Quote from: FreshGuy on February 12, 2013, 08:31:48 AM
Hey, can you elaborate what you meant about the depression test things? And how does it relate? Thanks, it seems interesting.
It's not the best comparison in the world, but when I was younger, twelve to fourteen I think, I took a lot of online depression tests. I wanted an explanation for why I felt the way I did about life, death and generally why I always felt so sad and down. I think I was scared that I wouldn't be 'depressed enough' because I would lose the only explanation that I felt was legitimate, and after the first couple of times I got so hung up on what answers would give what results that I found it hard to be honest. I almost felt disappointed when the results got better, because then I wouldn't have a reason to feel the way I did anymore, and that meant that I was crazy and fitted in no where for no reason -- looking back that was probably because I was trans and the guys didn't want to be see hanging around with a 'girl'.
When I got referred to my GP they asked the same basic diagnostic questions as the online tests did, and by that point I was unable to answer honestly for myself because I knew what each answer would tell him. If I gave the answers that would lead to depression then what would they do, I might get medication, but would it take my mind away from me? If I gave the answers that would say I was okay then everyone would just think I was a faker and want to know why. If I gave him the truth... what was the truth and what was I just trying to project onto myself to get the answers I wanted? I'd over thought things to the point that I didn't know what I honestly felt any more.
I see this relating to you because you seem like you're looking for specific answers. Everything that you're saying that isn't the general characteristics of a trans person is always suffixed with "but it could just be denial." Yes, it could be some sort of denial, but that's for you to work out, we can only help you by commenting on what we're told, and if you're not able to be entirely honest with yourself, or fishing for specific answers -- not saying that you're conscious that you're doing it -- we'll definitely not be able to be that useful. Seeing someone in real life would make it easier, but I think you mentioned something about getting messed around by the NHS before? (Apologies if I've gotten the wrong person.) Well, join the club mate. It's always worth giving them another go though, because I don't believe that if my experiences were widespread that there would be any shrinks left in the country. I've also got a temperament that doesn't match well with the average airy-fairy shrink, so you might fare better.
Have you ever flipped a coin and got disappointed by the answer so you do a best of three, and then a best of five, and then decide to go against it anyway? By flipping that coin and setting up rules about what would happen if you got heads, or if you got tails, it helps you to work out what you really want by whether you're disappointed by the results or not. Obviously this is more suited to working out whether you should have porridge or pancakes for breakfast (pancakes seeing as it's pancake day!) than deciding what gender you are, but the basic theory is there. If I flipped a coin and said, if it's heads I have to come out to everyone and sign my deed poll, if it's tails then I have to delete my Susans account, tell my girlfriend it was all a mistake and never think of trans things again, I would feel devastated if it came up tails. Just thinking about it makes me want to curl up into a ball for the rest of time. We might think we want things, but at the end of the day it's when the other options are seemingly taken away from us we decide what we really need.
A couple of people have suggested working through your other issues first before trying to determine whether or not you are trans. That's always a good idea, and what a good shrink will have you do first, or alongside any trans issues if you go to see them questioning your gender. If there is a root to your constant thinking that you're trans then it's better for everyone if that root is fixed, rather than just sticking you on hormones. Not saying that being trans is caused by a root, but in your case it seems like there may be some OCD or anxiety which is leading you to fixate on this, like others have said. I don't have any personal experience with illnesses like those so I can't really comment too much there, other than to see people about it.
Where there any other triggers that started you thinking this way? You've said you were dressing up as Sporty Spice in your room and started wondering whether or not it meant you were trans. From what you've told us, you were dressing up because you were going out in a group all dressed up, rather than doing it to really experiment or feel comfortable. Okay, so you might not have had to dress up there and then but could have waited until the night, but it's pretty natural to wanting to see how things look, especially when they're not "allowed". It's like me as a little kid attempting to put make up on, did that make me grow up into a woman? Heck no, I wouldn't go near the stuff now. I just wanted to see what it would look like. I'm just a little confused how that seems to have sparked off this whole worrying about whether or not you're trans, and whether you're going to lose your penis.
And on the matter of the penis, no one is going to force you to have it removed, and with MTF SRS it's not just hacked off anyway, whether you are or aren't trans. And as far as I am aware it's perfectly normal to have it shrink and the balls retract in cold weather, something to do with regulating temperatures I'm assuming, so I wouldn't worry there.
This is more relevant to another thread you've started, but I'm going to post it here because I'm lazy:
Transgender and transsexual don't mean the same things. I would say that someone who doesn't identify as their birth sex entirely would be transgender. I think if you're perfectly comfortable with your body and how society views you without doing anything to change you from your assigned gender ("what you were born as" *cringe*) then you're not transgender. That's just my take on it though, and the definitions vary a lot, even within this site. A man who dresses up as a woman once does not make him trans, or a crossdresser. If he enjoys it and does it regularly then yes, I could say that it did make him a crossdresser, but wouldn't stop him being male. Hundreds of women, lesbian and otherwise, wear men's clothes, that doesn't mean that they're all crossdressers though in my eyes. It's a complicated world out there when you're talking about clearly defining things so complex and entwined in society and stereotypes as this.
I
personally would say that:
- If you want and desire surgery or hormones then you are "transsexual", even if you cannot afford them, or it would be medically unsafe so you refrain.
- If you dress as the opposite gender to perform then you are a drag king/queen.
- If you dress as the opposite gender because it's sexy to you then you are a ->-bleeped-<- (what lovely pictures that word brings up.)
- If you dress as the opposite gender because you want to then I would say that it's good for you and f- the labels, but some would class you as a CD, especially if you're dressing in female clothes as a male. I don't like defining this because there seems to be a double standard between men and women, no one would call my girlfriend a CD, but she's always wearing her dad and brothers clothes, but if my dad threw on my mother's trousers then there would be a stir.
More importantly though, stop worrying about labels. Some people find them comforting, and they're useful to find people like you I suppose, but that's all they're really good for. I don't know what my sexuality is, and it doesn't matter to me, I like who I like, and okay if I had to I would probably tell you that I was a straight demisexual, but it doesn't feel important to me. Am I transgender or transsexual? I'm probably "officially" transsexual, but to me I'm just male. Forget the labels, who are you underneath them all? How would you explain how you felt about your gender etc to a small child who had never heard those words?