Quote from: Cruelladeville on December 06, 2010, 05:10:50 AM
@ Spacial....
*Using borrowing for lesser degrees of spending is a sure road to bankruptcy.*
You'll enjoy this.....
And I apologise in advance for flipping off topic for a wee while.....lol
Thanks for that. It's an intersting point of view.
But National finance is very different from personal.
I'd rather not get into a debate about national.
With personal finance, we need to identify different types of spending.
Capital spending is, generally, that which creates more wealth. If a car is necessary to earn your living, then it can be considered capital, but only when it is just sufficient for the need.
EG. You get a new job which pays well. But you must have a car. In one instance, a basic saloon is adequate, you only need it for traveling. The cost is recouped by the extra earnings you will get.
If you buy a limo, most of that is not capital. It will take considerably longer to pay it off, plus the additional running costs, fuel, maintence, insurance, so it will take you longer to be turning a profit on your new job.
In the second instance, the new job requires a limo. But the pay is not particularly good so it will probably take several years to repay any loan. During that time, there is the continuing risk of total loss of the limo, through uninsured event, for example, leaving you with no job, no income, no limo and a substantial debt.
That's the principal of domestic finance.
In this instance, Maddie needs to raise a substantial amount of capital for a surgical procedure that is essential to her well being.
If she were to borrow the entire amount, assuming she continues to have a secure and reasonably well paid job afterward, she will be repaying the loan for many years. Those repayments will consume a substantial portion of her pay, reducing her standard of living and limiting her scope for future spending, not to mention, trapping her in her present position.
Realistically, it seems unlikely that most people can assume long term secure employment. Moreover, the realities are that, for someone who had gone through gender surgery, there will be enormous social and psychologocal adjustment.
In this instance, borrowing is, frankly, suicide, always assuming you could find anyone prepared to lend. If you did, they would charge an enormous interest rate, increasing your burdon and destroying your life entirely.
For expenditure such as Maddies, she needs to find another way to raise the finance. Preferably, raising most of it without any recourse to any borrowing at all.
For that, she needs to find some capital project. That is a project which will show a financial return.
House purchase is one. Land purchase, espcially in the US, can be very profitable, provided you are careful where you buy and when.
But sometimes, it can be a case of spending on education or training, getting a decent job and saving up.