Quote from: Mister on June 16, 2009, 10:24:29 AM
You can't ever transition in 100% secrecy. You've got to file things in court, tell your parents, etc.
As the kids say, THIS.
Even if you lived as a man right up until your transition date, if you one day just started living full time, which some people do, I think the feminization of the male appearance will be a little obvious. People will notice weight loss, or weight re-distribution, and start to think you're sick. It happened to me at church. I wasn't really out, and people thought I was ill. Physically ill, not GID-crazy.
I just don't think it's impossible to hide completely. Especially not now. The internet makes it much harder to just disappear.
Lori--
Two things you said stuck out to me.
The first was the comment about people not noticing what you're doing to your appearance at work. I have to say that based on my own experience, people DO notice, and they just aren't saying anything. You're at work, everyone's there to be professional, etc, and your business is your business. Unless it affects your work, no one at work has a right to know what you're doing. If you wear pink bracelets and pluck your eyebrows and whatever else, people won't care as long as you're still a good employee. But don't think they haven't noticed. They might not be able to pinpoint individual changes (i.e. you got your eyebrows waxed) but they will notice that you look different.
When I was starting out, I was doing the same thing, feminizing my appearance a bit at a time, and people at work DID notice, they just didn't say anything. I thought they were oblivious, but they were really just being awkwardly careful not to say anything about it. Talk about the elephant in the room. Being open with my co-workers actually helped lighten the atmosphere. I started by telling people that I was doing laser hair removal, seeing a therapist. Once I opened the subject, they felt comfortable to ask questions without the whole thing being awkward. I wouldn't compare what I'm doing to someone like Lyn Conway, but I think that education at the grass-roots personal level is what's going to change acceptance for trans people in society. One person at a time, I guess.
The second thing you said was that
Quote from: Lori on June 16, 2009, 09:58:44 AM
...I've seen others that still looked like men after 5 years of hrt and srs. I cannot live like that. I won't live like that. That is my personal decision to not do it.
I cannot afford surgeries for FFS and body sculpting...I would like for HRT to help transform me into a female in body. I know I won't get hips and a big butt and other things but I've certainly seen plenty of GG's with no hips and no butt...I want to feel like I want to live. I want to be happy.
I think it's been said before with respect to surgery that it won't make your life 100% better. IOW, if you had a crap life before SRS, chances are your life will still be crappy post-SRS, you'll just have a vagina instead. IMO, the same kind of conventional wisdom applies to HRT and transition in general. HRT will help to feminize your appearance, but it doesn't magically make all your other problems go away. I have depression. I've had it for years. Some of it is GID related, but some of it is not. Being on HRT, or socially transitioning, didn't make the depression go away, now I just get depressed about different things. Learning to deal with those things is part of what makes transition so hard.
If you put all your eggs in the basket of hope that HRT will make you into a girl, you might be setting yourself up for disappointment. I don't mean to be the pessimist here, but I am trying to be realistic and say that the kinds of things you're talking about are kind of scary-- "I won't live like that" If HRT doesn't do what you want it to, are you saying you'll kill yourself? I think a lot of us here have been suicidal or depressed to the point of suicide, and speaking from my own experience (which may or may not help you at all) it's important to find your reasons to live outside of how you look, outside of how smoothly transition goes and outside of anything except the part of you that says "there are things I still want to do, a life I still want to live. I might not pass perfectly, or be a beautiful supermodel, but there's an advantage to living my life in as authentic a way as I can."
I think Sandy has said some great things, and probably put everything more eloquently than I could. Please don't think I'm attacking you, I'm just concerned, and like Sandy said, we're here for you, and talking about your issues and problems is good. We're not experts, but we are here to support you.
Love and hugs.