Quote from: suzifrommd on May 13, 2013, 05:20:24 PM
This sounds like a load of malarkey. I'm real suspicious when I hear a psychotherapist tell a patient they're not trans. There are a lot of incompetent shrinks happily taking their patients' money and a bunch of other ones that believe that trans people need to be talked out of it. (Incompetent isn't the word for these. The only words that come to mind aren't allowed here.)
A therapist needs to allow the patient to come to their own conclusion. No one can tell you whether or not you're trans.
Of course I don't know the whole story, haven't met either one of you, but from what you'd write, I'd be very concerned.
I agree 100 percent. A mental professional is supposed to be non judgemental and allow you to come to your own conclusions.
How does a "trans" talk? Sounds like an assumption to me. Yes she may have dealt with other transgenders but there are also many variables. Geographical areas where the person grew up, what the person's family feels about ->-bleeped-<-, religious bearings, generational and about a million and a half more that I won't go into.
I will say this. In my generation and where I grew up, There is no way that I could try to convince the other children that I was a girl. I was sometimes mistaken as one but not after 11 or 12 yrs. If I would have tried, I would have been beaten everyday or worst. So I had to look, act and talk like a boy. Even with long hair but that goes with the whole guitar thing and was a really good excuse for wearing makeup if only for a little while.
Salemass, in case you don't know I will tell you. There is a tremedous difference between a psychotherapist and psychiatrist. A psychiatrist is a medical doctor. They do all the normal doctor stuff. They go to med school, do a residency and so on and then they decide to do the psychology deal. They are very knowledgable on how the brain works, but I find that they do lack on matters of the mind though. They can prescribe medicine that will help with mental problems such as depression, anxiety and so on.
A psychotherapist has a degree in strictly in Psychology. They cannot prescribe medicine but can refer you to a Psychiatrist and get you an appointment which is hard to do on your own. Pretty much they listen to you, provide feedback to what you may be able to do yourself and so on. I see a Psychotherapist and Psychiatrist. I have signed over to where the therapist can share with the doctor if I say so. My experience has been that the therapist is a lot more understanding, compassionate, asks what is bothering me, how it is affecting my life and so on. The Psychiatrist on the other hand does pretty much the same but it feels different to me and then she will explain this is what is going on with the brain, lets try this medication and see if it works and so on.
How many appoinments have you had with the Psychiatrist? You can't really get to know a person with a one hour session in order to come to a clear conclussion about that person. The only thing that I can tell you is what other's said on this thread and that is the only one that truly knows if you are transgendered or not is you.
Quote from: salemasss on May 13, 2013, 01:36:53 PM
Hello again. I mentioned somewhere else that I have OCD. I've been to my psychiatrist recently. She said that I'm not trans and all I have are intrusive thoughts. I tried to be as open as possible. She said that I don't even speak like trans person when I say "i tried to make breasts for me" or "i tried wearing women's clothes". 1 And if I were really trans I wouldn't feel so horrible when accepting thoughts that I'm a woman. I felt a relief for a few days after that. Suicidal thoughts dissapeared, but now I'm doubting again. 2.The main reason I don't want to be a transsexual is because I would lose contact with my family.3. Also when I was telling myself that I was trans I still had doubts ocasionally. I've seen films about such children and it surprised me how liitle boys weren't scared of others and tried to prove everyone that they were girls.I don't have such an experience. 4There were other reasons for doubting too, like I was begining to think I was a pedophile and I noticed that my reactions to those thoughts were similar to transsexual ones. And I remember before deciding I was a woman I smiled when some random man told that I was handsome dude. 5.What is more, when I thought I was a woman, everyday was a torture for me. I thought I wouldn't be able to work until I get hormones because I could faint easily. 6.But when I think that I'm a man I feel stronger but always doubting and questioning what I trully want. I imagine again how it will be living like a woman but I don't want let myself feel happy over those thoughts. And I don't most of the time. 7.It really tires me. I wish I was happy as a man and that those thoughts would leave me alone. Psychiatrist said that hormones won't help me relax only make me look more feminine. And she said that she has expierence with other transsexuals. Any thoughts?
A few things do bother me in your post above though.
#1 What kind of horrible feelings? I would say that I have never felt horrible, not even guilty. Sometimes somewhat selfish but not really for wishing for my own happiness instead of thinking of how it would effect my family and such. But never any "horrible feelings" other than being genetically male that is.

#2 I am transgender no matter what. I can't control that. I can choose to go through HRT or SRS or present as female or male, but I am still transgendered no matter what and that will never change and never has.
#3 It's in my post before I am breaking yours down to tiny bits. Not everyone is the same and not all experinces are the same. Those little "boys" may have extrememly supportive parents, not all of us do or did. Geographical locations may dictate that this is normal, other places this could never happen because of the old closed minded set.
#4 This statement really bothers me salemass. Make sure you tell your therapist and please maintain control and don't do anything to a child. As a matter of fact, your therapist or Psychiatrist has emergency numbers and Please call them ASAP. Don't hurt a child. Not just this statement but talking about feeling trans like you put that statement across maybe why she thinks it is intrusive thoughts. WIth this I think you need to call them ASAP and tell them about those thoughts.
#5 That is kind of worrisome too. Are you talking thinking you were a woman on a physical level or psychological level? Yes there is a level of anguish on a psychological level of wanting to change genders.
#6 Yes males are typically physically and emotionally stronger or better at hiding their emotions anyway. Yes, if you are just now coming to terms with being transgeder you may have big time doubts and confusion. Believe me hon, there is nothing to feel guilty about though thinking and wondering about being a female. Even if you are not transgendered, do you know how many cisgender people have these same thoughts and fantasies? I guarantee you, it is more the norm than the acception. Fantasies are ours, we own them. We can choose to share them or just go with them. Don't feel guilt or shame about them because it's just the way the mind works for whatever reason specific to you.
#7 I feel for you salemass. Don't let it get you down to the point that you are mentally exhausted. We have talked before and I had told you little things that you can do to make yourself feel more feminine. You don't really need the breasts or the genetals to do these little things and see how it makes you feel. Hair grows back fairly quickly if you shave your legs. growing long hair takes a while, wearing feminine underwear, no one ever has to know. I know you mentioned your dad would throw a fit, but really it is your body. The Psychiatrist is right, hormones will not make you more relaxed that is something that you have to learn to do. And with your confusion and going back and forth with feelings of being comfortable being male and wishing and wondering about being female, you really need to decide first. Keep seeing the Psychiatrist or therapist and work through the feelings. Eventually you will figure them out and then act on it accordingly.
Find some books or look on the internet about meditation. Believe me it will help with the relaxation issue. The transgender aspect, that is something you have to figure out but before doing anything like hormones and such make for certain without a doubt who you are and what you want to be. Your young so slow down, calm down and take your time because you'll have a far better outcome.