Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

A Quaint Treatise of Brooke Renée

Started by Brooke Renee, January 15, 2024, 09:04:24 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Jessica_Rose

The first time I remember hearing about a transsexual was in an issue of 'Playboy' after the movie 'For Your Eyes Only' came out. One of the 'Bond women' in the film was Caroline Cossey (aka 'Tula'), and many were shocked when news came out that she was transsexual. It was difficult to find information on her back then, but I did buy that month's 'Playboy' just to read about her. She was also in the video for 'Some Like It Hot' by The Power Station. It's possible that little piece of information rolling around in the back of my mind for decades helped me realize that I did have a choice.

Love always -- Jess
Journal thread - Jessica's Rose Garden
National Coming Out Day video - Coming Out
GCS - GCS and BA w/Dr. Ley
GCS II - GCS II and FFS w/Dr. Ley
FFS II - Jaw and chin surgery w/Dr. Ley
Hair - Hair Restoration
23Mar2017 - HRT / 16Feb2018 - Full Time! / 21Feb2019 - GCS / 26July2019 - GCS II / 13Oct2020 - FFS II
"It is never too late to be what you might have been." - George Eliot
  • skype:Jessica_Rose?call
  •  
    The following users thanked this post: Brooke Renee

Courtney G

Thanks for sharing, Brooke. So much of what you wrote is relatable.



Pre-crash post count: >487
Pre-crash reputation: +10/-0

Courtney G

Quote from: Jessica_Rose on January 24, 2024, 11:55:44 AMThe first time I remember hearing about a transsexual was in an issue of 'Playboy' after the movie 'For Your Eyes Only' came out. One of the 'Bond women' in the film was Caroline Cossey (aka 'Tula'), and many were shocked when news came out that she was transsexual. It was difficult to find information on her back then, but I did buy that month's 'Playboy' just to read about her. She was also in the video for 'Some Like It Hot' by The Power Station. It's possible that little piece of information rolling around in the back of my mind for decades helped me realize that I did have a choice.

Love always -- Jess

I was fascinated by Tula. Of course.



Pre-crash post count: >487
Pre-crash reputation: +10/-0

CaelaNotKayla

Too often the portrayals of transgender individuals have trended towards the camp or the sensational.... great fodder for a puerile comedy or the worst that Geraldo Rivera could throw at it. I think it was probably "The World According to Garp" where I saw an unsensationalized transgender person on the silver screen. My life nowadays has much more in common with Roberta Muldoon than Dorothy Michaels for sure!

Hugs!!

Caela
"Who knew it'd be so bright without the blindfold"- Demi Lovato

Iztaccihuatl

Another movie of the 80's that had a lasting impact on me was Second Serve with Vanessa Redgrave portraying Renee Richards.

Hugs,

Heidemarie
  •  

Brooke Renee

Oh wow, @Jessica_Rose @Courtney G @CaelaNotKayla @Iztaccihuatl you all are bringing up movies that I have not thought of for many years!  A lot to add to my streaming list! 
  • skype:Brooke Renee?call
  •  

Brooke Renee

Chapter 7

It's funny how the mind works, or doesn't..  Here I was, having gone through childhood with feminine leanings where I even vocalized I wanted to be like the girls.  Then as I aged my activities were always more on the female side.  The friends I made were almost always girls, I avoided any form of male roughness. In the years that followed I explored dressing, I was fascinated when the Avon Lady visited.  When I saw clothing at the mall I was drawn to it not from arousal but from a desire to feel feminine.  I like things that were pretty, I wanted to be pretty.

I felt left out because I could not express myself the same as the girls did. 

Every one of these feelings were such powerful markers, you'd have to be the village idiot to not recognize them.  Hello village, I'd like to introduce myself, I am your new Idiot. 

The thing is I have to give myself a bit of a pass on this one.  I now know my lack of self awareness, or perhaps better phrased, lack of self acceptance was heavily shaped by my compartmentalization.  And that compartmentalization was heavily shaped by society's overt transphobia.  This in turn caused me to internalize the transphobia and fear what I may be. 

Essentially, I witnessed enough examples where a trans people were cast in a bad light I started to believe it.  This then kicked the denial and compartmentalization into overdrive where I could never allow myself to think I was trans.  There's no way I am one of those people. 

It so stupid and I feel so silly.  But remember, I was trying to sort out all of these feelings alone.  They started as a child and only grew stronger as I aged.  Unfortunately, my skills at denial increased as well. 

All of this eventually reached critical mass and created this gigantic pink explosion where everyone around was covered in shards of pastel satin and chunks of a rainbow. 

If I learned one thing to pass on to those wrestling with these thoughts is please do not do what I did.  Do not fear your feelings, do not have guilt over your feelings.  Explore them, dip your toes in the water.  You are who you are, period.  And if you are trans then you can make some decisions.  Remember, being trans is not a choice but choosing what to do with it is.

But sadly I would not learn these lessons myself for many years. 

In the mid nineties the cosmos lobbed a HUGE opportunity for self discovery at me but I never recognized it.  My wife had recently announced that she was pregnant with our first (and only) child.  Hearing the news I went into the usual panic of a new parent but as time went on I began to think about my female feelings and how that was going to work. 

While these thoughts created more panic I felt some solace in the fact that there had never been a female in my bloodline born in the US so we were certainly going to have a boy.  I never questioned why that gave me solace but it did. Maybe at the time I felt I could hide more effectively from a son versus a daughter, maybe?  The universe must have heard my thoughts because a few months later they said, "hold my beer" and we found out we were having a daughter. 

Then it hit me and hit me hard.  I was going to have a daughter, I was going to watch her grow up and experience all of the life moments that I wished I had.  She was going to live a life without hesitation as a female.  I did not resent my child, instead I just felt worse about myself. 

As it turns out, this was my first attack of Gender Dysphoria.  I had no awareness of the term Gender Dysphoria but that is exactly what this was.  Up until that moment I generally felt envious, maybe slightly depressed but this made me feel awful.  With no support structure I was ill equipped on how to process these feelings.   

  • skype:Brooke Renee?call
  •  

Iztaccihuatl

There's no way I am one of those people.

Yep - that's what I told myself all the time too.

And: Thank God that I am not trans because I'd be an ugly woman and at 6'6" I would never find any clothes that fit.

I guess I used that for over 15 years to suppress my female identity whenever it tried to peek through.

Aren't we a funny group of folks?

Hugs,

Heidemarie

D'Amalie

Quote from: Brooke Renee on January 24, 2024, 09:40:27 AMGood morning ladies.  Thank you for all of your support and kindness to keep going with this blog.  Today's Chapter will explore how our culture shaped my view of trans people and ultimately led to my own internalized transphobia. 

Chapter 6

I was born in the late sixties, came of age in the late 70s and early 80s so certainly no internet.  Being Gay or Lesbian was considered a dirty secret that you must keep to yourself, especially living where I grew up.  I don't think the word "transgender" was even a thing.

Me.

Quote from: Brooke Renee on January 24, 2024, 09:40:27 AMYou might hear someone mention the term transvestite which when spoken immediately sounds like a pathology.  All of the popular and religious culture of the time hammered that point home as well.  I grew up in the buckle of the Bible Belt and even though my family was not very religious we were definitely imbedded with an entire community that was.  We were sort of like a Where's Waldo picture.  Anyway, there just was not available resources to learn about these types of things.  Heck, merely asking a question would quickly draw unwelcome attention. 

Also me.

Quote from: Brooke Renee on January 24, 2024, 09:40:27 AMThis situation basically ceded LGBTQ+ education to daytime TV. 

In the early days it was The Phil Donahue Show, then Riki Lake, and Springer.  Basically they all followed the same recipe.  A family would come on and one of the members would use this opportunity to reveal a closely held secret.  Sometimes it would be incestuous, or an extra marital affair.  Or it might be swingers or diapers or who knows what else. 

And sometimes the family member would reveal that they wanted to be a woman. 

In every case, the conversation would de-evolve into a violent brawl where the episode climaxed with someone being hit with a chair.  Roll the credits. 

As a young and confused person with deeply concerning thoughts regarding their gender I was horrified by what I saw.  OMG, is that my future?  Considering my own violent history it seemed so. 

I saw that people with notions like mine were at BEST treated as though we had a disease where the treatment would surely involve being institutionalized.  "See!  You tried on a bra and you caught a raging case of the Transvestite!".

Again me too!

Quote from: Brooke Renee on January 24, 2024, 09:40:27 AMAt WORST folks like me were seen as deceitful, liars, criminals, perverted, and a general menace to all of society.  Cue the villagers with the torches and pitchforks.  A vision of my future frequently played out in my head:

"Hey, that's a dude wearing a skirt, get him!" 

Still a reality today!

Quote from: Brooke Renee on January 24, 2024, 09:40:27 AM"Officer, it's not a skirt, it's a Kilt"

"Yeah right, tell that to the Judge you Nancy" [/i]

Then on Halloween night of 1987 something truly magical and life changing occurred.  I met up with a bunch of Art and Theater friends at the local University and watched the midnight showing of the Rock Horror Picture Show. 

OMG, I was so happy!  I was watching a room packed full of people, many of whom in full Rocky Horror themed costumes, cheering on Dr. Frank N Furter as she pranced around the big screen in full makeup and lingerie. This was amazing!  No villagers with pitchforks, no bible thumpers, just happy people celebrating a great time. 

How did you know!  You described me!

Quote from: Brooke Renee on January 24, 2024, 09:40:27 AMIt's funny to think back, but this was my first "positive" transgender roll model.  Okay, okay.  Yes, Ms. Furter did kill Eddie with an ice axe but.. he was ill tempered AND he was riding his motorcycle in the house.  Seriously, who does that?  I think he had it comin'.

In any case, for years to come I would be front and center for subsequent Rocky Horror screenings.  Could I sing the songs and tell you the plot line?  Not really, I just sat in the audience and soaked in the notion that maybe, just maybe I was not broken or mentally ill. 

Then in 1991 Hollywood put an end to the party with the release of The Silence of the Lambs.  Overnight, the angry mobs were re-invigorated with a new villain, Buffalo Bill.  Even though Jonathan Demme has repeatedly apologized for not making it more clear that Buffalo Bill was not trans, the damage was done.  Hate crimes occurred, people were singled out.  There were probably actual villagers with actual pitchforks. 

The damage to my sense of self would also prove irreparable.  Well, maybe not irreparable but certainly an open wound for years to come.  One that would shape how I saw myself, one that would shape how I saw others like me.













[/quote]
One shouldn't open the book of another's life and jump in the middle.  I am a woman, I'm a mystery.  I still see and hear who I used to be, who I am, who I'm gonna be. - Richelle
"Where you'd learn do to that, miss?" "Just do it, that's all; ... I got natural talent." "I'll say you do, at that." - Firefly
  • skype:damalie?call
  •  

D'Amalie

I curtsy to you, while your eloquence sears my eyes.

Humbly, I offer an agregate.  Striking my soul with a simple journal entry, your recall portrays, yes stabs us, with cultural criticisms of this audience's personal realities.  Words highlight ignorance, intolerance and intransigence of our culture at best.  At worst, the words deepen angst, anger and anxiety. 

Reading this triggers my depression.  Its dragging me down.  I ache within, such an attack as I've not felt in three years.  Tears aren't meant to short my keyboard, are they?  I ask, is my journey or ours collectivelly for naught?  I'm defenseless against the onslaught.  It must be so with many of our sisters, though with lifetimes habit, we'll not tell anyone.  It's not shiny.  No.  Not Shiny at all, Captain.

Part II an hour passed -- I sat up, rose to my feet and stumbled away for a few minutes.  Brewed a coffee, gazing out upon the dreary winter landscapa a bit of a while.  Popped a modern chemical (prescribed for such events.)

Coming back to this, I reread the post.  I see where you are light hearted and merely reliving the past.  It helped me climb out of that morass of could've, would've and should've I tripped into.  Thanks for the memories.  I wish I may, I wish I might, accept the realities of my plight.
One shouldn't open the book of another's life and jump in the middle.  I am a woman, I'm a mystery.  I still see and hear who I used to be, who I am, who I'm gonna be. - Richelle
"Where you'd learn do to that, miss?" "Just do it, that's all; ... I got natural talent." "I'll say you do, at that." - Firefly
  • skype:damalie?call
  •  
    The following users thanked this post: Brooke Renee

Brooke Renee

Quote from: D'Amalie on January 26, 2024, 09:44:46 AMI curtsy to you, while your eloquence sears my eyes.

Humbly, I offer an agregate.  Striking my soul with a simple journal entry, your recall portrays, yes stabs us, with cultural criticisms of this audience's personal realities.  Words highlight ignorance, intolerance and intransigence of our culture at best.  At worst, the words deepen angst, anger and anxiety. 

Reading this triggers my depression.  Its dragging me down.  I ache within, such an attack as I've not felt in three years.  Tears aren't meant to short my keyboard, are they?  I ask, is my journey or ours collectivelly for naught?  I'm defenseless against the onslaught.  It must be so with many of our sisters, though with lifetimes habit, we'll not tell anyone.  It's not shiny.  No.  Not Shiny at all, Captain.

Part II an hour passed -- I sat up, rose to my feet and stumbled away for a few minutes.  Brewed a coffee, gazing out upon the dreary winter landscapa a bit of a while.  Popped a modern chemical (prescribed for such events.)

Coming back to this, I reread the post.  I see where you are light hearted and merely reliving the past.  It helped me climb out of that morass of could've, would've and should've I tripped into.  Thanks for the memories.  I wish I may, I wish I might, accept the realities of my plight.


Dear @D'Amalie

Thank you so much for your comments, I fear many of us have walked these thorny trails.  I went way too long without an outlet to discuss these challenges, keeping all of this angst inside has been toxic.  Finding a therapist has helped purge these ghosts and move on except, I am just not that good at talking about my life in person.  Sure, she gives me the opportunity, I mean that is what I pay her for. 

But alas I seem to always freeze up..  "you have 53 minutes to talk about your life, GO..."  Camera zooms in on Brooke staring at her shoes.. Then all that comes out is me complaining about the weather and perhaps if I am on point, a "drive by" discussion my latest GD episode.  But usually all that comes out is pointless babble akin to chatting the relative merits of whole milk to 2%. 

This is where the blog has be a God-send.  I can work through  AND purge this darkness, find humor, and most importantly find fellowship with my sisters and maybe pass on a nugget or two that will help someone. 

Later this morning I will be adding my next chapter, I promise it is getting to the point in my journey where confusion and fear are becoming replaced with joy and self acceptance.  I just needed to go through and get past my rocky beginnings. 

Offering warm loving hugs,

Brooke
  • skype:Brooke Renee?call
  •  

Brooke Renee

#31
Good morning ladies!  Please let me apologize upfront for the Great Wall of Text on this chapter.  But, several deeply meaningful events came pretty close to each other during my journey and I wanted to capture them all.  If you have read any of my previous entries I think you will agree it was my turn for some wins. 

Chapter 8

Many years have now passed since the birth of my daughter and much of the initial fear and anxiety had melted away into the daily events of homework, soccer, and holidays.  My thick walls of compartmentalization were solid.  Yeah, most of your are jumping up and down yelling "Denial" right now which is correct but keep that to yourself. 

Anyway. 

As I mentioned in previous posts, I strictly limited my feminine expression to women's undergarments. Specifically panties. I was (and still are) adamant about using the term panty over underwear at it is way more feminine to me.  Being this was my only female outlet I allowed myself, I needed it to be as feminine as possible.  You know, squeeze every drop of pink goodness from this forbidden fruit. 

So little by little I began to accumulate a collection of panties.  I don't exactly recall how my "hobby" came to light but my wife did eventually become aware.  It must not have been a thing though as we just went on with our days.  In time she even participated by purchasing panties for me.  I even recall several shopping trips where she would see something that she knew I would like and she would add it to her purchases.

eBay was also a game changer.  The magic of the internet allowed me an anxiety free shopping experience where I could browse the selections and make purchases without feeling compelled to fabricate some ridiculous cover story.  Honestly, the whole process of finding a style that I liked, choosing the right size and color, and checking out was very affirming and an effective antidote to the waves of GD.  Retail therapy right?  Ladies, you all know it works!

And because GD had become a frequent co-pilot I did a lot of retail therapy.  A lot. Hey, it was way cheaper than a therapist at 100 dollars an hour! 

In a short span of a few years my panty collection had grown to epic proportions.  Looking back and laughing, I would say a therapist might suggest an intervention.  Whatever, if not this then what?  We all know GD demands action. 

It was about this time that a conversation occurred with my wife.  I saw it coming and I dreaded the potential outcome.  We were enjoying some pillow talk one evening and she stated that she could certainly understand my desire to wear something silky, who wouldn't she added. 

Uh oh, here it comes I thought...

She then wanted to know if I liked panties because they were silky and felt nice or if I liked them because they were pretty. 

Bam.  Deer meet headlights.  Time froze as did that trickle of moisture forming on my brow.  What do I say?  Do I hazard the truth?  Oh god.  Think dang it, think! 

With a very dry mouth I coughed out the response that maybe a little of both?  Mostly silky for sure, but colors and decoration made them kind of exciting.  Maybe?  I looked away expecting the whoosh and thud of the guillotine. 

To my elation, there was no whoosh.  There was no thud.  Instead she cheerfully giggled and exclaimed "you're a crossdresser!"  I stammered an unintelligible response, not really sure if what came out of my mouth even remotely resembled words.  I think muscle memory eventual took up the slack for my stunned silence and I explained that my interest was limited to just panties.  This seemed to satisfy her curiosity and she moved on. 

That was it?!?

Maybe, just maybe, the vision of my future crafted by fear and guilt was all just a farce.  Scare tactics by my over active amygdala.  That said, she did bring up some points that landed with a thud.  She did use the word "crossdresser" and she did bring up the pretty versus silky question.  While I was not in the headspace to address the crossdresser comment to myself I did spend a lot of time thinking about the desire to seek out items that were pretty. 

Perhaps this was me taking baby steps toward a greater level of self discovery.  In any case, I acknowledged to myself that I DID want my choices to be pretty and this desire especially applied to color.  You see, male underwear comes in colors but those colors were always dark or muted.  However, panties came in pretty pastels, something you would never see the Marlboro man wearing.  Once this connection was made my mind was set.  It is funny, you could present me with a pair of black satin panties absolutely dripping with lace and I would recoil!  Those are too masculine, take them away!  Silly right?  GD poisons the brain in some weird ways. 

A few months after this conversation an event occurred that would forever change my family.  It was the summer before my daughter's Junior year in high school and she had an announcement, she came out as a lesbian. 

As a parent you notice things which I did.  I would sort of catalog them away to see what happens.  I knew when or if the time came that I would be supportive.  Very supportive.  In my mind I knew exactly how I would want the response to be if I came out.  I made darn sure to express my support in the best way possible. 

It all went down like this. 

With teary eyes, "Mom...Dad... I have to tell you something.  I'm gay". 

Us, "Babe, your mom and I love you so much and all we want is for you to be happy, where are we going for dinner." 

She smiled through her tears, we all embraced and went for pizza.  That was it. But not really. 

Shortly after "the" conversation my wife and talked, we knew we needed to make a move.  You see, at the time we were still living in the midwest.  A part of the country where our daughter would never live her best life.  My wife and I knew we needed to move and move fast.  The next day at work I located an open management position in Seattle, I called my wife up and without hesitation she said do it. 

It wasn't easy, moving never is.  But this one had purpose. We put our home on the market, broke the news to our families and I started the exhausting process of boxing up all those panties.  Really, that was a thing.  Don't judge.. 

By December of that year we had arrived in the PNW and were getting settled.  The cultural change was amazing!  We went from a town where everyone scrutinized everything and everyone to a city where "you do you" is the mantra.  I think the best (and kindest) way for me to put this is, in the Midwest they place a high value on conformity while on the West Coast, we place a high value on individuality. 

June rolled around and gave me the most emotional moment since witnessing the birth of our daughter.  As a family, we attended PRIDE in Seattle.  Seeing the tears in my daughter'e eyes as she looked around at the hundreds of thousands of people jammed in downtown Seattle, all celebrating her right to be her.  I cry as I type this.  Witnessing her find herself and find her home is the most special gift a parent could ever hope for. 

As the day aged I made some discoveries for myself too.  There were a lot of trans folk out and about.  All being accepted, all feeling love, and all expressing themselves without hesitation. 

While this experience did not erase the years of transphobic conditioning it did start to chip away at it.  About two weeks later a bright light broke through the cracks in my closet door and I ordered my first bra. 










  • skype:Brooke Renee?call
  •  
    The following users thanked this post: Maid Marion

Brooke Renee

Chapter 9

The purchase of my first bra was without question, the initial crack in shattering my carefully crafted mental walls.  To borrow a movie line one would say, "that escalated quickly".  It's true though, history has yet to witness a dam fail softly.

I was now in the headspace where I was no longer afraid of a label.  I mean, I suppose I finally overwhelmed my denial with facts. 

"Hey skillet head, you know how you have wrestled with this gender thing for like 45 years?  That's because it's a thing".  "You should probably accept it and learn about how to handle it".  Solid advice from myself to myself. I'm sure I had been lobbing those words at the person in the mirror for years and now I was able to actually hear them.  Up until that point I am sure I was just lip reading and I'm sure I thought the words were "buy another pair of khaki trousers, they're snazzy".

So off to the internet I went in search of knowledge.  No preconceived notions of where I wanted to search to lead me, just see where the facts go.  Without fear of labels I looked everywhere.  Am I a crossdresser, am I actually gay, am I transgender?  And just what is the difference between a crossdresser and one that is transgender? 

Again, I was now ready for an actual accounting of my feelings without mental boxes or guardrails.  Just peel back the breading and see if we're having chicken or fish.

Of course any safari into the internet will involve some rabbit holes.  My searches initially took me to several different forums which we all know can be a mixed bag.  Eventually I stepped away from the forums for a more medical description and analysis.  This is where I finally found my truth or maybe I should say "finally accepted my truth".  Yeah, the term "accepted" probably has 50% more truth than "found". 

Anyway. 

As I read the clinical descriptions of a crossdresser and the clinical descriptions of transgender my situation became incredibly clear.  When I read the DSM-5's metrics for diagnosing Gender Dysphoria I was floored.  According to the manual, one must experience at least two of the 6 symptoms for greater than 6 months. 

Ha!  That's funny!  I could hear my Ego pushing my ID and Superego aside yelling "hold my beer!  You've experienced all 6 of these for 40 plus years!" 

Also, and most importantly...  I learned that being transgender is NOT a pathology, the emotional distress of GD is.  There it was, right there in black and white.  From the Mayo Clinic no less, I am not broken. 

I slept so well that night.  Free of guilt, free of shame.  For the first time in my life I knew who I was.  The label did not scare me nor did it even remotely compel me to repair my broken walls of denial. 

The next morning I took my shiny new epiphany shopping and we ordered some silicone breast forms.  About a week later they had arrived.  For the first time in my life I saw my body as nature had intended, the emotional release was intense. 

Ladies, I sat on my bed and wept.  For the first time in my life I was at peace. 



  • skype:Brooke Renee?call
  •  

Jessica_Rose

Quote from: Brooke Renee on January 28, 2024, 08:15:45 AMAm I a crossdresser, am I actually gay, am I transgender?  And just what is the difference between a crossdresser and one that is transgender? 

I can't answer the first compound question, but the answer to the second question is 'usually about two years'.

Quote from: Brooke Renee on January 28, 2024, 08:15:45 AMThe next morning I took my shiny new epiphany shopping and we ordered some silicone breast forms.  About a week later they had arrived.  For the first time in my life I saw my body as nature had intended, the emotional release was intense. 

Ladies, I sat on my bed and wept.  For the first time in my life I was at peace. 

Once you understand the source of decades of pain, the emotional release can be intense. When the weight of all those years of questions and denials suddenly lifts, it's like your soul sees light after decades of darkness.

Love always -- Jessica Rose
Journal thread - Jessica's Rose Garden
National Coming Out Day video - Coming Out
GCS - GCS and BA w/Dr. Ley
GCS II - GCS II and FFS w/Dr. Ley
FFS II - Jaw and chin surgery w/Dr. Ley
Hair - Hair Restoration
23Mar2017 - HRT / 16Feb2018 - Full Time! / 21Feb2019 - GCS / 26July2019 - GCS II / 13Oct2020 - FFS II
"It is never too late to be what you might have been." - George Eliot
  • skype:Jessica_Rose?call
  •  
    The following users thanked this post: Brooke Renee

Brooke Renee

Quote from: Jessica_Rose on January 28, 2024, 09:38:39 AMI can't answer the first compound question, but the answer to the second question is 'usually about two years'.


Hi Jessica!  I so love this answer! 


Hugs,

Brooke
  • skype:Brooke Renee?call
  •  

REM.1126

Transgender is a big umbrella term.  Cross dressers are transgender, but so are transsexuals, which are what most people tend to think of as transgender. 
  •  

Brooke Renee

#36
Quote from: REM.1126 on January 28, 2024, 11:40:29 PMTransgender is a big umbrella term.  Cross dressers are transgender, but so are transsexuals, which are what most people tend to think of as transgender. 

Hi Rachel,

I think my desire during that period of self acceptance was to find nice, neat little boxes in which to categorize my feelings.  I did not care what the label was, nor did I assign value to one over the other.  That lack of value remains to this day.  Early childhood conditioning by less than honorable sources had planted plenty of misinformation in my psyche which I was committed to expelling. 

All of the research I did during those months and years of self discovery pointed toward "activity" versus "identity" as the demarcation between crossdressing and one that identifies as trans.  A common phrase I read was that one who engages in crossdressing does not experience an incongruity with the gender they are assigned at birth.  Further, most clinical descriptions I read stated a crossdresser does not experience gender dysphoria when they are unable to present in a manner consistent with their preference. 

For me, that hit the nail right on the head.  My identity is binary female, I have significant feelings of incongruity between my sense of self what lies betwixt my legs.

Now that I have more experience and education on the subject I do see that the lines are very blurry.  Sure scholars have placed "activity" and "identity" on opposite ends of the gender expression continuum but in reality, we know there is significant overlap.  This is exactly why I love Jessica's response so much!

In practice, I do not consider presenting as my gender identity as crossdressing, it's just dressing.  However, when I have to present as a man I do consider that crossdressing as that presentation is inconsistent .   

As for the term transexual.  All of my readings agree that this is an older term that originated in the medical and psychological communities that has been rejected by the transgender community due to a negative connotation. GLAAD has be a reliable source for me in navigating this minefield, I find their discussions on terms to be progressive and affirming. 

https://glaad.org/reference/trans-terms/?response_type=embed&gad_source=1&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIqP6R49uChAMVxdDCBB2n9APkEAAYBCAAEgL8gvD_BwE

Warmly,

Brooke
  • skype:Brooke Renee?call
  •  

D'Amalie

Quote from: Brooke Renee on January 29, 2024, 07:54:52 AMIn practice, I do not consider presenting as my gender identity as crossdressing, it's just dressing. 

I love this!  Like I keep saying when ever I think others may care, I dress according to my reality.  It really doesn't matter to anyone but me, or shouldn't.
One shouldn't open the book of another's life and jump in the middle.  I am a woman, I'm a mystery.  I still see and hear who I used to be, who I am, who I'm gonna be. - Richelle
"Where you'd learn do to that, miss?" "Just do it, that's all; ... I got natural talent." "I'll say you do, at that." - Firefly
  • skype:damalie?call
  •  

Brooke Renee

Quote from: D'Amalie on January 29, 2024, 11:10:28 AMI love this!  Like I keep saying when ever I think others may care, I dress according to my reality.  It really doesn't matter to anyone but me, or shouldn't.

Amen Sister! 
  • skype:Brooke Renee?call
  •  

REM.1126

Transsexual may have lost favor, but it is useful as a term because it describes something specific in contrast "transgender" which basically means gender norms don't fit me without saying how or why.
  •