I too, early on in my FFS surgeon research, came across this hack job site against DR. O. It scared the heck out of me. After much more consideration, he stayed on my list. I had joined a Yahoo FFS group and watched those reports very closely.
The only negative I would say about Dr. O, is that he is getting on in age and is pricey. I might have used him, except that he took too long to get back to me with a written consult and quote.
I personally know 3-4 women who have gone to him and are satisfied. If you send me an email, I will put you in touch with 2 women that just got back from San Francisco and Dr. O.
Personally, I used Dr. Stephen Pincus in LA. I just felt comfortable with his approach and quality.
If you want and need major facial surgery, including bone work (forehead, chin and jawline) in addition to soft work, then he's excellent. Don't get more surgical procedures than you need, and make sure to get a few different consults.
Don't sweat it. Go with your gut and trust your judgment.
BTW, in this economy prices may or may not be negotiable, too. Good luck!