Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

REGISTERING FOR THE DRAFT

Started by Cassi, March 20, 2018, 05:21:13 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Devlyn

I do indeed stand corrected.  :)
  •  

Cassi

Quote from: Devlyn Marie on March 20, 2018, 07:09:35 PM
I do indeed stand corrected.  :)

No problem Miss Devyl!

I just feel it's an opening to either stop discrimination because it is written and understood, or change the law.
HRT since 1/04/2018
  •  

Cassi

Thank you all for your comments :)
HRT since 1/04/2018
  •  

alex82

Quote from: Kylo on March 20, 2018, 06:05:34 PM
Probably because successive generations forget the value fought for, or maybe a serious economic slump will trigger it. When I was a kid I thought we'd learned something from WW1 and 2. Now it looks like a lot of people learned bugger all and we're going to end up going through it all again. Only with drones and robots and possibly nukes.

Why they stopped teaching Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four in school here is anyone's guess. It's more relevant than ever.

Yes, I thought we had too, which is partly why I find Brexit so horrifying.
  •  

alex82

Quote from: Cassi on March 20, 2018, 05:46:41 PM
I can only imagine :)

Israel has the IDF and requires all citizens, male and female to serve.  I think it's two years but they're surrounded by people who want to destroy them.

That's not true. Israel's largest border (if you don't count it's occupied territories) is with Jordan which has expressed no such wish. Israel is run by a coalition headed by Likud whose founding charter rules out a two state solution, is a party that shelters virulent racists, and is headed up by a man who poured petrol onto a fire leading up to Rabin's assassination.

It also doesn't require all citizens to serve - the ultra orthodox are exempt, which is a contentious point for secular citizens and an increasingly acute problem. Attempts to overturn this have always met with resistance from the Hasidic parties the secular right wing relies on to stay in power.
  •  

Cassi

Quote from: alex82 on March 21, 2018, 07:29:06 AM
That's not true. Israel's largest border (if you don't count it's occupied territories) is with Jordan which has expressed no such wish. Israel is run by a coalition headed by Likud whose founding charter rules out a two state solution, is a party that shelters virulent racists, and is headed up by a man who poured petrol onto a fire leading up to Rabin's assassination.

It also doesn't require all citizens to serve - the ultra orthodox are exempt, which is a contentious point for secular citizens and an increasingly acute problem. Attempts to overturn this have always met with resistance from the Hasidic parties the secular right wing relies on to stay in power.

I stand corrected then.  Those who I know from there told me otherwise :)
HRT since 1/04/2018
  •  

Chloe

Sorry I got lost so what's the final answer re transgender?

We have the 2nd amendment which includes most all adults the only service me and mine would ever register for is a war fought on US soii as in ie: The Walking Dead!

Lol Live right next door to Senoia GA!

Someone mentioned brexit. I might sign to defend England it depends am proud of them!
Face "fines" everyday running overweight down the highway am more concerned about who I could actually kill!

Sent from my LG-M150 using Tapatalk

"But it's no use now," thought poor Alice, "to pretend be two people!
"Why, there's hardly enough of me left to make one respectable person!"
  •  

Cassi

Quote from: Kiera on March 21, 2018, 01:06:25 PM
Sorry I got lost so what's the final answer re transgender?

We have the 2nd amendment which includes most all adults the only service me and mine would ever register for is a war fought on US soii as in ie: The Walking Dead!

Lol Live right next door to Senoia GA!

Someone mentioned brexit. I might sign to defend England it depends am proud of them!
Face "fines" everyday running overweight down the highway am more concerned about who I could actually kill!

Sent from my LG-M150 using Tapatalk

United States Selective Service law dictates that if you were born female and trans to male you are not required to register.  If you were born male and trans to female you are required to register or face a $250,000 fine.
HRT since 1/04/2018
  •  

alex82

Quote from: Cassi on March 21, 2018, 11:06:26 AM
I stand corrected then.  Those who I know from there told me otherwise :)

Easy enough to visit or research, or both. Those are the facts. I don't know why knowing a few locals would change that - here in this thread you have two British people with diametrically opposed views to Brexit and related matters. One seems to think it's great, I on the other hand think it's a disaster area and no surprise that only Putin, Trump, and Islamic State were the international entities that allied themselves with it.

It's no different from many countries on having a right wing and a left wing, and that depends on the speaker and the audience. Americans do seem to get the right wing narrative, resulting in the latest mess with the embassy and defiance of carefully balanced norms. As Netanyahu himself said, the US is unusually pliable and credulous - and that works for his very right wing policies that you take the international flak and pay the financial price for.
  •  

alex82

Quote from: Kiera on March 21, 2018, 01:06:25 PM
Sorry I got lost so what's the final answer re transgender?

We have the 2nd amendment which includes most all adults the only service me and mine would ever register for is a war fought on US soii as in ie: The Walking Dead!

Lol Live right next door to Senoia GA!

Someone mentioned brexit. I might sign to defend England it depends am proud of them!
Face "fines" everyday running overweight down the highway am more concerned about who I could actually kill!

Sent from my LG-M150 using Tapatalk

Sorry,  what? What's that about? You obviously don't know anything about it.
  •  

alex82

Quote from: Cassi on March 21, 2018, 01:34:27 PM
Not sure who you were reflecting the last comment to?

No, not you - the person going on about Brexit in relation to highways and running while overweight and being proud of England (which isn't even the state in question - it's one constituent part of it).
  •  

alex82

Quote from: Cassi on March 21, 2018, 01:08:53 PM
United States Selective Service law dictates that if you were born female and trans to male you are not required to register.  If you were born male and trans to female you are required to register or face a $250,000 fine.

You learn something new every day round here. I wonder why women aren't required to register? What's the reasoning behind that?
  •  

Kylo

Quote from: alex82 on March 21, 2018, 06:41:37 AM
Yes, I thought we had too, which is partly why I find Brexit so horrifying.

I'm not sure why you find it so horrifying. We signed up to the EEC, not Junker's private funland. Currently people like him get to do whatever they like and dictate what my country has to allow without being accountable in any way whatsoever to me, a voter. That is fundamentally un-democratic and I don't want any part of it. This political union has gone far enough. Now they want an army and to change the demographics of nations and do as they will with those nations' resources without their say. No thanks. We can have an economic pact with the EU without them dictating what we do, which was supposed to be the plan in the first place. They've lost their way.
"If the freedom of speech is taken away, then dumb and silent we may be led, like sheep to the slaughter."
  •  

Cassi

Quote from: alex82 on March 21, 2018, 01:32:37 PM
Sorry,  what? What's that about? You obviously don't know anything about it.

It took me a second or two to comprehend what you were referring to, lol.

I don't know much about the UK armed forces other than a little on the Royal Marines having spent 12 years in the United States Marines and I found out a few months back that my great great great (and maybe great again) grandfather was a member of the King's Rifles which I didn't even know we had English ancestors.

However, my sister insists that we are related to the great Scotish Poet Robert Burns but he was quite active from what I hear :)
HRT since 1/04/2018
  •  

Cassi

Quote from: alex82 on March 21, 2018, 01:38:39 PM
You learn something new every day round here. I wonder why women aren't required to register? What's the reasoning behind that?

At the risk of getting in trouble, I think there's a deep seated belief in many that women shouldn't be in the military here in the US.  More likely has to do with continuing the species I would think.  Again, I mean no disrespect or insult, but if as many women fought and died in the wars that humanity has fought, our species probably wouldn't be as large???????
HRT since 1/04/2018
  •  

alex82

Quote from: Kylo on March 21, 2018, 01:38:47 PM
I'm not sure why you find it so horrifying. We signed up to the EEC, not Junker's private funland. Currently people like him get to do whatever they like without being accountable in any way whatsoever to me, a voter. That is fundamentally un-democratic and don't want any part of such a political union.

They don't though - he's accountable to an elected senate, which we were a full part of. He won't be there forever - another country's representative will be leading - it could've been one of ours. By the way, the UKIP MEP's we sent to parliament were barely there - Farage turned up for one meeting in 70. He has one of the very lowest attendance rates, as do the rest of them on that side. How do you remove our head of state by the way? You don't. She is above elections and has been in post since 1952. Now I quite like her, but it's hardly the peak of democracy if you want to compare it to the EU as a whole.

Of every vote in the European Parliament or the directives from The Senate, the UK got its way 97% of the time. That's really not bad going in a cooperative endeavour.

I'm horrified because it's the largest and richest trading block in existence, with freedoms to live work, be educated, and retire in 28 countries. It has extremely high social security nets in general, and the very highest standards when it comes to human rights.

I'm horrified because it is a grand cultural project with fine aims that has been lied about by the Murdoch press and the Daily Mail. I'm horrified because they along with its other supporters and financial backers are no friends to LGBT people. I'm horrified because of the damage done to international standing.

I'm horrified because London is at the crossroads of the world and is the major global centre, partly because of passporting rights into the largest and most cosmopolitan free trade area that's ever existed, and that's been placed at serious risk.

I'm horrified because of the cuts that have had to be made for yet another extended period (and the billions made available within hours of the vote count to steady the Bank of England) by a government in such crisis it's overwhelmed by an impossible and harmful policy. I'm horrified that the EMA and the banking regulator pulled those jobs this year, just as they told us they would do - and Brexiters said they were bluffing.

I'm horrified that we are being represented by seriously corrupt liars, many of whom have already been sacked. Some others have been brought back after sacking for previous very serious corruption.

I'm horrified because there isn't one EU rule that causes us harm. We had opt outs from Schengen and hence had border controls in place -you have to go through passport control every time you re-enter the UK, and we had an opt out from the Eurozone. Not that it matters anymore because the £ has crashed since the vote, so import costs gave rocketed and and companies have already gone out of business or are shifting operations.

I'm horrified that Trump, Putin, and IS alone thought it was a good idea, because none of them want a strong or functioning EU. I'm horrified at the impact on the higher education system, on the NHS, on food standards. I'm horrified that judges in the supreme court simply doing their constitutional jobs have been branded traitors by right wing newspapers who've tried to muck spread about their sex lives. In horrified that people like Gina Miller have police protection after death threats - presumably entirely credible ones considering the murder of an MP by a Brexit supporting fascist.

I'm horrified that my grandfathers generation who achieved peace and prosperity in Western Europe, and raised their kids to double down on that, have been betrayed by misinformation from tax evaders, and churned out by right wing groups.

I'm horrified about the precarious implications for Northern Ireland, and equally horrified that Scotland and Gibraltar as constituent parts are being ignored, and their devolved parliaments being sidelined despite the wishes and huge remain votes in those parts of the U.K. England (minus London, and the other progressive cities and counties) and Wales have potentially risked the integrity of the U.K. - on the basis of largely false information, and it's very sad.

An EU army would need to be approved by each member state - it wasn't going to be. I think that's a shame because a common response, and the nuclear capabilities of the UK and France combined would be something. This week we see again how Brexit has isolated the UK - Putins mob running amok with chemical weapons. Not for the first time. That's the cold reality.
  •  

alex82

Quote from: Cassi on March 21, 2018, 01:42:20 PM
At the risk of getting in trouble, I think there's a deep seated belief in many that women shouldn't be in the military here in the US.  More likely has to do with continuing the species I would think.  Again, I mean no disrespect or insult, but if as many women fought and died in the wars that humanity has fought, our species probably wouldn't be as large???????

That's a shame and prejudiced of a policy to reduce women to hyothetical biological functions that the individual may not be interested in using. That's almost Saudi style policing of women, of outdated and not working gender roles, and of women's bodies.

Women make good warriors wherever used - they have throughout history. The Soviets fended off the Nazis successfully with legions of women troops. There are many other examples.
  •  

Cassi

HRT since 1/04/2018
  •  

alex82

Quote from: Cassi on March 21, 2018, 01:38:59 PM
It took me a second or two to comprehend what you were referring to, lol.

I don't know much about the UK armed forces other than a little on the Royal Marines having spent 12 years in the United States Marines and I found out a few months back that my great great great (and maybe great again) grandfather was a member of the King's Rifles which I didn't even know we had English ancestors.

However, my sister insists that we are related to the great Scotish Poet Robert Burns but he was quite active from what I hear :)

If it's your thing, it's easy online and quite addictive to find out - reliable English birth marriage and death records tend to go back to the mid 16th century. Scottish to a century later in general. He may not have been English - there are different constituent parts of the UK. It's like a Californian is also an American who lives in the USA - they're just not from Wisconsin, or the other states. A Scot is also a British person who lives in the UK - they're just not from England, or the other parts.
  •  

Cassi

Quote from: alex82 on March 21, 2018, 02:14:20 PM
If it's your thing, it's easy online and quite addictive to find out - reliable English birth marriage and death records tend to go back to the mid 16th century. Scottish to a century later in general.

Thanks!  I got into genealogy a few years back. A wealth of information on my paternal side being from Germany/Prussia and blue bloodies :)

My paternal grandmother had the English bloodline.

On the maternal side, always believed they were mostly native american but again, it was my sister who insists on the Scotish heritage.

On the maternal side,
HRT since 1/04/2018
  •