based judgement.
It seems like you're letting your community's opinions, and/or those of your upbringing, and/or those of your overall societal context generally, judge your experience for you without you fully experiencing and understanding it on your own. Maybe I'm wrong but it seems that way when I read what you say.
Next time you experience a puzzling fluctuation, you might consider sitting down and taking a deep breath, exhaling... let the robotic judgements such as "good" and "bad" float away... just try to relax and ask yourself... is being a woman truly a setback? Is that a "bad" thing? You talk about it above as if it is... but is it? If so, why?
My personal judgement (which should not matter to you beyond your assessment of what I'm saying) is that you are judging yourself, reviewing yourself, based on imprints from upbringing/society/environment, as opposed to really relaxing and asking yourself with your highest civilized mind what is going on, what is okay, etc.
When robotic forms of "good" and "bad" float away, the real strong needs for good/bad judgements don't leave... they are always there (even if somewhat subjective from human to human, we often agree on certain things). If someone falls down while running, that may be a "bad" thing on most people's judgement because we generally don't want that to happen to someone else. There's things in life that folks easily agree are "bad." But a genetic male being a woman... or feminizing... in closed-minded communities that's often a "bad" thing... in open-minded communities that aren't threatened by such harmless notions, it is not "bad" and likely "good." I mean... be careful about whatever judgements you may be implicitly attributing to your experiences, possibly even without your own awareness that's going on. We live in a horribly judgmental society... without scientific data, I have a personal hunch it is the source of a lot of the mental health problems we deal with (as a society).
Quote from: Erika_Courtney on September 13, 2017, 08:36:39 PM
... Here is what gets me if the progression was like the alphabet A to Z, I start at A and move from letter to letter, if I stop I start again on the letter I was just on, well that is not how life is going. ...
Wrong... apparently that is "how life is going" ... and it's not only "how life is going" for you, but you are also judging it as bad without relaxing to truly consider things. Maybe your life is one that goes from A to Z throughout your life... you may really see that and want that. Or if you want to change something, maybe the best footing is to first acknowledge that is what's going on, and even in confusion about it, admit you may not have the data yet to fully understand it, to judge it.
Quote from: Erika_Courtney on September 13, 2017, 08:36:39 PM
... Five minutes ago, I didn't even want to be woman. Now I am back wanting to be a woman and all of sudden I want to get my ears pierced. So maybe I fall back into wanting to be a woman, but how have I moved from not wanting some part of womanhood to now wanting it. I should be where ever a left off not further down the road. ...
Wrong again... your faulty judgement tells you in uncompromising terms "I should not be where ever
[I
] left off
[and
] not further down the road." The truth of the matter is you should be nowhere but where you are. And you are going from not wanting to feminize, to then wanting to feminize. First, there's no data in that to make it definitively "bad" but you can likely find 100s of closed-minded towns around the world that would tell you "bad bad bad" ... and the world is full of messages that such is "bad bad bad." Maybe you are applying a robotic judgement something is "bad" without using your own soul/mind to make a personal wise civilized judgement on your own. That dilemma is not unheard of.
When I read what you wrote... I see you changed from not wanting to feminize, to wanting to feminize... and I don't see any issue with that. It's not a "bad" thing. It's who you are at this time. It doesn't mean that will happen all your life. Also, if you wish to not spend time feminizing, it's not inconceivable that you might learn to manage those feelings such that you can achieve your goal. BUT... and this is important... don't take what I just said as "that's what you should do to be 'good'" ... I'm not saying that.
I'm trying to say your mind is powerful, and it can help your create unhealthy repression just as it can help you move yourself to a place without unhealthy repression. If you're confused at any one time, that's fine... you can sit there in that moment, take a deep breath, exhale, and admit you experienced
what you think may be conflicting thoughts... but that you don't know more yet. If that moment of pondering, letting confusion just be there can often help because it can help you avoid forcing a judgement simply to resolve the confusion. You don't need to resolve confusion in the moment you feel it. And you don't need to judge yourself as "bad" because of confusion. You are allowed to nonchalantly observe confusion, avoid judgement, and even be merry about it... i.e., "Hey, I see my wondrous confusion... what a wonderful mind I have that is processing something... let's what it learns over time... maybe hours, days, years... I have time... I will live the best life I can as I figure this out. I'll only judge when I feel the judgement for myself is clear." ... that sort of thing. I sometimes feel we have a mental health epidemic on this earth because we fail to give ourselves such healthy latitude. You are allowed to give yourself such latitude.
Over judgement just gets is everyone's way so much... there is definitely a time to say "no, that is bad" ... those times exist... but we apply that to so many things where it just gets in the way. Feminizing oneself is generally harmless... to imprint people that it's "bad" is a societal health problem.
Quote from: Erika_Courtney on September 13, 2017, 08:36:39 PM
... I feel like I don't want to be a woman full time, but I don't want to be woman part either. ...
You should discuss that in therapy. Sounds like dysphoria... those are mutually exclusive so I'm wondering if one or the other stems from judgement from imprinting and not your wise soul/mind. But until you know, I'd recommend not concluding it's "bad" or "good" or mutually exclusive. I say this because even what you write there is your own judgement to convey with words and given your other judgements, I'm suspicious your rendition of what you're experiencing within your wonderful mind is too hasty, quick... lacking the full color of what's really going on. On the high level, I get you're experiencing a form of confusion... but I don't sense it's as mutually exclusive as you present... something can either be understood further or resolved further toward less confusion. (And to split hairs... you can be okay with your confusion such that you accept it and understand it in way that is not confusing to you. Not saying that applies to you, just that it's a potential that shouldn't be written off. A non-judgemental accepting view of one's so-called confusion that leads to clarity.)
Quote from: Erika_Courtney on September 13, 2017, 08:36:39 PM
... As frustrating as this all feels, right now and in the at least near future staying a guy is the right choice for me. I know I am transgender, no normal cis guys feels the way I feel, but I can't give in to my fantasies. ...
If it's the "right choice" that's great... fine, no problem. But "right choice" sounds like "good" to me, versus "bad." So if it's not a blind good/bad thing, it's fine... nobody says there's a rule you have to live as a woman. It's really up to you to figure out how to live... resolving gender issues is really (to me) about removing unhealthy repression that gets in the way of being a certain way that works best for someone. So I assume the goal for you in terms of resolving gender issues is to find a way to live life where you feel content in your life/relationships. There's an infinite number of outcomes to all that.
Quote from: Erika_Courtney on September 13, 2017, 08:36:39 PM
... I know someday I will just need to start estrogen, wait a month or two then tell my wife that I am transitioning to be a woman and there is no going back. I understand our relationship is over and there is no saving it, with that being said I want to enjoy every monument I can with her now.
I'm sort of with what others have said... I'd caution against deceiving anyone unless you feel they are abusive and you must be secretive just to move toward health but I don't sense that here. If you lie to someone who expects your trust, that (to me) creates unhealthy karma (it's not good for the soul/mind). Are you saying you know your relationship is over already now? If so, does your wife know you feel that way? If not, can you talk about that with her? Are you certain it's over? Regardless of any answers here, try to find a therapist you can discuss things with personally and perhaps with your wife.