Susan's Place Logo

News:

Visit our Discord server  and Wiki

Main Menu

Information on surgeons, please.

Started by Hazumu, April 25, 2007, 09:27:30 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Melissa

The 5 surgeons I have the best options of are:
Dr. Brassard
Dr. Bowers
Dr. Meltzer
Dr. Suporn
Dr. Chettawut

This is just my opinion, but I have heard almost all good things from these surgeons.  I'm sure there are many more, but these were in the list of surgeons I personally did research on.  Most of them were too cost prohibitive for me though.
  •  

Laura Eva B

Quote from: gothique11 on May 01, 2007, 06:32:52 PM
I'm going to Montreal (Dr. Bassard or Dr Menard) for my SRS sometime spring-ish or summer-ish 2008. I'm going there because they are good, and my province pays for the surgery there. I hear Meltzer is good, too (I have a friend going to Meltzer in July). Most of the post-op people I know here have gone to montreal and I haven't run into anyone with any problems, and everyone has said the results were great.

You might find that Dr Menard has retired by then ....

I can only add that my experience with Dr Brassard was first class, and my speed of recovery, lack of any complications, and cosmetic & functional result was exactly what I was hoping for.

You're lucky to have such a good surgeon on your doorstep, and a local health system which funds the surgery.

Laura x

  •  

Yvonne

I had my GRS with Dr. Bowers two years ago.  I'm German and I know I could have travelled to a few closer doctors in Belgium or the UK but didn't want to take risks. I'm happy with how everything turned out and so are my friends who have gone to her.
  •  

Maud

just to pop my head in for a rare post.......



The UK surgeons.

they're not too shabby. the sheer number of people i know who've gone to Phil Thomas and got around 6" depth excellent cosmetics, orgasmic function and a reasonable recovery speaks volumes, he's a bit expencive if you go private ('bout £10k).

Him and James bellringer both trained under Michael Royle so have similar techniques, everyone i've spoken to who went to bellringer says hes the best and everyone who's gone to thomas says he's the best.

The main differences are that thomas takes longer to do the deed  as bellringer does it like a mad dash (2 1/2 hours an op) and thomas tends to make the labia majora more baggy and puffy than bellringer, also thomas prefers to have you lie flat on your back for 5 days following the op whereas bellringer likes to get you on your feet and on a solid food diet ASAP, from what I've heard from people personally bellringer's approach to recovery is better albeit a little scarier.


Tim terry. gods does he have bad rep and honestly I'm starting to think it's undeserved. there are two pics on anne lawrence both of which are a bit gross looking one's all melty and the other just looks weird, however I know people who've gone to him and were satisfied, he seems like a terribly nice guy who'll try his best even though he's not the best he's still allright.


I'm not quite sure about what terry does but both bellringer and thomas do either two procedures typically depending on whether you were circumcised or not, a peno scrotal flap technique if you were penile inversion if you were not. obviously it's not always that way, some well endowed people who were circumcised get inversion and some people with non circumcised micropenis's get peno-scrotal flap work done.

http://www.transgenderzone.com/library/srs/1.htm

That's a good set of photo's showing how peno scrotal flap work is done, inversion is pretty similar just the bottom flap is not used and the penils skin is just sewn up on it's own and inverted, there are a few other differences also but i've never seen intra op pics.

What this all means for you is that if you're getting peno-scrotal work done you need to clear the scrotal area of hair and around the base of the penis, and if you're just getting inversion you usually just need the base cleared.

http://www.transgenderzone.com/library/ae/fulltext/27.htm

That's a good page on bellringer.


The biggest trouble with phil thomas is that he's so damn secretive, there are 4 pictures of his work on the internet, one of which is early work and looks a bit weird, one is when he was doing a two stage and the second stage was not performed so looks a bit, um, basic. and the other two on anne lawrence are fairly typical though not that great examples. He doesnt have a website bar soem vauge details on a private practice page and I can't for the life of me get hold of an email adress to contact him at, I also hear he's not very good with people skills and makes promises like not sending pictures of examples of his work when he promises to

From what I've seen in real life and via pictures sent privately his work is better than what's reflected from what you'd research on the internet and from word of mouth he's definitely the best in the UK and is a world class surgeon, if he was in america or thailand he'd definitely be a prime choice.




A little something about the thai surgeons:

The never do the vagina entrence in a manner that looks vaugely natural, like, ever. it tends to look like a big gaping hole under the vulva when it should sit at the bottom of the vulva and be enclosed by the labia, that's a big cosmetic concern for me.




Personally as you can probably guess I'm going to thomas, partly because of my competence in him but mostly due to the fact that it's free on the NHS, I just have to wait 6 months more to get my letters apply for PCT funding and sit on the waiting list.... so probably about a year.
  •  

Thundra

QuoteThe 5 surgeons I have the best options of are:
Dr. Brassard
Dr. Bowers
Dr. Meltzer
Dr. Suporn
Dr. Chettawut

This is just my opinion, but I have heard almost all good things from these surgeons.  I'm sure there are many more, but these were in the list of surgeons I personally did research on.  Most of them were too cost prohibitive for me though.

The best work I've ever...ahem...seen up close was done by Suporn and Chettawut. The results were incredibly natural-looking, sensate, and definitley had the big "O" going on. In fact, many women who knew one certain person, were jealous that she looked much better than any of them. I still do not understand why anyone would go anywhere else besides Thailand. Same surgery, same or better results, less money. You could probably get several procedures done over there for what you would pay in the states for just the bottom surgery.

Plus, with Suporn, you go to an island paradise. Surgeon + vacation. What could be better?

I've seen Meltzers work too, and I think the guy is overrated. Maybe he used to do a better job, but not anymore based on what I saw.

  •  

Laura Eva B

Quote from: Thundra on May 16, 2007, 10:37:13 PM
The best work I've ever...ahem...seen up close was done by Suporn and Chettawut. The results were incredibly natural-looking, sensate, and definitley had the big "O" going on. In fact, many women who knew one certain person, were jealous that she looked much better than any of them. I still do not understand why anyone would go anywhere else besides Thailand.

I could post more "horror pictures" and stories, needs for multiple revisions, fistulas, necrosis (of labia, and even of clitoris  :( - it happens), haematomas, poor cosmetic results, pain .... of Suporn's work than any other surgeon I know.

Sure he hits real "jackpot" sometimes, and ain't he so pleased to publicise the result on his website !

I've never seen a single girl independently post a result of Suporn's work that I myself would have been happy with except maybe after a "revision" visit .... (maybe you or others could post links to correct this ?)

The Anne Lawrence "Suporn" pics (long removed due to legal action by Suporn) rest my case.

As do Suporn pics on dedicated surgery sites.

Suporn has this really wierd idea that you can create accurate "textbook" feminine genital anatomy ... but what he creates is often truly "Frankenstein" ... sooo "up front" and gross, no "finesse" at all, a five year old's picture of how the bits look !  Other surgeons (Thai and elswhere) are less fussy in being able to "label bits" and achieve a far more natural look ...

In my opinion far better Chettawut, or better still Sanguan, who work really well, take a more "conservative" approach, and have modest egos ! (Sanguan would have been my "safe" Thai choice).

Meltzer is good and incredibly reliable, but just check out Brassard ....

Every pic / story I've heard of Brassard has been so consistent (well on a par with Suporn's upper 10 percentile ) .... yes if you're really fussy you might go back for a secondary labiaplasty / revision .... but tramping the streets of Montreal at 10 days, and work in 6 weeks is something Suporn just cannot offer.

I definitely have the big "O"  :)  - but how can you tell Thundra that anyone else other than yourself has it "going on" ????

I've been very open with posting my surgical results on really "safe TS only sites", Susan's lets visitors in ....

I'm just so glad I didn't go with popular UK opinion ... and either risk our own one or two half decent surgeons, or jet off to Thailand !

Just wish that Suporn was knocked of his "mythical" demi-God pedestal ...  and people would rationalize his true results like with any other surgeon.

(Preparing to be crucified for my observations !)

Laura


  •  

Maud

^ true, I've seen a fair few suporn results direct from the people who've gone to him and they're all so variable, what's on his site is cherry picked.
  •  

Rashelle

A little bit of firsthand experience here with Dr. Chettawut, a been there with my ex g/f look at Dr. Suporn, and a seen a bad example of Dr. sanguins.
     First off choose your own surgeon based on your opinion, as after all your are the one to have to live with the results.
     I went to Dr. Chettuwut in Bangkok and had both SRS and BA in Sept. of last year. For the most part I am happy and recommend him as a srs surgeon. I can see where the results could possibly of been a little better. But then I can see that for anything seing as we as people aren't perfect.
     I went with my at the time G/F to her SRS with Suporn in Nov/Dec of last year and stayed with her. I liked her results. Might even of been better then mine. And Suporns staff does make a wonderful effort at taking care of the patients.
     I played I'll show you mine if you'll show me yours with one of Dr. Sanguins patients who was not happy with her results and I agree I wouldn't be happy either.
     So firsthand accounts I myself would have no problem with either Dr. Chettawut or Suporn doing further work on me if I was to decide to have something else done (with the exception of I don't recommend noses by Chettawut). I know one of Suporns patients that was there with me when I was in Chonburi who she isn't happy with Suporn mainly due to attitude.
     Enough from me for now.
Rashelle
  •  

Hazumu

Interesting information on Suporn -- I went to another board, and several self-identified 'Supornistas' couldn't stop raving about his perfect results and how he fine-tunes everything in several clinic visits after surgery...

It's difficult to choose...  :eusa_think: :icon_confused2: :icon_frown: :icon_dizzy: :icon_confused:

Karen
  •  

asiangurliee

Quote from: gothique11 on May 01, 2007, 06:32:52 PM
I'm going to Montreal (Dr. Bassard or Dr Menard) for my SRS sometime spring-ish or summer-ish 2008. I'm going there because they are good, and my province pays for the surgery there. I hear Meltzer is good, too (I have a friend going to Meltzer in July). Most of the post-op people I know here have gone to montreal and I haven't run into anyone with any problems, and everyone has said the results were great.

aww really? I live in Ontario, does that mean if I move to Quebec, the province will pay me for the surgery with Dr. Bassard or Dr Menard? I though that's a private clinic?? The doctors sound really good, btw, i went to their website and it looks very professinal.
  •  

Keira


No, if your in the provicne of Quebec, they'll will pay for it but send you to another country for an operation!!!!!! because Brassard is outside the health system (he's gone private).

That's the stupidest I've ever seen.
They send people to get a major surgery on the other side of the world, when I could have one next to home and recuperate in my own appartment (I just can't wrap my head around this).


  •  

Lin

Quote from: Keira on May 20, 2007, 03:16:44 PM

No, if your in the provicne of Quebec, they'll will pay for it but send you to another country for an operation!!!!!! because Brassard is outside the health system (he's gone private).

That's the stupidest I've ever seen.
They send people to get a major surgery on the other side of the world, when I could have one next to home and recuperate in my own appartment (I just can't wrap my head around this).



I'm from Montreal, and I'm just lucky becoming a Dr.Brassard's girl recently, but I paid all the cost myself. The fact in QC is they'll pay for the op (only a part), only if you get your letter from the psychologist, who is from a certain sexuality clinic (pravite one too) in Montreal, and this clinic is controled by a group of people who are involved in the health system of QC. They charge 60-75$ for a 1h session, and what they're used to do is just try to keep their clients (they treat their patients just like clients) in their programes as long as possible before they agree to give you the letter. I was in their programe for a few sessions a couple years ago, but finally I decided to be out (smart decision!). I have some friends still in their programes for years and haven't got the paper yet. One of them even told me everytime she just felt she was facing a microphone and always repeated the same thing that she had said many times to her psychologist. As a result, the fact is you have to pay a good few thousands dollars and years to get the letter, and then finally the goverment agree to pay you a part of your surgery (something like max 10,000 CA$). That's why those, who finally get the letter from the clinic, have to go out of Canada to find some less expensive surgeons (IMO, the price in Montreal is very reasonable and worthy), cause in this way they might be able to pay their surgery fee, after they pay for the psychologist. So, finally the big part of the money offered by the gov. actually goes into the porket of the clinic, cause they control the whole province's cases by their exclusive authority (sort of monopoly). That's just like a kind of political game! The govermoent declares they pay for it, but there are some stories beneath...

Come back to the topic of this thread. The only thing I want to say is Dr. Brassard is really really good. So far I've been post-op for a bit more than 2 monthes, and he did a very good job for me. No matter the nurses or my boyfriend, they all told me it looked perfect. Specially for my bf, the surgery is like a magic. I would say he is very experienced with women (only with GG before me). He said if he wouldn't have known it, he wouldn't even have a second thought on my neo-vaginal... and for myself, I feel so lucky that I just happen to live in Montreal, and it just happens there is such a world famous clinic and surgeon in town. Frankly I didn't do much research online before the surgery(Actually I just found this great website during my recovering period at home, and this is my first post here, "Hi everyone and thanks! :)" ). I just naturally decided to go for Dr. Brassard directly, and when I saw him for the first sight, my 6th sense told me he would be just the surgeon that I've been waiting for many years since I was a few years old... and plus he is so charming and attractive...  ;) Now even luckier, every a few weeks I can see him again (his clinic is just 10 mins from my home). He gonna follow my whole recovering period and check how it is going every so often... I feel much safer in this way, and that's also one of the most important reasons that I chose him...

PS. Dr. Menard hasn't totally retired yet, but he does do less job at present. Around one month ago, I was lucky to have him checking up my healing state in the clinic, cause that week Dr. Brassard was in vacation. He is such a kind and experieced matured man... I remember while I opened the door to leave the clinic, he told me "walk slowly and be careful", cause that day there was a big storm outside, which was unusual in April even for the cold Montreal...
Quote from: Steph on May 01, 2007, 08:18:35 PM

...

As you know I chose Brassard and although you have probably read my write up on my experience in my blog I would just add that I had no regrets and I would and plan to return for further surgeries (possible BA).

Just my thoughts.

Steph


Hi Steph, I'm a Dr. Brassard's girl too. I just had my op in March, and I had both GRS&BA at the same time (less expensive & less pain). I think it would be a very good ideal if you decide to come back for Dr.B for BA. As 2 monthes post-op, my breasts have become very soft and much natural looking... I'm very happy and satisfied with the result...
  •  

Thundra

Quote(Preparing to be crucified for my observations !)

Laura

For being honest about how you feel?  No way. Not from me. I like you, can only give an opinion based on my own observations. If you feel Suporn is unreliable, than avoid him at all costs. It has simply been my observation, that in the limited sample of women I have seen, that Suporn did beautiful work. And, being a frugal person, I am all about why pay more if you do not need to? I have known numerous women that have gone to Thailand, paid less than 10K for their surgery and a few other things, in addition to lodging and food, and all of them had excellent results -- including the big "O" and having it going on as far as the partners they attract. I know of no one so far, that regrets their trip to Thailand.

If anyone has had less than positive results from the likes any Thai surgeon, than I have not had contact with any of them. I don't have much of an opinion on the Canadian surgeons, because I have not seen their work up close and personal. Based on the pics supplied the AL site, I would say, that in my opinion, the visual results seemed adequate but not as attractive as others I have seen. But that is just my opinion.
  •  

Lin

Quote from: Karen on April 25, 2007, 09:27:30 PM
...

So I discussed this with my therapist.  She gave me the 'homework' assignment of researching SRS horror stories.  I said I'd already googled the term and all the variations I could think of, but didn't come up with all that much.  She said, try again.  I did.  Still, paltry results (and I think I'm pretty darned good at teasing information out of the 'net with Google...)

So, if you've already found sites with good first person accounts of the good -- but more importantly the bad -- could you please post the links here?

I wanna' get an 'A' in my assignment  ;D

Thank you;

Karen

Hi Kraren, these a few links include some horror stories happened in Thailand... Hope it's not too late to help you to get an "A" in your assignment...

1. Dissatisfaction With Dr. Pichet : http://www.annelawrence.com/pichetdissatisfaction.html
2. Dr. Pichet Rodchareon, February 2003, #1 : http://www.annelawrence.com/pichet02031.html (Be careful, the pic could be a bit horrible)
3. Dr. Pichet Rodchareon, February 2003, #2 : http://www.annelawrence.com/pichet02032.html
4. SRS with Dr. Preecha: A Cautionary Tale : http://www.annelawrence.com/preechanarrative.html
  •  

Thundra

Last quote I heard on Pichet is that Preecha never even trained him for that surgery, and wished he'd stop. Stay away from THAT guy for sure.

Dr. Preecha is an enigma of sorts. This is after all, the big kahuna of Thai SRS, but like Biber down in Colorado, he has long overstayed his welcome in the OR. His surgery team has great respect and admiration for him, but I think even they dislike having to fix some of his surgery on the down low. It is against custom in Thailand for a student to correct the work of the teacher, so if you choose Preecha, you may have a problem getting it fixed.

Right now, the buzz I have heard is that Chettawut is the guy of the hour. They all pretty much use the same hospitals and staff.
  •  

Laura Eva B

Quote from: Asianrose on May 28, 2007, 10:40:53 AM
I just naturally decided to go for Dr. Brassard directly, and when I saw him for the first sight, my 6th sense told me he would be just the surgeon that I've been waiting for many years since I was a few years old... and plus he is so charming and attractive...  ;)

Isn't he just !!!



Class of Aug 14 / 15th 2006 (me 2nd from left)  :)

Laura x

  •  

tinkerbell

  •  

Keira


Brassard....  :icon_biggrin: ... Sorry, I was lost in my toughts...

I saw him several times because
I had my rhino + brow bossing with him and
I decided seperately on both ops, so I got to visit him twice for
evaluation visits before the op.

I would have got another ops just to have him examine some more, hehe.

Yeah, very handsome and since I'm french canadian, I speak his language :-).

Its funny, I mentioned to my therapist how attractive he was and she seriously said it would be unethical for him to go out with me because I was his patient ;D :D, Like there was any chance that he'd leave his wife and I think god knows how many children and be attracted to little me... For a moment, I did have this mental fantasy though. All PG rated... Of course hehe.

The strange thing is that my therapist has known him for more than 10 years and knows, so why tell me such a strange thing!! Is he know for affairs ?  >:D (that's probably another fantasy of mine  :angel:)

I saw him 3 times after my FFS because I had minor complications with my sutures, I got a bad reaction to the threads and the scar did not want to heal for a month, and also he removed the plaster on my nose.

After that, I kinda wish I had other slight complications so I could return... I'm suppose to see him this autumn for my 1 year followup.

I think I have a slight crush on the guy, maybe that's what the therapist saw :-).






  •  

Thundra

Quoteone of the most handsome men alive?

I wouldn't know?  ::yawn::

Thundra
  •  

Lin

Quote from: Laura Eva B on June 06, 2007, 03:51:18 PM
Quote from: Asianrose on May 28, 2007, 10:40:53 AM
I just naturally decided to go for Dr. Brassard directly, and when I saw him for the first sight, my 6th sense told me he would be just the surgeon that I've been waiting for many years since I was a few years old... and plus he is so charming and attractive...  ;)

Isn't he just !!!



Class of Aug 14 / 15th 2006 (me 2nd from left)  :)

Laura x



What a nice pic, everyone had a great smile! :laugh: I can see the pic was taken in the recovery clinic, right? You know what? Actually, I just met Dr.Brassard this afternon to have my regular post-op check-up, again I just cant help myself to say he is so cute, charming and well-mannered... actually he looks even much better in person than in pics... I remember the night just before our op, my roommate and I were still discussing how cute he was...  ;)

Here I've to mention my overall experience of the surgery was very nice except the disappointement of the recovery clinic. I've heard a lot of great stories and experience about the famous La Maison de l'Isle, so I was looking forward to something similar about the new recovery place, but unfortunately it turns out to be a cold/boring clinic (mixed with different type of patients from different private hospitals), no any family atmosphere like the old place (La Maison de l'Isle). I got the feeling it's more like a business/benifit orentated clinic with an un pleasant location... I've heard Dr.B is planning to buy a place just nearby his hospital to build his own recovery residence. Hope this will come to be true soon...
Quote from: Keira on June 06, 2007, 11:00:02 PM

Brassard.... 

I would have got another ops just to have him examine some more, hehe.

Yeah, very handsome...



You know everytime when I leave his office, I start to count in how many weeks/days I'll have my next rendez-vous (appointment) with him...   ;)
Quote from: Keira on June 06, 2007, 11:00:02 PM

Its funny, I mentioned to my therapist how attractive he was and she seriously said it would be unethical for him to go out with me because I was his patient ;D :D, Like there was any chance that he'd leave his wife and I think god knows how many children and be attracted to little me... For a moment, I did have this mental fantasy though. All PG rated... Of course hehe.


Don't even think about it... He has 4 children, and he once showed me his youngest son's pic. From his eyes I could see how much he loves his family, wife and kids... I guess this great quality makes a man more charming... Probably that's why we all love him... :)

Btw, I've ever discussed with him that how a man would feel a neo-vagina during an intercourse with a post-op... and he told me the feeling might be...%@#% ... I joked to him if he had some real expereince, he answered no, and he would never touch his patients... here you go... :icon_mrhappy:
Quote from: Keira on June 06, 2007, 11:00:02 PM

... I think I have a slight crush on the guy, maybe that's what the therapist saw :-).


That's pretty normal to crush on a guy like him... You know what? Actually my therapist happens to know him too, and before I went to see him, my therapist told me that "il est un belhomme" (he is a good looking man). I didn't really keep that in my mind (never lack of male admirers :P), but after I saw him in person and talked to him, I began to realise why many of his patients said "He is a very good surgeon, but he is cute too!"  ;D
  •