Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

Sympathy for the Devil?

Started by ABadGuy, November 13, 2013, 03:11:50 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

ABadGuy

So... I'm not sure how to begin this... I can be a bit shy about these sorts of things, and tend to default to bluntness just to get the words out. I would like to preface though, by saying this. I am not lurking around for nookie, or trying in anyway to foster any king of relationship, sexual or otherwise, with this post. Circumstances in my current life are not conducive to romance, as such I am abstinent... despite how much I hate it, hehe. I would also like to say that, I don't use most of these terms often, so if I screw up, and use a word in a wrong way, I am very sorry. I'm not trying to be an . I also want to say, I'm not trying to break any rules here. The topic at had, in a very simplistic view, can be considers "sexually orientated", but its is so much more in my mind...

The reason I am posting this here is two fold... three technically. A: I want the views of a trans community. B: I have perused this forum a few times, and you guys (unknowingly) helped me when I was having a hard time. C: You all seemed very cool, and very... tolerant.  So... Lets throw myself into the fire, huh?

I have a question for the transgender community. Why am I the 'bad guy'?

I have a confession that I have never really told anybody. I am sexually attracted to pre-op transsexual women... I'm that "straight guy" (more on that later) that wants to have a sexual relationship with a woman that has male parts down there....

Now, this is not to say I am only sexually attracted to this. I have the same physical desire for woman. Rarely I have had the same attraction towards men, though that has been few an far between. Truth be told, I don't consider my self hetero. Though, when asked, it is just easier to say that then to describe fully what I find to be sexually attractive... And, if I'm being honest, I don't want to deal with the hassle from some jackwagon who thinks that these issues are simple A or B matters.

Specifically, I don't really consider myself straight. Or gay. Or bi... I guess queer would work, if that wasn't a loaded term in some communities. I don't really consider myself anything. I am. And I enjoy things. And if you enjoy something, you should do it... so long as you are not harming anybody. Its really that simple.

Now... what originally directed me to this rant/query/ whatever it is I'm writing, was this...

While wandering around online I somehow stumbled into a discussion of other blokes pretty much talking about how much they would like to "<not allowed>" a "->-bleeped-<-" and other * like that. While distasteful, individual people where more respectful, and that kept me reading. As the discussion evolved, it grew into a "why do I like this am I gay OH NOES!!1!" type bs. And then a post from a trans woman. 'traits of guys that like trans-women' or something along these lines...

I clicked the link, and read through them, curios what she had to say as an "insider" as-it-were.  And this is where that little devil on my shoulder started telling me to punch someone in the throat... She made these huge sweeping generalizations. Using terms to describe people like me such as:

"low self esteam",
Okay.. I admit. I have some self esteem issues. But these are spawned from a hard life and a bunch of screw ups, and have NOTHING to do with my sexuality.

"insecurties, paranoia, nervous, scared, shy,"
Again, I'll relent a bit. I am shy. I'm shy around girls, boys, people, crowds, speaking in public, yada yada. Shy isn't bad.. It just is. But most "natural" females I have known consider shy guys to be "cute"

"very confused"   "suffering from some sort of sexual idenity crissis. They don't know if there gay, straight, bisexual, or curious, lol."   "never stay faithfull towards u. Because since there bisexual, a girl with a vagina, and a girl with a penis, they will always go back and forth, and will never settle down with just one gender."
Again,  I will give in a bit. At first, when I was trying to understand my own sexuality, there was a bit of confusion, including a brief period of time I thought I may be trans myself... but, after some deep thought, the confusion cleared.... Are you sure the "men" you are dating aren't boys in disguise? As for 'choosing a gender' to be attracted to... How dare you.... How  dare you.

"not alpha males."
Hehehe... How old are you? Seriously? Grow up. Humans don't even come close to that sort of social structure. "Alpha Males" are guys that have security issues... or at least everyone that I have met.

"(Total bottom )"
If anybody (outside of a romantic lover in a very particular setting) said anything like this to me, I would show them what a "" could do with a sledgehammer.... (No.. I'm not actually saying I would hurt her. Just fuming)

"pathological LIERS"
On average humans tell dozens of lies a day... HUMANS...

"There pretty much, geeks, wierd, nerds and just * up, lol."
Since when are geeks bad? Geeks and nerds, if you haven't noticed, own and run the world now... AS for * up... well again, I have lived a hard life. It leaves scars. I'm sure you can understand that... Now, correct me if I am wrong, but thats part of being in a relationship. Helping the person you love deal with bad stuff... >.> At least, that's what I've done.

"cheap skates"
Seriously, what kind of people are you seeing?

"total cowards,  aka =losers"
I have, literally, stepped in front of a charging bear to protect my girlfriend at that time.... cowardice in its purest form.

"in fact homophobic".
<not allowed> ....

Now that I had my say, let us continue...

I guess it wouldn't bother me so much, and I would just chalk it up to stupid is as stupid does... but the response from other trans woman these comments got... The only time I have seen such vitriol is when bigots verbally assault... trans people.

In part, I want to say this...

I am a physical being. Nature has programed me to be attracted to certain forms of stimulation, based upon my five senses and emotion. Among this stimuli I am attracted to are cupcakes, Hawaiian pizza, being hugged, Death Metal, certain voices ( I would make love to Corey Taylors vocal cords if I could :P ),  "pretty things", cool and dark colors, the feeling of snow under my feet, the warmth of lips pressed against mine, the presence of someone I care about, the feeling of my hair being pulled, the sensation of things in my mouth, and yes..

You cannot tell me that, as a physical being, you don't respond to certain stimuli also? A lover nibbling on you earlobe? A cuddle on the couch while watching a  movie? I could go on...

As a trans, you should understand this next question well... What if society (or an element there of) shunned you for feeling a certain way. What if you were called things you where not. Gay. , Man, Woman, Freak. ...... would you like me to continue?

So... I like the idea ( I cannot say more than that due to me never having actually been with one) of being with a pre-op trans-woman.... or do I? Cause truth be told, the idea of a woman with a strap-on hits most of the same sexual triggers.... So lets say this instead... I like the idea of being with a woman that has something extra... or not... Maybe a very pretty bloke instead. Here. This is what I like.. I like having a sexual relationship with a person that is aggressive or "dominant" in the bedroom. There we are... Can none of you say the same?

But of course, cause I'm the "->-bleeped-<- ->-bleeped-<-" I'm the bad guy... I'm the scum... even though I have not once engaged a single trans-woman for sex...

Ah... sex... Maybe thats our problem... sex.

Sex is good. Except for a handful or rare cases, everybody loves sex. But sex is NOT a relationship... just as sex IS NOT gender....

Now, I don't know if these woman that had all these negative things to say about people like me are just bad at choosing romantic interests... or what... But a lot of it seems to be based off of that terrible three letter word that causes so much strife.

From what I understand, and have witnessed (much to my dismay) woman (which if it is like I understand it, thats what trans women are) like to be treated like a woman. In bed and otherwise. Understandable. I like to be treated a certain way in bed and otherwise to... and if I'm not getting that, I am missing something I "need".

Do you know what grown-ups do when they aren't being fulfilled in a relationship? (Granted, this is the ideal, and so few people are able to  do so... more on that later.) They separate. And then they go find someone that can give them what they "need". Hopefully, barring in bad circumstances, they can remain friends with their prior lover... but sadly that isn't as often as it should be...Admittedly sometimes for the better though.

I could go into how relationships work, or should, but lets keep this brief (cause I'm doing a bang up job with that).

The sex thing is only a small part of a functional relationship. If this is your basis for a relationship, then your... 

What about the important stuff? Attraction. Both physical and mental. What about emotional attraction? The power of sex, so far as I understand it, is nothing compared to the power of love. Might sound like hippy bs... but its true. After all, I wouldn't step in front of a charging ursine for a good <not allowed>... But I wouldn't even think about it if love was on the line. 

...

One of the responders to the wretch of a woman that triggered this, made a few more rational statements...

She described the tendency of her past relationships to be 'hit it and quit it'. That the blokes she hooked up with just wanted to play (which, imo, is fine so long as both parties understand this) and how they were not interested in her as a person . Her "advanced science degrees" or "professional art".... I am truly sorry for this... it really does suck that she was being treated like a sex object. I know me personally, if I found a lady into the sciences as much as I am.... wow...

But that's beside the point.. She was being treated like an object... and that sucks.. I am truly sorry that some guys are  like that... but, and I'm sorry to say, welcome to the world as a woman.

There are MANY guys that are only interested in playing... which could be okay, if who they want to play with is cool with that. But if this is your ONLY experience... you have some real questions to ask yourself.

What kind of jerks are you dating? Why give "it" up so quickly? There is a reason that there is the "gatekeeper" perception of woman's sexuality... cause, if you want to find some one that is genuinely interested in a meaningful and productive relationship... you kinda gotta be.

Now, I'm not saying this tendency to just be after a <not allowed> is exclusive to males, but it is more common in blokes than chicas.

If you are one of these girls that having these kind of issues with guys, I first want to say I am sorry. Next I want to say is... keep trying.

I am one person, so I am hardly a decent sample size... but I don't see how I could be the only male on the face of the planet after more than a <not allowed>. Its just.. VERY unlikely... And despite my experience deprived, but deeply desired, relationship with a lady with something extra... Even if I met the physical ideal of what I want... I STILL would not sleep with her. I want to make sure, first, that we get along. That we can converse and enjoy each others company. That we have enough similar interests to enjoy together, but enough different ones so we get our private time. And then we have to make sure she is at least roughly as smart as me (preferably smarter)... and that she can handle all the "baggage" I come attached to, and I hers (I cant imagine her life was easy in this age of bigotry). IE... We have to start falling in love first.. then MAYBE (lets be honest, Probably....) I would sleep with her... And then it gets a bit more complicated, as we have to make sure we are into the same things.... I can't be the only male with my 'kink' that feels the same way... But I'm just a dirty pervert fetishist, so what does my word matter...

Lets be honest... The above is virtually impossible to attain... Chances are you arn't gonna find a * insert desired type here *. You aren't, and nor are 90% of the people on this planet. You gonna have to settle on something... I suggest you take an ugly guy who loves you, over a "alpha male" who wants you to... Just as I'm gonna have to settle... I'm never gonna find the ideal, let alone a "dominant" woman who is attracted to me for myself... so I'm gonna have to settle on that front. Thems the apples. Hope you can live with them.

I understand the life of a trans person (and anyone who doesn't fall into the binary mold) can be very hard. And at the end of the day, it can leave you feeling very lonely and very insecure... I feel like that to. And I understand what its like to be labeled as * pick your derogatory *, thats what sparked this rant. And I understand that you prolly feel some frustration that people are treating you like an object and not the awesome person you are. I cant really say I know what that feels like though... I wish I did. (if only to know what to say to soothe the welts it leaves).... but... As the Dread Pirate Roberts said "Life is pain!" (anyone that tells you otherwise is a liar, or trying to sell you something). But its through these pains, or the conquering of,  that we receive clarity. And humanity. It makes us strong. It teaches us right and wrong. And, with a bit of luck, it brings us to the arms of someone we love, and someone that loves us.

I feel like there is a lot I left unsaid (more like ranted). And I feel like I said too much. I hope what I wrote didn't hurt anyone... And I hope you can understand why I am so upset. But  who cares... I'm just a scumbag fetishist.

Addendum

I couldn't really find a place to work this in.. and am not quite sure I should. But I'm trying to be as honest and forthright as possible.

Like I said, I am abstinent for personal reasons. This is not to say I don't masturbate. And, if you read above, you can guess what porn I prefer. I do want to say this. I feel guilty about it. Constantly. Mind you, I have no guilt about liking kinky stuff.... I feel guilty about other things.

I understand in the pornography world, there is ALOT of exploitation or trans folk (mostly of trans-woman).  This is what I feel guilty about.  Even the thought crossing my mind that this woman hates the body she was born with, and is only doing this to pave the way to full transition. I feel unrelenting guilt that she even may feel disgusted/exploited/ or used.... This does weigh on me. I feel horrible that my sexual desire could be, inadvertently, harming someone... It literally makes me want to puke.

I try hard to stay away from this... I try to only consume material that is written word or hand/computer generated. Though I do, sometimes, lapse... the desire to see a physical being outweighing my humanity... and I feel filthy for that.

For this, I want to say, I am sorry.
  •  

Cindy

I will tolerate your post now I have cleaned it up.

However we are not a dating site and I am very unsure of your intentions in posting.

I advise you to read the Terms of Service in the announcement section.
  •  

Danielle Emmalee

I'm so confused....sorry, I'm not sure if it's because it's been edited but I just don't get it.  What are you trying to say, or ask?
Discord, I'm howlin' at the moon
And sleepin' in the middle of a summer afternoon
Discord, whatever did we do
To make you take our world away?

Discord, are we your prey alone,
Or are we just a stepping stone for taking back the throne?
Discord, we won't take it anymore
So take your tyranny away!
  •  

Sammy

I feel that I kinda get what he is trying to tell and this was very insightful post (maybe because it resonates with my current feelings and experiences) - apart of profanity which was timely edited, of course.
Such a pity that the old "Sexuality" thread is locked away for subscribers only - this would fit in there just purrrfectly :). I am looking forwards to an interesting discussion here, before I jump in with my own assumptions - which are likewise purely theoretical at the moment. But I always like to know what the other side thinks about all of this :).
So, yeah, this Devil got my symphaties for the time being :)

By the way, speaking about this porn thing... (I am actually surprised how this comes up quite often lately), I spoke with an insolent and ignorant gay guy last Saturday and I was trying to educate him just for fun :P. He was puzzled what is the audience for that kind of porn and well, I told him that most of them are straight guys which was a total surprise for him too. But it was necessary to tell him that porn is porn (essentially it is a fairytale for kinky adults... if I might say so) and guys searching for that kind of experience in the real life are up for some surprises. You said that You have not yet... So, I sort of wanted to warn You that You might be "surprised" too. You seem to understand fairly well that most of pre-op MtF TS-girls are not really into their lower parts and would prefer to leave them outside of "play". The other thing, which is sort of interconnected with the previous point - and often being neglected by guys posting in those threads "Here is a pic of /insert pretty pre-op TS/ - would You do her?" - they have no idea what kind of effects the anti-androgens and estrogen therapy has on one's libido and physical capability. She would not be willing to engage into kinky acts, plus, being chemically castrated - she would not be physically able to either (this is not porn, remember?). So, do You still wanna...? :P
  •  

Danielle Emmalee

I read it a couple more times and I kinda finally clued in.  There's often a lot of assumptions from transgender people when it comes to that, somewhat understandably.  You can't help who you're attracted to but the sad thing is porn gives a lot of men the wrong impression of what the majority of transwomen are like.  And some of those men make all trans-oriented men look the same, whether or not they are actually all objectifying and/or disrespectful
Discord, I'm howlin' at the moon
And sleepin' in the middle of a summer afternoon
Discord, whatever did we do
To make you take our world away?

Discord, are we your prey alone,
Or are we just a stepping stone for taking back the throne?
Discord, we won't take it anymore
So take your tyranny away!
  •  

Cindy

I am for obvious reasons monitoring this closely. Let us be careful with being disrespectful to any group.

I will remove the thread if there is any hint of disrespect to anyone.
  •  

Danielle Emmalee

I have a sneaking suspicion the OP is not coming back and this was a one off post. 
Discord, I'm howlin' at the moon
And sleepin' in the middle of a summer afternoon
Discord, whatever did we do
To make you take our world away?

Discord, are we your prey alone,
Or are we just a stepping stone for taking back the throne?
Discord, we won't take it anymore
So take your tyranny away!
  •  

Cindy

Possibly. It is their privilege.

But there are some thoughts of interest. Many of us are looking for men to date. Is there anything wrong (?) in dating a man who likes you or rather is initially attracted to you because you are transgender?

I would say not. Men are attracted to woman and woman to men for many reasons. It is the establishment of a meaningful relationship that is important for me. Initial attraction is just that.
  •  

FTMDiaries

Thanks Cindy.

Quote from: ABadGuy on November 13, 2013, 03:11:50 AM
The reason I am posting this here is two fold... three technically.

A: I want the views of a trans community. B: I have perused this forum a few times, and you guys (unknowingly) helped me when I was having a hard time. C: You all seemed very cool, and very... tolerant.  So... Lets throw myself into the fire, huh?
A: I am not a community, just an individual, but I'm happy to give you the benefit of my experience. B: Glad you found some help here. C: Yes, we are indeed very, very cool.

Quote from: ABadGuy on November 13, 2013, 03:11:50 AM
I'm that "straight guy" (more on that later) that wants to have a sexual relationship with a woman that has male parts down there....
You will find that the vast majority of women who have 'male parts down there' are enormously uncomfortable about their presence... because growing up with male features meant that other people could use this as a weapon to hurt them by invalidating their identities. Most of them just want to be seen as ordinary, everyday, garden-variety women, and having somebody want them specifically because they have male parts is deeply offensive and upsetting to many of them. I daresay the transwomen you encountered there have come across that kind of guy, and if they're deeply hurt and offended by the way they've been treated by those guys, that is very understandable. Please don't take what they said personally: they don't know you as an individual... but likewise, you don't know them or what they've suffered to get to where they are today.

As I suspect you already know, Gender Dysphoria isn't a kink or a fetish or a sexual thrill where a lady has a penis or a guy has a vagina for teh lulz. It's a deep-seated horror at the fact that the rest of the world demands you fit into a gender role that is inappropriate to you. It's spending every day walking down the street with people calling you 'madam' instead of 'sir' - or vice versa - and every single time they do it is like a slap in the face. It's looking down at your body, seeing its secondary sexual characteristics, and crying your eyes out because it's so very, very wrong for your body to be shaped this way. If somebody else finds that sexually stimulating, that's pretty darn cruel towards the person who has suffered all this pain and anguish for so many years. That's the reason why I won't enter into another sexual relationship until I've had my surgery: I can't stomach the thought of some guy wanting to use the equipment I was born with.... because when they do, they think of me as a woman and I just can't bear that kind of pain.

Quote from: ABadGuy on November 13, 2013, 03:11:50 AM
While wandering around online I somehow stumbled into a discussion of other blokes pretty much talking about how much they would like to "<not allowed>" a "->-bleeped-<-" and other * like that. While distasteful, individual people where more respectful, and that kept me reading. As the discussion evolved, it grew into a "why do I like this am I gay OH NOES!!1!" type bs. And then a post from a trans woman. 'traits of guys that like trans-women' or something along these lines...
Yes, that kind of discussion is very distasteful. But it's important to remember something: humans are, as a species, bisexual in nature. That means that we are all theoretically open to sexual contact with anyone, but our societies have socialised us into thinking that certain natural behaviours are shameful or taboo. This can make them titillating, which leads to some people developing fetishes.

The reason why guys like the ones in that thread want to <not allowed> a '->-bleeped-<-' is because deep down, they have homosexual tendencies (as do most of us) but due to cultural reasons they have a deep aversion to being 'gay', so they think a transsexual woman with male parts is the perfect solution. And they think this because, deep down, they think of the transsexual woman as being 'a woman who is really a man', so in their twisted logic it doesn't count as being 'gay', whilst at the same time it kinda does, so it hits all their buttons.

Can you see why we might find that deeply offensive? Those of us who have spent an entire lifetime trying to convince the rest of the world of the truth of our identities are hardly going to respond positively to people who invalidate us in that way. And truth be told, 'heterosexual' men are far more averse to homosexual experiences than 'heterosexual' women are, so transwomen tend to suffer this kind of invalidation much more than transmen do.

The lady who posted those generalisations - and I agree some may be a little rude or inaccurate, but many have at least a grain of truth in them - has probably met quite a few guys who have invalidated and hurt her in this way.

The 'in fact, homophobic' comment hits the fricken nail on the head when describing that kind of guy. Perhaps not you specifically, but it does describe that kind of guy in general. See, they want to have sex with a man, but are too homophobic to... well, have sex with a man. So they go for a transwoman instead because they think of her as a man-but-not-really. That's not just homophobic, it's massively transphobic too.

Quote from: ABadGuy on November 13, 2013, 03:11:50 AM
So... I like the idea ( I cannot say more than that due to me never having actually been with one) of being with a pre-op trans-woman.... or do I? Cause truth be told, the idea of a woman with a strap-on hits most of the same sexual triggers.... So lets say this instead... I like the idea of being with a woman that has something extra... or not... Maybe a very pretty bloke instead. Here. This is what I like.. I like having a sexual relationship with a person that is aggressive or "dominant" in the bedroom. There we are... Can none of you say the same?
If the idea of a woman with a strap-on hits most of the same triggers, then great! Go for it. If you can find a transwoman who is happy to use her original equipment, then great! Go for it. If you'd like a pretty boy, then great! Go for it. But please be respectful of your lover, and don't ever ask anyone to do anything they're uncomfortable with just because you'd like to try it.

Quote from: ABadGuy on November 13, 2013, 03:11:50 AM
From what I understand, and have witnessed (much to my dismay) woman (which if it is like I understand it, thats what trans women are) like to be treated like a woman. In bed and otherwise. Understandable. I like to be treated a certain way in bed and otherwise to... and if I'm not getting that, I am missing something I "need".
Yes, absolutely. You're entitled to what you need in bed, just like everyone else. But what you need should never be at the expense of your lover's happiness, self-worth or comfort. It should never make them feel bad about themselves. That's the idea of consensual sex. And you'll find that many transwomen won't feel happy or comfortable about being made to take a traditional male role in bed, because that just echoes the heartache, abuse and self-denial they had to suffer for so many years. Just like I did by having to take a traditional female role in bed.

Quote from: ABadGuy on November 13, 2013, 03:11:50 AM
But that's beside the point.. She was being treated like an object... and that sucks.. I am truly sorry that some guys are  like that... but, and I'm sorry to say, welcome to the world as a woman.
I'm glad you're showing compassion for that situation. You're right that this is the world as a woman. I know that only too well, having been forced to suffer it for several decades. But that doesn't make it okay, and it doesn't mean that you have to perpetuate the suffering. So please do whatever you can to not be that guy, OK?

Quote from: ABadGuy on November 13, 2013, 03:11:50 AM
What kind of jerks are you dating? Why give "it" up so quickly? There is a reason that there is the "gatekeeper" perception of woman's sexuality... cause, if you want to find some one that is genuinely interested in a meaningful and productive relationship... you kinda gotta be.
Aren't you the guy who just a few paragraphs before talked about having needs that you should expect to be fulfilled? Well, don't women have needs too? Aren't women also sexual beings? Aren't they entitled to have their needs fulfilled, just like you?

Quote from: ABadGuy on November 13, 2013, 03:11:50 AM
Lets be honest... The above is virtually impossible to attain... Chances are you arn't gonna find a * insert desired type here *. You aren't, and nor are 90% of the people on this planet. You gonna have to settle on something... I suggest you take an ugly guy who loves you, over a "alpha male" who wants you to... Just as I'm gonna have to settle... I'm never gonna find the ideal, let alone a "dominant" woman who is attracted to me for myself... so I'm gonna have to settle on that front. Thems the apples. Hope you can live with them.
Please don't presume to tell any of my sisters here that they should settle for less than they deserve because they're never going to find the right guy. If you choose to settle for less than you deserve, that's your indaba. But please don't tell my sisters to do the same, because they're awesome. And hey, so are you - so don't you dare settle either, OK?

Quote from: ABadGuy on November 13, 2013, 03:11:50 AM
But its through these pains, or the conquering of,  that we receive clarity. And humanity. It makes us strong. It teaches us right and wrong. And, with a bit of luck, it brings us to the arms of someone we love, and someone that loves us.
Pain doesn't necessarily bring clarity, humanity, strength, nor does it teach us right from wrong. It can harm us in untold ways from which we may never recover. There is nothing noble about suffering, so suffering is not to be encouraged. Instead, we should encourage love, tolerance and respect.

Quote from: ABadGuy on November 13, 2013, 03:11:50 AM
I feel like there is a lot I left unsaid (more like ranted). And I feel like I said too much. I hope what I wrote didn't hurt anyone... And I hope you can understand why I am so upset. But  who cares... I'm just a scumbag fetishist.
I for one appreciate you taking the time (quite a bit of time, evidently) to put your thoughts down. Thank you for reaching out, and for sharing your perspective. It was interesting to read.

In my opinion, the best kind of partner for a transperson of any description is one who simply treats us as a human being. That's all we are: ordinary, everyday human beings who deserve the same love and respect as anyone else. Finding a partner who is 'whatever' about the equipment in our underwear is absolutely ideal. Finding a partner who gets thrills about us having the wrong equipment is - for many of us - totally unacceptable.





  •  

Sammy

I am sure, he will be back :). Maybe as a lurking Guest only, but he will :). Call this a female intuition ;)
  •  

DriftingCrow

Hello ABadGuy, welcome to Susan's.

I confess I didn't read your entire post because it's very long, but FTMDiaries did a nice job in contributing to the discussion. Like Cindy said, it's not a dating site here, but I just wanted to point out that you'd be welcome to join our community. We do have a Significant Other board, and we do have at least one member I am aware of who's attracted to transsexuals. We also have some cis-gender members who just come here to learn more.

See you around
ਮਨਿ ਜੀਤੈ ਜਗੁ ਜੀਤੁ
  •  

Shaina

Welcome to Susans ABadGuy  ;D

While I think FTM Diaries broke it down really well I just wanted to add that you're definitely right in thinking this a tolerant community! I hope you find some of the answers you're looking for or discover some things-like what drives sexual attraction-don't need answers.

Oh and that lady's stereotypes about guys who pursue trans women are completely false imho! However, we should consider that she's likely been the subject of stereotypes as well. Maybe everyone feels like a devil in need of sympathy sometimes-even her.

::HUGS::
I was a child and she was a child   
    In this kingdom by the sea:   
But we loved with a love that was more than love—
    I and my Annabel Lee
  •  

Devlyn

Hi ABadGuy, welcome to Susan's Place! I didn't read your whole post, but I think I have the idea. I don't care for people being called ->-bleeped-<-s or any other names in a derogatory manner. We reserve the right to land anywhere we want on the gender/sexuality spectrum, and I believe it's only fair for others to like and love people from anywhere on the spectrum they choose. So I won't give you sympathy, you don't need it. You're just another person trying to live your life, just like me. Hugs, Devlyn
  •  

aleon515

Quote from: Cindy on November 13, 2013, 04:40:56 AM


But there are some thoughts of interest. Many of us are looking for men to date. Is there anything wrong (?) in dating a man who likes you or rather is initially attracted to you because you are transgender?


I really hate to read solid blocks of posts. The font is san serif which is hard to read. So I didn't read that much. To answer to that question (and I think we could pose it either way-- man or woman and for transgender people generally). But I don't think so. I think that esp with men attracted to trans women well there is a huge deal about that and men who do that are really publicly shamed. I think the shaming is a bad thing. People have all kinds of initially attractions. Very few are purely attracted to anybody (trans or cis) for their intellect or sense of humor or whatever. Okay I didn't mena there is no attraction to these things, just that I don't think there is "pure" attraction like that. I think physical attraction exists. Being attracted to "equipment" is probably as old as human kind. We have people in our community, go to the support groups and so on, who like transmen. I don't consider them ->-bleeped-<-s. Some of these people have become pretty good alleys and obviously are caring individuals. It's just how they are wired. I think there are less desirable sorts out there too.

--Jay
  •  

eli77

There is a reason for an initial hostile reaction towards men who are specifically interested in pre- or non-operative trans women.

Many trans women are among the most disadvantaged people in society. Many of us are poor, lack strong support networks due to losing much of them in transition, and often have to deal with discrimination on a regular basis. Between all that and the dysphoria itself, many of us suffer from depression and social anxiety, and struggle with feelings of worthlessness. If you've actually looked around this forum much, you'd hardly have difficulty verifying that. This forum primarily acts as a place for support specifically because of these problems. And for some, it's the ONLY place where they can get support.

Some men exploit our disadvantaged status and emotional baggage to essentially prey on trans women. We are regularly objectified, sexually exploited, assaulted, and raped. Those who target us, often do so specifically because of our trans status. For example, the quantity of porn involving trans women is massive, and, as you pointed out, much of it involves women who have extreme constraints on their ability to consent. So we get a little jumpy around men who would just love to screw one of us. Because, to be honest, most of them are not like you (assuming you are actually anything like you claim). Most of them are not looking for a relationship. Most of them lack basic respect for us as human beings. Most of them just want to get a shot at their favourite porn first hand.

Why is this? The same society which tells us that we are wrong/bad/perverted, tells men who like us the same crap, that to desire us is perverted/fetishistic/gross. So, really, how many dudes want to take home a trans lady to their parents? It takes a certain kind of person, a certain strength of will, to push back against all the noise, all the shame that our social norms poor down on him. And he isn't forced to take action by the dysphoria like we are.

So instead of simply saying "wow, what a bitch" to that particular trans women, maybe you could consider how bloody horrific her life experiences have been to give her that perception of men who are attracted to women like her. Maybe have a little compassion for the hell that she has walked through, and respect that the only way, the ONLY WAY men like you are ever going to convince trans women that we aren't just the target of creepy dudes who want to exploit us, is to fight to make our lives easier, and our place in society more accepted, so that we are not exploited with such horrifying regularity.

The good news is that in many places things ARE getting better, and there are more trans women who are willing to accept that SOME of the men who are attracted specifically to them are not fundamentally horrible human beings. But it's a work in progress. And if you want things to change, stop getting pissed at the victims, and start trying to make things better. Anyone who gets kicked often enough is gonna start lashing out in self-defense. I'm sorry you got caught in that when maybe you don't deserve it, but I'm not really that interested in how rough things are for you. Because really, dear cis nominally-straight dude, they aren't very rough. If you want to prove you have something to offer us, learn to be an ally, work to gain our trust, and maybe that will change some minds about the guys like you.
  •  

peky

The Devil will get my sympathy if his attraction goes beyond "one night stands" can he love and make a commitment? If yes, then all my sympathies goes to him but if not, then back to hell, pun intended  >:-)
  •  

Danielle Emmalee

Even the ones that just want one night stands have my sympathy.  What loses my sympathy is if they are not upfront about that and are manipulative about it and do not respect the fact that someone might not also be looking for just a one night stand.
Discord, I'm howlin' at the moon
And sleepin' in the middle of a summer afternoon
Discord, whatever did we do
To make you take our world away?

Discord, are we your prey alone,
Or are we just a stepping stone for taking back the throne?
Discord, we won't take it anymore
So take your tyranny away!
  •  

Shaina

Quote from: Sarah7 on November 13, 2013, 06:16:09 PM
Some men exploit our disadvantaged status and emotional baggage to essentially prey on trans women. We are regularly objectified, sexually exploited, assaulted, and raped. Those who target us, often do so specifically because of our trans status. For example, the quantity of porn involving trans women is massive, and, as you pointed out, much of it involves women who have extreme constraints on their ability to consent. So we get a little jumpy around men who would just love to screw one of us. Because, to be honest, most of them are not like you (assuming you are actually anything like you claim). Most of them are not looking for a relationship. Most of them lack basic respect for us as human beings. Most of them just want to get a shot at their favourite porn first hand.

A very compelling point Sarah. Thanks for sharing I learned a lot about another perspective reading your post. :)
I was a child and she was a child   
    In this kingdom by the sea:   
But we loved with a love that was more than love—
    I and my Annabel Lee
  •  

DanicaCarin

Quote from: Cindy on November 13, 2013, 04:40:56 AM
Possibly. It is their privilege.

But there are some thoughts of interest. Many of us are looking for men to date. Is there anything wrong (?) in dating a man who likes you or rather is initially attracted to you because you are transgender?

I would say not. Men are attracted to woman and woman to men for many reasons. It is the establishment of a meaningful relationship that is important for me. Initial attraction is just that.

Cindy,

Your right! But lets not forget that there are men who "TARGET" Trans women, for their, often selfish reasons. Treating Trans women like meat, whores, & garbage! Although I identify as Lesbian, I have had many Trans women friends who have been abused by men who seek out and target Trans women. Not allowing the discussion of this "dynamic", is most definitely doing  disservice to members of Susan's who are entering the dating scene, and will with out question come across this type of person.

Are there wonderful, sweet, down right GREAT guys out there, who are attracted to Trans women? Sure! But for every one of those, there are 10 losers who will do nothing but abuse them. If Susan's is in fact a support site, then its worth possibly offending a few, in order to protect many!

The OP could be a great guy. And my warning/request is not directed at him.

Dani
  •  

DanicaCarin

I just finished a 16 hour shift, so I may not be totally "with it". I may have violated the rule of "challenging" a MOD or Susan"s rules/wishes. Let me say now that was not my intent. I have no dog in this fight, other than preventing a fellow member of Susan's from a broken heart, or worse! :-\
  •