September 18, 2022
This has been a momentous week, in more than one way. While performing quite well in tennis, a number of cascading trigger events placed me in my first depression since last spring and reminded me that i'll never fit in at my club. Here's the journey that led up to a decision to declare failure and move on.
The Experiment that Failed
Two years ago, on the cusp of going full-time, i pondered here whether i should move an hour north to begin Laura's life where people wouldn't have the old me to compare to the new me. I knew the city i live in was generally not accepting of the LGBT community, so I spent several months considering my options: Stay here and hope that i'll be accepted or move north to a city more accepting. In the end, i chose to stay. The drama that ensued last year is already on these pages, but i still wasn't ready to give up. I used those experiences to try to improve myself, to be less "him" and more "Laura" on the courts. I do feel that i'm a better person now but i despite my evolution, i know it's not been enough.
We all know the classic definition of insanity, that is doing the same thing over and over hoping for different results. I tend to be someone who doesn't give up easily because i keep hoping for conditions to improve, and yet despite my evolution during the past two years, nothing has really changed at my club. I'm still an outcast who will never be accepted.
I've written about the Mixed Doubles league that i've been part of these past three months and how my partner and i have worked well together and achieved a nice level of success. There have been two parts of the league. In the first, the 14 teams played each other in a round robin with the final standings acting as ranking for the season end tournament. Last Sunday we played our 12th match against a team i thought we'd beat easily. Despite that, it was a long two-setter lasting two hours, mainly because the woman, Rose, played exceptionally well. We still won, 6-1, 6-0. After the match i hung around because other teams were playing, sitting first with Rose, who often plays in my Saturday group. She's been very friendly with me in the past, perhaps because her son is gay and she understands the challenges we in the LGBT community face. After we talked for some time, i walked over to where several other people were sitting, including Bobbi who was one of the first people i came out to three years ago. She's always been supportive. Bobbi and i talked for awhile but after i mentioned ladies interclub, she said something that triggered me. Now, i've been very thankful to have been part of the league, partially because i enjoy the competition, but also because i was missing ladies interclub because none of the women would play with me. Out of the blue, Bobbi said that she doesn't think I should be allowed to play ladies interclub. Of course, the inference was that because i'm trans, because i'm really a man, that i have an unfair advantage. I'm not a woman in her eyes. I can only extrapolate that my participation in the Mixed Doubles league should also be disallowed. These thoughts began the cascade that only got worse during the week.
Monday night we played our last match against the first place team which was undefeated (our record going in was 11-1). If we won, we'd own first place due to the tie breaker. A loss would guarantee us second place and a "bye" in the first round of the playoffs. it was a tough, three-hour match that we could have/should have won. Our loss is my fault though. I hate playing at night because it's harder for me to see the ball, ,especially with the lighting at our club, so my play was substandard compared to our other matches. that loss brought me down for a day.
On a side note, playoffs began yesterday with the Round of 16 (for which we had a bye) and the quarter finals. Our quarter final match was a grind, lasting three hours. My partner and i played poorly in the first set, surprised at the quality of play by the female who was subbing for the woman who normally plays. Despite this, we never gave up. For myself, i didn't want this journey to end because being part of the league has meant so much to me. We fought back the final two hours and despite many tough, long points, we won. The semi-finals and finals are scheduled for next Sunday. Regardless how we do, i'm still proud to have been part of this league. it's not brought me any respect from the women here, and perhaps that's one reason i've decided to move on.
Wednesday brought triggers from two sources. Ladies Interclub began that day and while three subs played for the team, i know i'll never be asked to help. Their captain knows i'm willing to sub, but i'm not one of the four people they've added to their team web site as possible subs. Am i bad person? Is my game weak? No. I'm an "other" to them. No women or men have asked me to play this year. No women, nor men asked to partner with me for interclub or the mixed league. Are my Mixed Doubles wins illegitimate because i'm not a woman in their eyes? These reminders pushed me over the edge and my depression began in full force. Making things a bit worse is that for the first time, i couldn't assemble a simple foursome for my Saturday group. Numbers began dwindling after the league began and i can only hope that some will return next week. Still, i'm reminded that despite my inviting a large group of men and women each week to my Saturday group, none of them have ever invited me to play. These past three months, this league kept me going, as i hoped others would recognize that my play has improved. With it ending, i return to my Saturday group and my friend's evening group as my only outlet.
Clearly, my experiment to stay in my city and club has failed. I've not gained any new friends, nor invited to play with anyone. To continue hoping that conditions change is only insanity.
During my Should I Stay phase, my escape from this city would be to a more liberal city an hour north. that city has a large, very successful tennis club with an active program. My other options for new tennis clubs would only end with the same results. My city has a country club with a tennis program. While expensive to join, the women there are more wealthy and hence more snobby about who participates. Some of my bullies play there. Thirty minutes north is another tennis club, also part of Interleague, but several bullies also play there (and they're part of the Interleague board that ignored my bullying). My best choice, if i hope to make a fresh start, someplace where they might clock me, yet never know about the old me, is in the city i investigated two years ago.
For now, my plans are join that club as a new experiment. I'll need to drive there to play and while that's an inconvenience, i'll never know if it's a better environment until I try. I'm still a member of my local club, so i'll continue with my Saturday group, as well as social tournaments the club. When the Mixed Doubles league restarts next spring, i hope to participate as well. I love to play partially because it's great exercise but also because i enjoy being around other players. I no longer hope for their acceptance though so i won't be encumbered by concern for their rejection. We'll see what happens next.
Thank you for your advice. You know i always appreciate it. I DO love myself now and while i have evolved in the past year be a better person on the court, you're telling me that's not enough, that my behavior on the court still isn't acceptable. yes, i know i'm still verbal, but my attitude is quite different now. There are parts of my personality i'm not willing to discard and if that's why i'll never be respected, then that's too bad. i know i've done my best and have treated everyone nicely. i know i'm a good person and if others can't see that, that is there loss. I've no doubt that many at Brenda feel the same way Bobbi does about my playing as a woman. That attitude will never change.
My staying in Modesto was an experiment. I wrote extensively two years ago about whether i should stay or go, whether i should begin life full-time in a new city where people wouldn't have access to who i used to be or if i should stay in Modesto and see if i could fit in. Certainly, this experiment has been a failure and like my last marriage where i stayed too long, hoping for different results, it's time to move on.
I'm going to join Laguna Creek and spend the next several months figuring out if i fit in there. I still plan to organize my Saturday group and participate in Brenda's socials (as well as the ladies' play days). If the Mixed Doubles league begins next spring, i'll play if Ashish will have me, but i'm done waiting for people to come around. Insanity is doing the same thing over and over hoping for a different result.
Laura