I'm going to recount my wonderful night last night. I'll leave out the screaming and nuttiness that led up to it.
My eleven year old went as an evil princess. Lots of makeup and velvet. I tied a pride flag around my neck for a cape and wore a homemade crown and carried a big stick with feathers and glow-bracelets on it. I was officially a king of Narnia, but I really just looked like some kind of gay primitive. We live in a yuppie neighborhood, but we went and trick-or-treated in a poorer neighborhood so we could relax a little. It was so fun.
On the way home, though, there was a situation that was scary for me. That's the story I want to tell. A bunch of boisterous drunk guys were talking to me on the train platform, and I was passing well. Then we got on the well-lit train, and they went and sat close to us and kept talking. They asked if my daughter was my sister or my niece. When I said she's my daughter, it was clear they didn't really believe me. These guys were pretty macho-acting and rough around the edges, obviously not city people, and they'd already mentioned being army guys from Alabama, so I really didn't feel safe outing myself.
So I whispered to Leah "call me dad, okay?" and kept myself carefully arrogant for the rest of their questions. They asked my age, and then didn't believe I was 30. They started honest to god quizzing me about pop culture from the eighties and early nineties. It was bizarre. I finally just turned it around and started telling the alpha guy that he looked pretty young himself, and asked him if he gets carded much.
Leah slipped up and called me "mom" at least once, but they didn't seem to notice. They were hyper-focused on the age thing. They luckily got distracted by another group of drunks (evening halloween train ftw), but I was so adrenalinized I made a beeline for the doors at our stop and left my feathery staff. Meh.
Idk. I'm leaving out so many details. I really don't know how to navigate situations like this. I feel it would be unfair to deny parentage, but then I don't want to get beat up by rednecks, either. Or even preached at. I need to get better at avoiding these kinds of discussions. Or maybe I'll always have trouble when I'm out with a preteen girl who doesn't look much younger than me. Maybe I just need facial hair, or a deeper voice.
Lol that could've been a nice tidy story, but now I'm daydreaming about all the ways I could've handled it.