Price not equal quality, Price never equals quality, I think.
This said I have had the best luck so far with the "love my nails" brand. Generally $0.99 a bottle, with a nice selection of colors. Color and brand notwithstanding I highly recommend investing in bottles of both the bottom and top coats. (2 base, 2 color, 1 glitter(optional), 1 topcoat. Such is how I keep my nails from self destructing and believe me without this I am unable to keep similar lengths on me paws.
Color wise what comes to mind would be a nice red. My eye not withstanding however one could always do a bit of comparison at the store itself by comparing skin color and the bottle colors.
For comparison I started with a turquoise color

Luck to you and have fun